Exhibit 2- TPA ComparisonRate Fee Rate Fee Rate Fee Rate Fee Rate Fee
Medical Only 90 160.00$ 14,400.00$ 160.00$ 14,400.00$ 160.00$ 14,400.00$ 135.00$ 12,150.00$
Indemnity (TX)40 899.00$ 35,960.00$ 995.00$ 39,800.00$ 960.00$ 38,400.00$ 725.00$ 29,000.00$
Record Only 2 30.00$ 60.00$ 49.00$ 98.00$ 40.00$ 80.00$ 25.00$ 50.00$
WC Subtotal 132
Bodily Injury 28 699.00$ 19,572.00$ 750.00$ 21,000.00$ 795.00$ 22,260.00$
Prop. Damage 162 349.00$ 56,538.00$ 375.00$ 60,750.00$ 400.00$ 64,800.00$
Record/Incident Only 2 30.00$ 60.00$ 49.00$ 98.00$ 40.00$ 80.00$
Auto Subtotal 192 -$ -$
Total Claim Fees 324
3 IDs 5,000.00$ 3 IDs 3,500.00$ 4 IDs Included 2 IDs Included 3 IDs 3,000.00$
Claim Reporting (telephonic, web or e-
Fax)324 $20 6,480.00$ $0 -$ $0 -$ $0 -$ $0
Total Admin Fees
Total Estimated Fees
WC only $67,700.00 WC Only $66,298.00 WC Only $60,880.00 WC Only $66,500.00 WC Only $47,200.00
Workers' Compensation
Medical only 16 99$ 1,584$ 75$ 1,200$ -$ -$ 75$ 1,200$
Lost Time 32 599$ 19,168$ 575$ 18,400$ 480$ 15,360$ 195$ 6,240$
Data (one-time)5,000$ 5,000$ 7,500$ 7,500$ -$ -$ -$ -$
Total 25,752$ 27,100$ 15,360$ -$ 7,440$
Note:Data costs do not include outgoing data feed from TPS.
No quote for AL, GL or property
Offering 3 year deal with no increase until 2023
Offering only 3 claim reviews annually
Per Bill
No additional charge
Not quoted
Ancillary Services
Estimated Takeover (WC only)
NA NA
Flat Fee of $59,500
Not Quoted
41,200.00$ 59,500.00$
Not Quoted Not Quoted
AS&G has not quoted AL, GL or property
AS&G PMA
$8.00 $8.50
Medical only defined as <$3,000
Not stated 27%
Not stated 27%
$7,000.00
$3,000.00
$6,000.00
Claim Handling Fees - (New Claims only)
$7,000
** Life of Contract
Administration
Implementation Fee Included Included $3,000.00
$17,280.00 $12,000.00 $5,000.00
126,590.00$ 136,146.00$ 140,020.00$
AS&G PMA
City of Denton
TPA Claim Handling Comparison
Broadspire Gallagher Bassett Sedgwick
Automobile
76,170.00$ 81,848.00$ 87,140.00$
** Estimated Claim Volume
Workers' Compensation
50,420.00$ 54,298.00$ 52,880.00$
Annual Administration Fee $5,800.00 $8,500.00 $5,000.00
RMIS Fee
$143,870.00 $148,146.00 $145,020.00
Managed Care Options
$7.75 $9.50 $8.25
PPO Hospital and Outpatient Care Networks 27%28%$8.25 + $11.50
Other Ancillary Services
Out of Network 27%28%$8.25 + $11.50
Nurse Triage Not Quoted Not Quoted Not Quoted
504 quoted through Novare
Takeover cost includedKey Differences
Broadspire Gallagher Bassett Sedgwick
3 year deal at 2% year 2 and 2% year 3 Willing to take Rodriguex as one off
Estimated Frequency
Offering a 504 Provider panel
Excellent takeover pricing (see below)
Medical only defined as <$5,000
Offering HCN (1305 provider penal)
Quoted higher on bill review
Medical only defined as <$3,000
Most competitive bill review pricing