Exhibit 2 - Pricing EvaluationStuart C. Irby Company, LLC Techline, Inc.
Fort Worth, TX Fort Worth, TX
Line #Description Mfgr QTY UOM Unit Unit
2 3000A, 138kV Circuit Breaker, 40kA SIEMENS 2 EA $154,783.00 $158,040.00
3 3000A, 138kV Circuit Breaker, 63kA SIEMENS 10 EA $233,355.00 $237,250.00
4 4000A, 138kV Circuit Breaker, 63kA (12 BCTs -2000:5)SIEMENS 12 EA $255,625.00 $261,005.00
5 4000A, 345kV Circuit Breaker, 63kA (12 BCTs -3000:5)SIEMENS 8 EA $661,740.00 $675,515.00
6 4000A, 138kV Circuit Breaker, 63kA (12 BCTs -3000:5)SIEMENS 1 EA $261,000.00 $261,005.00
7 3000A, 138kV Circuit Breaker, 40kA MITSUBISHI 2 EA No Bid No Bid
8 3000A, 138kV Circuit Breaker, 50kA MITSUBISHI 10 EA No Bid No Bid
9 4000A, 138kV Circuit Breaker, 50kA MITSUBISHI 12 EA No Bid No Bid
10 4000A, 345kV Circuit Breaker, 50kA MITSUBISHI 8 EA No Bid No Bid
12 Add (2) SEL-421 Merging Units with Wiring as shown in Spec.12 Per Breaker No Bid No Bid
14 Y-Relay 1 EA $720.00 $685.00
15 Close Coil 1 EA $610.00 $580.00
16 Trip Coil 1 EA $610.00 $580.00
17 Charging Motor 1 EA $1,330.00 $1,265.00
18 Cabinet Heater 3 EA No Bid No Bid
20 Porcelain Bushings (145kV)1 EA $2,160.00 $2,050.00
Item #Stuart C. Irby Company, LLC Techline, Inc.
1 12.00 12.00
2 12.00 12.00
3 14.67 14.67
4 40.00 39.01
78.67 77.68Total Score:
SECTION I - CIRCUIT BREAKERS - SIEMENS
SECTION II - CIRCUIT BREAKERS - MITSUBISHI
SECTION III - 61850 OPTION
SECTION IV - MAINTENANCE PARTS
SECTION V - RECOMMENDED SPARE PARTS
Scoring Criteria
Delivery/Project Schedule - 20%
Compliance with Specifications - 20%
Probable Performance - 20%
Price, Total Cost of Ownership - 40%
Respondent's Business Name:
Principal Place of Business (City and State):
Exhibit 2
RFP 8836 - Pricing Evaluation for Electric Utility High Voltage Circuit Breakers
Evaluation