Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Exhibit 2 - Pricing Evaluation
Line #Description QTY UOM Unit Extended Unit Extended Unit Extended Unit Extended Unit Extended Unit Extended Unit Extended Unit Extended 1 BREAKER UW410 & DIGITAL FAULT RECORDER PANEL 1 EA $63,047.00 $63,047.00 $75,730.00 $75,730.00 $77,932.09 $77,932.09 $69,480.00 $69,480.00 $49,759.00 $49,759.00 $86,199.00 $86,199.00 $78,205.97 $78,205.97 $78,432.00 $78,432.00 2 BREAKER UW420 & BUS C DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $25,495.00 $25,495.00 $22,955.00 $22,955.00 $22,745.96 $22,745.96 $28,090.00 $28,090.00 $28,137.00 $28,137.00 $27,295.00 $27,295.00 $31,296.94 $31,296.94 $35,241.00 $35,241.00 3 BREAKER UW430 PANEL 1 EA $16,134.00 $16,134.00 $17,231.00 $17,231.00 $17,510.47 $17,510.47 $17,774.00 $17,774.00 $21,762.00 $21,762.00 $17,459.00 $17,459.00 $20,322.83 $20,322.83 $28,462.00 $28,462.00 4 BREAKER UW440 & BUS B DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $25,495.00 $25,495.00 $22,989.00 $22,989.00 $22,745.96 $22,745.96 $28,090.00 $28,090.00 $28,137.00 $28,137.00 $27,295.00 $27,295.00 $31,296.94 $31,296.94 $35,241.00 $35,241.00 5 BREAKER UW460 & DENTON WEST LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $21,833.00 $21,833.00 $21,099.00 $21,099.00 $20,765.12 $20,765.12 $24,056.00 $24,056.00 $25,390.00 $25,390.00 $23,614.00 $23,614.00 $27,404.05 $27,404.05 $31,802.00 $31,802.00 6 BREAKER UW470 & BUS A DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $25,495.00 $25,495.00 $22,989.00 $22,989.00 $22,745.96 $22,745.96 $28,090.00 $28,090.00 $27,522.00 $27,522.00 $25,925.00 $25,925.00 $31,296.94 $31,296.94 $35,241.00 $35,241.00 7 BREAKER UW480 & R.D. WELLS LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $21,833.00 $21,833.00 $21,099.00 $21,099.00 $20,765.17 $20,765.17 $24,056.00 $24,056.00 $25,459.00 $25,459.00 $23,614.00 $23,614.00 $28,146.63 $28,146.63 $32,048.00 $32,048.00 8 BREAKER UW210/UW211/UW212 PANEL 1 EA $16,947.00 $16,947.00 $16,455.00 $16,455.00 $17,023.17 $17,023.17 $18,671.00 $18,671.00 $22,340.00 $22,340.00 $17,344.00 $17,344.00 $22,441.61 $22,441.61 $20,501.00 $20,501.00 9 BREAKER UW213/UW214/UW215 PANEL 1 EA $19,090.00 $19,090.00 $13,575.00 $13,575.00 $17,883.82 $17,883.82 $21,032.00 $21,032.00 $23,273.00 $23,273.00 $18,759.00 $18,759.00 $24,771.29 $24,771.29 $22,094.00 $22,094.00 10 TRANSFORMER T1 METERING PANEL 1 EA $12,035.00 $12,035.00 $15,063.00 $15,063.00 $14,575.45 $14,575.45 $13,256.00 $13,256.00 $15,245.00 $15,245.00 $13,583.00 $13,583.00 $14,053.65 $14,053.65 $22,935.00 $22,935.00 11 TRANSFORMER T1 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $20,180.00 $20,180.00 $20,583.00 $20,583.00 $18,965.53 $18,965.53 $22,233.00 $22,233.00 $28,070.00 $28,070.00 $21,938.00 $21,938.00 $29,179.28 $29,179.28 $20,322.00 $20,322.00 12 TRANSFORMER T1 DISTRIBUTION DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $21,485.00 $21,485.00 $22,155.00 $22,155.00 $20,744.69 $20,744.69 $23,674.00 $23,674.00 $25,933.00 $25,933.00 $25,287.00 $25,287.00 $25,812.15 $25,812.15 $21,285.00 $21,285.00 13 BREAKER UW220/UW221/UW222 PANEL 1 EA $16,947.00 $16,947.00 $16,455.00 $16,455.00 $17,023.17 $17,023.17 $18,671.00 $18,671.00 $22,364.00 $22,364.00 $17,347.00 $17,347.00 $22,441.61 $22,441.61 $21,385.00 $21,385.00 14 BREAKER UW223/UW224/UW225 PANEL 1 EA $19,090.00 $19,090.00 $17,121.00 $17,121.00 $17,883.82 $17,883.82 $21,032.00 $21,032.00 $23,273.00 $23,273.00 $18,754.00 $18,754.00 $24,771.29 $24,771.29 $44,188.00 $44,188.00 15 TRANSFORMER T2 METERING PANEL 1 EA $12,035.00 $12,035.00 $10,855.00 $10,855.00 $14,575.45 $14,575.45 $13,256.00 $13,256.00 $15,245.00 $15,245.00 $14,968.00 $14,968.00 $14,053.65 $14,053.65 $22,935.00 $22,935.00 16 TRANSFORMER T2 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $20,180.00 $20,180.00 $20,003.00 $20,003.00 $18,965.53 $18,965.53 $22,233.00 $22,233.00 $28,070.00 $28,070.00 $21,938.00 $21,938.00 $29,179.28 $29,179.28 $20,322.00 $20,322.00 17 TRANSFORMER T2 DISTRIBUTION DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $21,485.00 $21,485.00 $22,198.00 $22,198.00 $20,744.69 $20,744.69 $23,674.00 $23,674.00 $25,933.00 $25,933.00 $25,223.00 $25,223.00 $25,812.15 $25,812.15 $21,717.00 $21,717.00 18 TRANSMISSION HMI PANEL 1 EA $5,863.00 $5,863.00 $14,174.00 $14,174.00 $14,270.65 $14,270.65 $7,632.00 $7,632.00 $10,853.00 $10,853.00 $12,168.00 $12,168.00 $10,484.56 $10,484.56 $28,683.00 $28,683.00 19 DISTRIBUTION HMI PANEL 1 EA $5,863.00 $5,863.00 $10,684.00 $10,684.00 $14,270.65 $14,270.65 $7,632.00 $7,632.00 $10,853.00 $10,853.00 $12,168.00 $12,168.00 $10,484.56 $10,484.56 $28,672.00 $28,672.00 20 BREAKER DW8090 & UNDERWOOD LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $21,204.00 $21,204.00 $20,974.00 $20,974.00 $19,532.83 $19,532.83 $23,364.00 $23,364.00 $25,996.00 $25,996.00 $21,072.00 $21,072.00 $27,003.90 $27,003.90 $21,565.00 $21,565.00 21 BREAKER DW8120 & PONDER LINE #1 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $19,472.00 $19,472.00 $20,698.00 $20,698.00 $19,186.09 $19,186.09 $21,454.00 $21,454.00 $25,899.00 $25,899.00 $20,710.00 $20,710.00 $26,306.17 $26,306.17 $21,363.00 $21,363.00 22 BREAKER DW8130 PANEL 1 EA $13,731.00 $13,731.00 $17,246.00 $17,246.00 $16,905.20 $16,905.20 $15,126.00 $15,126.00 $21,988.00 $21,988.00 $15,635.00 $15,635.00 $18,476.67 $18,476.67 $23,068.00 $23,068.00 23 BREAKER DW8140 & PONDER LINE #2 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $19,472.00 $19,472.00 $20,698.00 $20,698.00 $19,186.09 $19,186.09 $21,454.00 $21,454.00 $25,899.00 $25,899.00 $20,709.00 $20,709.00 $26,306.17 $26,306.17 $21,362.00 $21,362.00 24 BREAKER R410 & UNDERWOOD LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $21,204.00 $21,204.00 $20,975.00 $20,975.00 $19,532.83 $19,532.83 $23,364.00 $23,364.00 $26,397.00 $26,397.00 $21,072.00 $21,072.00 $27,003.90 $27,003.90 $21,745.00 $21,745.00 25 Jim Christal Substation Panels 26 SWITCHGEAR BUILDING HMI PANEL 2 EA $6,930.00 $13,860.00 $8,570.00 $17,140.00 $12,384.53 $24,769.06 $6,454.00 $12,908.00 $8,983.00 $17,966.00 $9,462.34 $18,924.68 $8,288.08 $16,576.16 $6,992.50 $13,985.00 27 9RU STEEL PANEL PLATE WITH MONITOR AND KVM CUTOUT 4 EA $495.00 $1,980.00 $380.00 $1,520.00 $0.01 $0.04 $2,077.00 $8,308.00 $250.00 $1,000.00 $87.50 $350.00 $65.47 $261.88 $0.01 $0.04 Item # 1 2 3 4 Exhibit 2 RFP 8712 - Pricing Evaluation for Supply of Protective Relay Panels for Multiple Substations Respondent's Business Name:Principal Place of Business (City and State): Total Score: Evaluation Underwood Substation Relay Panels Denton West Interchange Relay Panels RD Wells Substation Relay Panel Miscellaneous Total:$569,350.68 $643,390.23 $694,594.04$501,455.00 $522,664.00 $531,249.49 $558,610.00 $602,763.00 MVA Power Relay & Power Systems, Inc.KeasleSalesLLCSchweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc. Texas Electric Cooperatives J.H. Davidson & Associates, LLC Integrated Power ServicesControl Panels USA, Inc. Shreveport, LA Austin, TX Georgetown, TX Austin, TXLeonard, TX Unit Pricing - PRICING SHALL BE QUOTED TO INCLUDE ALL COSTS, WITH SHIPPING FOB DESTINATION Include Delivery (Weeks ARO) Conshohocken, PZMontreal, QC McKinney, TX Standard Criteria Delivery/Project Schedule- 15% Compliance with Specifications - 25% Probable Performance - 10% Price, Total Cost of Ownership - 50% Schweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc.Integrated Power Services Texas Electric Cooperatives J.H. Davidson & Associates, LLC 47.2 80.20 9.00 15.00 10.00 44.88 78.88 9.00 15.00 8.00 41.6 84.00 Control Panels USA, Inc. 12.00 15.00 8.00 48.88 83.88 9.00 15.00 10.00 50.00 12.00 15.00 6.00 MVA Power Relay & Power Systems, Inc.KeasleSalesLLC 9.00 15.00 8.00 73.60 6.00 15.00 8.00 44.04 73.04 38.97 70.97 6.00 15.00 10.00 36.1 67.10 Line #Description QTY UOM 1 BREAKER UW410 & DIGITAL FAULT RECORDER PANEL 1 EA 2 BREAKER UW420 & BUS C DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 3 BREAKER UW430 PANEL 1 EA 4 BREAKER UW440 & BUS B DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 5 BREAKER UW460 & DENTON WEST LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 6 BREAKER UW470 & BUS A DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 7 BREAKER UW480 & R.D. WELLS LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 8 BREAKER UW210/UW211/UW212 PANEL 1 EA 9 BREAKER UW213/UW214/UW215 PANEL 1 EA 10 TRANSFORMER T1 METERING PANEL 1 EA 11 TRANSFORMER T1 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 12 TRANSFORMER T1 DISTRIBUTION DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 13 BREAKER UW220/UW221/UW222 PANEL 1 EA 14 BREAKER UW223/UW224/UW225 PANEL 1 EA 15 TRANSFORMER T2 METERING PANEL 1 EA 16 TRANSFORMER T2 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 17 TRANSFORMER T2 DISTRIBUTION DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 18 TRANSMISSION HMI PANEL 1 EA 19 DISTRIBUTION HMI PANEL 1 EA 20 BREAKER DW8090 & UNDERWOOD LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 21 BREAKER DW8120 & PONDER LINE #1 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 22 BREAKER DW8130 PANEL 1 EA 23 BREAKER DW8140 & PONDER LINE #2 DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 24 BREAKER R410 & UNDERWOOD LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA 25 Jim Christal Substation Panels 26 SWITCHGEAR BUILDING HMI PANEL 2 EA 27 9RU STEEL PANEL PLATE WITH MONITOR AND KVM CUTOUT 4 EA Item # 1 2 3 4 Exhibit 2 RFP 8712 - Pricing Evaluation for Supply of Protective Relay Panels for Multiple Substations Respondent's Business Name:Principal Place of Business (City and State): Total Score: Evaluation Underwood Substation Relay Panels Denton West Interchange Relay Panels RD Wells Substation Relay Panel Miscellaneous Total: Unit Pricing - PRICING SHALL BE QUOTED TO INCLUDE ALL COSTS, WITH SHIPPING FOB DESTINATION Include Delivery (Weeks ARO) Standard Criteria Delivery/Project Schedule- 15% Compliance with Specifications - 25% Probable Performance - 10% Price, Total Cost of Ownership - 50% Unit Extended Unit Extended Unit Extended $28,692.00 $28,692.00 $81,979.00 $81,979.00 $93,980.00 $93,980.00 $34,231.00 $34,231.00 $30,075.00 $30,075.00 $40,670.00 $40,670.00 $27,681.00 $27,681.00 $24,712.00 $24,712.00 $34,710.00 $34,710.00 $35,523.00 $35,523.00 $30,075.00 $30,075.00 $40,670.00 $40,670.00 $31,595.00 $31,595.00 $27,799.00 $27,799.00 $38,180.00 $38,180.00 $34,359.00 $34,359.00 $30,075.00 $30,075.00 $40,670.00 $40,670.00 $31,651.00 $31,651.00 $27,799.00 $27,799.00 $38,180.00 $38,180.00 $28,483.00 $28,483.00 $22,970.00 $22,970.00 $34,750.00 $34,750.00 $31,063.00 $31,063.00 $25,039.00 $25,039.00 $35,830.00 $35,830.00 $25,127.00 $25,127.00 $18,342.00 $18,342.00 $31,990.00 $31,990.00 $36,564.00 $36,564.00 $25,810.00 $25,810.00 $41,180.00 $41,180.00 $29,659.00 $29,659.00 $27,573.00 $27,573.00 $38,280.00 $38,280.00 $28,483.00 $28,483.00 $22,970.00 $22,970.00 $34,750.00 $34,750.00 $30,740.00 $30,740.00 $25,039.00 $25,039.00 $35,830.00 $35,830.00 $25,127.00 $25,127.00 $18,342.00 $18,342.00 $31,990.00 $31,990.00 $36,564.00 $36,564.00 $25,810.00 $25,810.00 $41,400.00 $41,400.00 $29,659.00 $29,659.00 $27,573.00 $27,573.00 $38,280.00 $38,280.00 $22,114.00 $22,114.00 $17,534.00 $17,534.00 $30,380.00 $30,380.00 $22,114.00 $22,114.00 $17,534.00 $17,534.00 $30,380.00 $30,380.00 $27,595.00 $27,595.00 $26,609.00 $26,609.00 $37,280.00 $37,280.00 $27,185.00 $27,185.00 $26,949.00 $26,949.00 $36,840.00 $36,840.00 $22,570.00 $22,570.00 $20,576.00 $20,576.00 $33,590.00 $33,590.00 $27,184.00 $27,184.00 $26,949.00 $26,949.00 $36,840.00 $36,840.00 $31,075.00 $31,075.00 $26,609.00 $26,609.00 $37,280.00 $37,280.00 $16,894.00 $33,788.00 $28,976.00 $57,952.00 $28,530.00 $57,060.00 $450.00 $1,800.00 $280.00 $1,120.00 $2,250.00 $9,000.00 Exhibit 2 RFP 8712 - Pricing Evaluation for Supply of Protective Relay Panels for Multiple Substations Evaluation $999,990.00 Underwood Substation Relay Panels Denton West Interchange Relay Panels RD Wells Substation Relay Panel Miscellaneous $740,626.00 $713,814.00 Equagen Engineers PLLC United Electric Systems Inc Crown Technical Systems Unit Pricing - PRICING SHALL BE QUOTED TO INCLUDE ALL COSTS, WITH SHIPPING FOB DESTINATION Include Delivery (Weeks ARO) Allentown, PA Fontana, CA Raleigh, NC Equagen Engineers PLLC United Electric Systems Inc Crown Technical Systems 12.00 15.00 6.00 33.85 66.85 12.00 15.00 4.00 35.13 66.13 12.00 15.00 8.00 25.07 60.07