Exhibit 2 - Pricing EvaluationLine #Description QTY UOM Unit Extended
Delivery
ARO
(Weeks)
Unit Extended
Delivery
ARO
(Weeks)
Unit Extended
Delivery
ARO
(Weeks)
Unit Extended
Delivery
ARO
(Weeks)
1
2
3 BUS A DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $12,278.00 $12,278.00 12 $12,149.00 $12,149.00 16 $13,157.00 $13,157.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
4 BUS B DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $12,278.00 $12,278.00 12 $12,149.00 $12,149.00 16 $13,157.00 $13,157.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
5 BUS C DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $12,278.00 $12,278.00 12 $12,149.00 $12,149.00 16 $13,157.00 $13,157.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
6 BUS D DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $12,278.00 $12,278.00 12 $12,149.00 $12,149.00 16 $13,157.00 $13,157.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
7 BREAKER 4010 WOODROW LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $11,644.00 $11,644.00 12 $11,605.00 $11,605.00 16 $12,061.00 $12,061.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
8 BREAKER 4020 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $10,139.00 $10,139.00 12 $10,769.00 $10,769.00 16 $11,028.00 $11,028.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
9 BREAKER 4030 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $9,125.00 $9,125.00 12 $9,771.00 $9,771.00 16 $11,176.00 $11,176.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
10 BREAKER 4040 SPENCER INTERCHANGE LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $11,644.00 $11,644.00 12 $11,605.00 $11,605.00 16 $12,061.00 $12,061.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
11 BREAKER 4050 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $7,829.00 $7,829.00 12 $8,598.00 $8,598.00 16 $9,317.00 $9,317.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
12 BREAKER 4110 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $9,125.00 $9,125.00 12 $9,771.00 $9,771.00 16 $11,176.00 $11,176.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
13 BREAKER 4120 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $10,139.00 $10,139.00 12 $10,692.00 $10,692.00 16 $11,002.00 $11,002.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
14 BREAKER 4130 MCKINNEY LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $11,644.00 $11,644.00 12 $11,596.00 $11,596.00 16 $12,061.00 $12,061.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
15 BREAKER 4310 COOPER CREEK LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $11,644.00 $11,644.00 12 $11,605.00 $11,605.00 16 $12,061.00 $12,061.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
16 BREAKER 4320 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $7,829.00 $7,829.00 12 $8,409.00 $8,409.00 16 $9,317.00 $9,317.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
17 BREAKER 4340 SPENCER INTERCHANGE LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $11,644.00 $11,644.00 12 $11,605.00 $11,605.00 16 $12,061.00 $12,061.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
18 BREAKER 4350 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $7,829.00 $7,829.00 12 $8,400.00 $8,400.00 16 $12,061.00 $12,061.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
19 BREAKER 4440 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $10,139.00 $10,139.00 12 $10,718.00 $10,718.00 16 $11,028.00 $11,028.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
20 BREAKER 4450 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $11,020.00 $11,020.00 12 $10,429.00 $10,429.00 16 $11,315.00 $11,315.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
21 BREAKER 4460 SPENCER INTERCHANGE LINE DIFFERENTIAL PANEL 1 EA $11,644.00 $11,644.00 12 $11,605.00 $11,605.00 16 $11,028.00 $11,028.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
22 BREAKER 4500 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $8,805.00 $8,805.00 12 $8,805.00 $8,805.00 16 $10,174.00 $10,174.00 12 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
23 BREAKER 4510 CONTROL PANEL 1 EA $8,745.00 $8,745.00 12 $9,104.00 $9,104.00 16 $9,317.00 $9,317.00 14 $16,050.00 $16,050.00 16
24 CONTROL BUILDING #1 HMI PANEL 1 EA $5,260.00 $5,260.00 12 $6,856.00 $6,856.00 16 $8,779.00 $8,779.00 14 $13,075.00 $13,075.00 12
25 CONTROL BUILDING #2 HMI PANEL 1 EA $5,260.00 $5,260.00 12 $6,856.00 $6,856.00 16 $8,779.00 $8,779.00 12 $13,075.00 $13,075.00 12
26
26.1
26.2
26.3
26.4
26.4
26.6
26.7
26.7
Item #
1
2
3
4
Location of Fabricating Facility? City and State
If the fabricator is foreign, state the name and location of the facility in the US that will be used in
the event that repairs or corrections are necessary:
Relay Panel fabrication experience (years):
Lead Time for Brinker Substation Panels identified in the Technical Specifications ARO (weeks):
Number of similar relay panel projects shipped in the last 18 months:
KD Johnson / SEL Electrical Power Products, Inc.KVA Inc.Panelmatic Inc.
Pricing Sheet for Supply of Protective Relay Panels for Brinker Substation The respondent shall complete the following section, which directly corresponds to the Scope of Services, Payment and Performance Requirements.
Fabricator Name
KD Johnson / SEL
Exhibit 2
RFP 7428 - Pricing Evaluation for Brinker Relay Panels
SECTION I - Unit Pricing: Pricing shall be quoted to include all costs, with shipping F.O.B. Destination.
SECTION II - Qualifications:
Leonard, TX Des Moines, IA
KVA Inc.Panelmatic Inc.
Houston, TXGreer, SC
Electrical Power Products, Inc.
32
16
72
In the past 18 month, percentage of shipments that did not ship on time (%):
In the past 18 month, average delay for shipments that did not ship on time (days):
200
0%
0
12, SEL can do 10 weeks if ABB
LEDs are sent to site to be installed
by others and IFC with PO
18%4.5%0%
7 6 0
1,391 200
Respondent's Business Name:
Principal Place of Business (City and State):
Same location as above or Pullman,
WA
Des Moines, IA 50321San Luis Potosi, SLP, Mexico GREER, SC Houston, TX
N/A N/A
17
0 16
18
N/A
Total Score:
$230,220.00 $237,395.00 $258,430.00
Probable Performance (10%)9
94
14
84.8 83.5
Complicance with specifications (25%)
KD Johnson / SEL Electrical Power Products, Inc.KVA Inc.Panelmatic Inc.
50
15
20
48.5 44.5 31.7
11.3
Description
71.2
Evaluation
20
11.5
18 18 20
7 7 8
$363,200.00Total:
Price/Total Cost (50%)
Project Delivery (15%)