7714 GMP1 - Subcontractor Scoring Summary7714 CMAR for SED-B
Subcontractor Scoring Summary for GMP 1
Work Category 1: Asphalt Paving
Jagoe Public Eurovia Texas Bit Reynolds Asphalt
Proposed Construction Price 40 40 32.5 26.6 5.5
Safety, Accident Rates and OSHA Record 20 20 20 20 20
Schedule and Planning 15 15 15 15 15
Financial Strength 10 10 10 10 10
Qualifications / Experience / References 15 15 15 15 10
TOTAL 100 100 92.5 86.6 60.5
Jagoe Public was both the low bidder
and the best value selection.
Work Category 2: Earthwork
McCarthy
Proposed Construction Price 40 40
Safety, Accident Rates and OSHA Record 20 20
Schedule and Planning 15 15
Financial Strength 10 10
Qualifications / Experience / References 15 15
TOTAL 100 100
McCarthy was both the low bidder and
the best value selection.
7714 CMAR for SED-B
Subcontractor Scoring Summary for GMP 1
Work Category 3: Concrete
McCarthy Beam
Proposed Construction Price 40 40 31.8
Safety, Accident Rates and OSHA Record 20 20 0
Schedule and Planning 15 15 0
Financial Strength 10 10 10
Qualifications / Experience / References 15 15 0
TOTAL 100 100 41.8
McCarthy was both the low bidder and
the best value selection.
Work Category 4: Traffic Control
Barricades
Unlimited Eagle Barricade McCarthy
Proposed Construction Price 40 40 0.7 37
Safety, Accident Rates and OSHA Record 20 10 15 20
Schedule and Planning 15 15 15 15
Financial Strength 10 10 10 10
Qualifications / Experience / References 15 15 15 15
TOTAL 100 90 55.7 97
Barricades Unlimited was the low
bidder but McCarthy was the best value
contractor, based on strict adherence to
the scoring criteria outlined in the Front
End Documents.
7714 CMAR for SED-B
Subcontractor Scoring Summary for GMP 1
Work Category 5: Utilities
John Burns Inc. North Texas Cont. Fort Worth Civil
Proposed Construction Price 40 36.4 40 29.5
Safety, Accident Rates and OSHA Record 20 20 20 20
Schedule and Planning 15 15 15 5
Financial Strength 10 10 10 10
Qualifications / Experience / References 15 10 15 15
TOTAL 100 91.4 100 79.5
North Texas Contracting was both the low bidder and the best value selection.