Loading...
Exhibit 2 - Evaluation SheetApproved Firms with a score above 80 are highlighted Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Carollo Engineers, Inc.1 89.60 20.00 27.60 25.20 16.80 Freese and Nichols, Inc.2 87.60 18.40 26.40 25.20 17.60 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.3 84.00 16.80 27.60 22.80 16.80 Black & Veatch Corporation 4 81.60 17.60 25.20 22.80 16.00 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.5 77.20 16.00 25.20 21.60 14.40 Garver, LLC 6 76.00 13.60 21.60 24.00 16.80 HDR Engineering, Inc.7 73.60 15.20 22.80 20.40 15.20 Lockwood, Andrews & Newnam, Inc.8 73.60 16.80 21.60 21.60 13.60 Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc.9 71.60 16.80 20.40 19.20 15.20 RPS Infrastructure, Inc.10 71.20 13.60 21.60 21.60 14.40 Arcadis U.S., Inc.11 70.40 15.20 18.00 22.80 14.40 Ardurra Group, Inc.12 68.80 14.40 21.60 19.20 13.60 LJA Engineering, Inc.13 68.80 13.60 22.80 20.40 12.00 KSA Engineers, Inc.14 66.80 14.40 18.00 21.60 12.80 Hazen and Sawyer, PC 15 66.40 15.20 20.40 18.00 12.80 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 16 52.40 8.80 15.60 16.80 11.20 RJN Group Inc 17 51.20 8.80 16.80 14.40 11.20 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Water & Wastewater Modelling & Hydraulics Exhibit 2 Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.1 86.40 16.80 27.60 25.20 16.80 Plummer Associates, Inc.2 86.00 18.40 26.40 25.20 16.00 Freese and Nichols, Inc.3 84.00 16.00 26.40 24.00 17.60 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.4 83.60 17.60 25.20 24.00 16.80 RPS Infrastructure, Inc.5 82.80 16.80 25.20 24.00 16.80 Carollo Engineers, Inc.6 82.40 17.60 25.20 22.80 16.80 HDR Engineering, Inc.7 80.40 17.60 26.40 20.40 16.00 Gresham, Smith and Partners 8 72.40 13.60 22.80 21.60 14.40 Arcadis U.S., Inc.9 70.80 13.60 21.60 20.40 15.20 Ardurra Group, Inc.10 69.20 13.60 22.80 19.20 13.60 Lockwood, Andrews & Newnam, Inc.11 69.20 16.80 19.20 20.40 12.80 Black & Veatch Corporation 12 68.40 15.20 20.40 19.20 13.60 Garver, LLC 13 66.40 12.80 19.20 19.20 15.20 KSA Engineers, Inc.14 66.40 15.20 18.00 20.40 12.80 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 15 54.80 8.80 16.80 18.00 11.20 RJN Group Inc 16 51.60 11.20 16.80 13.20 10.40 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Water & WW Planning, Master Plans and Permitting Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Carollo Engineers, Inc.1 90.00 19.20 27.60 26.40 16.80 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.2 89.60 19.20 27.60 25.20 17.60 RPS Infrastructure, Inc.3 85.60 17.60 25.20 25.20 17.60 Black & Veatch Corporation 4 82.80 17.60 25.20 24.00 16.00 Freese and Nichols, Inc.5 82.40 17.60 24.00 24.00 16.80 CP&Y, Inc.6 80.00 16.00 26.40 21.60 16.00 Arcadis U.S., Inc.7 77.60 16.00 22.80 22.80 16.00 HDR Engineering, Inc.8 77.20 17.60 22.80 21.60 15.20 Garver, LLC 9 76.40 16.80 22.80 21.60 15.20 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.10 76.40 17.60 22.80 21.60 14.40 Lockwood, Andrews & Newnam, In 11 76.00 16.80 22.80 22.80 13.60 Gresham, Smith and Partners 12 75.60 13.60 25.20 21.60 15.20 Plummer Associates, Inc.13 74.40 16.80 22.80 20.40 14.40 Hazen and Sawyer, PC 14 72.80 13.60 22.80 22.80 13.60 Ardurra Group, Inc.15 71.20 14.40 20.40 22.80 13.60 Binkley & Barfield, Inc.16 68.80 15.20 20.40 18.00 15.20 Dannenbaum Engineering Corporation 17 65.60 15.20 18.00 20.40 12.00 JQ Infrastructure, LLC 18 62.80 13.60 19.20 20.40 9.60 KSA Engineers, Inc.19 62.40 14.40 15.60 20.40 12.00 Parkhill, Smith & Cooper Inc.20 53.20 10.40 15.60 16.80 10.40 Weston Solutions, Inc 21 51.20 8.80 18.00 13.20 11.20 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Wastewater Treatment Facilities Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Freese and Nichols, Inc.1 92.80 20.00 28.80 26.40 17.60 Carollo Engineers, Inc.2 91.60 20.00 26.40 27.60 17.60 Garver, LLC 3 80.40 16.80 25.20 24.00 14.40 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.4 78.80 17.60 25.20 21.60 14.40 Arcadis U.S., Inc.5 78.00 15.20 24.00 22.80 16.00 HDR Engineering, Inc.6 76.80 16.80 24.00 21.60 14.40 CP&Y, Inc.7 76.40 16.80 24.00 20.40 15.20 RPS Infrastructure, Inc.8 75.20 16.00 19.20 24.00 16.00 Black & Veatch Corporation 9 74.80 15.20 24.00 20.40 15.20 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.10 72.80 17.60 20.40 20.40 14.40 Binkley & Barfield, Inc.11 70.00 15.20 21.60 18.00 15.20 Gresham, Smith and Partners 12 69.60 13.60 20.40 20.40 15.20 Ardurra Group, Inc.13 67.20 15.20 18.00 20.40 13.60 Dannenbaum Engineering Corporation 14 65.60 15.20 18.00 20.40 12.00 JQ Infrastructure, LLC 15 58.40 12.80 19.20 16.80 9.60 KSA Engineers, Inc.16 53.60 12.00 13.20 18.00 10.40 Parkhill, Smith & Cooper Inc.17 51.60 11.20 14.40 15.60 10.40 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Water Treatment Facilities Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Freese and Nichols, Inc. 1 87.20 17.60 26.40 24.00 19.20 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 2 84.40 16.80 26.40 25.20 16.00 Black & Veatch Corporation 3 77.60 16.00 24.00 21.60 16.00 Lockwood, Andrews & Newnam, Inc. 4 79.60 16.00 24.00 25.20 14.40 RPS Infrastructure, Inc. 5 82.00 16.00 22.80 26.40 16.80 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc. 6 80.80 18.40 24.00 21.60 16.80 Carollo Engineers, Inc. 7 78.40 16.00 22.80 22.80 16.80 Arcadis U.S., Inc. 8 76.80 16.00 22.80 22.80 15.20 Garver, LLC 9 75.20 14.40 24.00 24.00 12.80 HDR Engineering, Inc. 10 75.20 16.00 22.80 20.40 16.00 KSA Engineers, Inc. 11 72.40 14.40 21.60 22.80 13.60 Gresham, Smith and Partners 12 73.60 14.40 24.00 21.60 13.60 Binkley & Barfield, Inc. 13 71.20 14.40 22.80 20.40 13.60 Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc. 14 69.60 14.40 21.60 19.20 14.40 Neel-Schaffer, Inc. 15 68.40 13.60 20.40 21.60 12.80 Pape-Dawson Engineers, Inc. 16 67.20 13.60 21.60 19.20 12.80 Dannenbaum Engineering Corporation 17 66.40 13.60 19.20 21.60 12.00 Teague Nall and Perkins, Inc. 18 66.00 12.00 20.40 19.20 14.40 CP&Y, Inc. 19 65.60 12.00 22.80 18.00 12.80 Ardurra Group, Inc. 20 64.80 13.60 19.20 19.20 12.80 Hazen and Sawyer, PC 21 62.00 12.00 19.20 18.00 12.80 LJA Engineering, Inc. 22 61.20 12.00 18.00 19.20 12.00 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 23 58.40 11.20 18.00 18.00 11.20 Burgess & Niple, Inc.24 58.00 11.20 19.20 15.60 12.00 Parkhill, Smith & Cooper Inc. 25 56.80 11.20 16.80 19.20 9.60 Weston Solutions, Inc. 26 50.80 9.60 15.60 14.40 11.20 JQ Infrastructure, LLC 27 50.00 10.40 13.20 16.80 9.60 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Water Storage, Pumping and Distribution Facilities Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Freese and Nichols, Inc. 1 86.40 20.00 24.00 24.00 18.40 Arcadis U.S., Inc. 2 82.80 16.80 25.20 24.00 16.80 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 3 82.40 16.80 25.20 22.80 17.60 Carollo Engineers, Inc. 4 81.60 16.80 24.00 24.00 16.80 Lockwood, Andrews & Newnam, Inc. 5 80.40 16.80 25.20 24.00 14.40 Garver, LLC 6 78.40 14.40 25.20 25.20 13.60 RPS Infrastructure, Inc.7 78.00 16.00 22.80 24.00 15.20 HDR Engineering, Inc.8 77.20 16.80 24.00 20.40 16.00 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.9 76.80 15.20 24.00 21.60 16.00 Plummer Associates, Inc.10 76.00 16.00 22.80 22.80 14.40 Gresham, Smith and Partners 11 72.40 14.40 22.80 21.60 13.60 Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc.12 72.00 16.00 20.40 20.40 15.20 Dannenbaum Engineering Corporation 13 71.60 15.20 22.80 21.60 12.00 Binkley & Barfield, Inc.14 70.80 15.20 21.60 20.40 13.60 CP&Y, Inc.15 69.20 14.40 22.80 19.20 12.80 Pape-Dawson Engineers, Inc.16 68.00 14.40 21.60 19.20 12.80 Neel-Schaffer, Inc.17 66.80 13.60 20.40 21.60 11.20 KSA Engineers, Inc.18 66.40 12.80 18.00 22.80 12.80 Ardurra Group, Inc.19 64.40 13.60 18.00 19.20 13.60 Teague Nall and Perkins, Inc.20 63.20 13.60 18.00 18.00 13.60 Hazen and Sawyer, PC 21 60.80 12.00 19.20 16.80 12.80 LJA Engineering, Inc.22 60.00 12.00 18.00 18.00 12.00 JQ Infrastructure, LLC 23 59.20 12.80 18.00 18.00 10.40 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 24 58.40 11.20 18.00 18.00 11.20 Burgess & Niple, Inc.25 58.00 12.00 18.00 16.80 11.20 Parkhill, Smith & Cooper Inc.26 58.00 11.20 18.00 19.20 9.60 Weston Solutions, Inc 27 56.40 11.20 18.00 16.80 10.40 RJN Group Inc 28 51.60 9.60 16.80 15.60 9.60 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - WW Detention, Lift Station & Collection Facilities Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Carollo Engineers, Inc. 1 90.00 18.40 27.60 26.40 17.60 Baird Gilroy & Dixon, LLC 2 85.20 16.80 26.40 25.20 16.80 Signature Automation, LLC 3 82.40 17.60 25.20 25.20 14.40 Ardurra Group, Inc. 4 81.60 16.00 24.00 24.00 17.60 Arcadis U.S., Inc. 5 80.40 16.00 24.00 22.80 17.60 RPS Infrastructure, Inc. 6 80.40 14.40 26.40 25.20 14.40 Gupta & Associates Inc.7 78.00 16.80 26.40 20.40 14.40 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 8 42.40 9.60 12.00 12.00 8.80 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Cobb, Fendley & Associates, Inc. 1 88.00 16.80 26.40 26.40 18.40 Teague Nall and Perkins, Inc. 2 86.00 17.60 27.60 24.00 16.80 HDR Engineering, Inc. 3 82.80 15.20 26.40 22.80 18.40 Pinnacle Consulting Management Group, Inc. 4 81.20 18.40 25.20 21.60 16.00 LJA Engineering, Inc.5 73.20 16.80 21.60 20.40 14.40 Pape-Dawson Engineers, Inc.6 68.80 14.40 21.60 19.20 13.60 Dannenbaum Engineering Corporation 7 67.20 15.20 20.40 20.40 11.20 Neel-Schaffer, Inc.8 67.20 14.40 20.40 20.40 12.00 Shield Engineering Group, PLLC 9 59.20 12.00 18.00 18.00 11.20 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 10 55.20 11.20 15.60 18.00 10.40 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Water & Wastewater - Electrical & Instrumentation, Telemetry, and SCADA RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Easement and Right-of-Way Acquisition Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Alliance Geotechnical Group, Inc. 1 89.60 18.40 26.40 26.40 18.40 D & S Engineering Labs, LLC 2 87.20 17.60 27.60 25.20 16.80 Alpha Testing, Inc. 3 83.60 16.80 25.20 24.00 17.60 Raba Kistner, Inc.4 78.80 16.00 25.20 21.60 16.00 HVJ Associates 5 67.60 14.40 19.20 20.40 13.60 RJN Group Inc 6 50.00 9.60 15.60 14.40 10.40 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Teague Nall and Perkins, Inc. 1 85.60 16.00 27.60 25.20 16.80 Cobb, Fendley & Associates, Inc. 2 85.20 17.60 26.40 25.20 16.00 Pape-Dawson Engineers, Inc. 3 80.40 15.20 26.40 22.80 16.00 LJA Engineering, Inc.4 78.00 16.80 24.00 22.80 14.40 White Hawk Engineering & Design, LLC 5 78.00 16.80 25.20 21.60 14.40 Neel-Schaffer, Inc.6 71.20 16.00 22.80 20.40 12.00 JQ Infrastructure, LLC 7 70.00 15.20 21.60 20.40 12.80 Shield Engineering Group, PLLC 8 66.40 13.60 20.40 20.40 12.00 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 9 60.80 12.80 16.80 21.60 9.60 RJN Group Inc 10 55.20 11.20 20.40 13.20 10.40 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc. 1 83.20 17.60 24.00 24.00 17.60 Alpha Testing, Inc. 2 80.00 17.60 22.80 22.80 16.80 LJA Engineering, Inc.3 72.80 16.00 24.00 19.20 13.60 Raba Kistner, Inc.4 62.40 12.00 18.00 20.40 12.00 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Surveying and Subsurface Utility Engineering RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Environmental Reports-Water Quality & SWPPP RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Geotechnical Engineering & Testing Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Plummer Associates, Inc. 1 89.20 17.60 26.40 27.60 17.60 HDR Engineering, Inc. 2 80.00 16.00 24.00 24.00 16.00 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.3 78.40 14.40 24.00 24.00 16.00 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.4 75.60 16.80 20.40 21.60 16.80 Hazen and Sawyer, PC 5 67.60 15.20 21.60 18.00 12.80 Dannenbaum Engineering Corporation 6 62.00 13.60 18.00 19.20 11.20 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Carollo Engineers, Inc. 1 89.60 18.40 27.60 25.20 18.40 Plummer Associates, Inc. 2 86.80 16.80 26.40 27.60 16.00 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.3 77.20 14.40 21.60 25.20 16.00 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.4 72.80 14.40 21.60 21.60 15.20 HDR Engineering, Inc.5 64.40 12.80 19.20 18.00 14.40 Hazen and Sawyer, PC 6 62.00 12.00 20.40 16.80 12.80 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 1 86.00 16.80 26.40 25.20 17.60 Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc. 2 80.80 16.00 21.60 24.00 19.20 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Reclaimed Water RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Direct Potable Reuse RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Bed and Banks Permitting Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Carollo Engineers, Inc. 1 88.80 20.00 26.40 24.00 18.40 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 2 88.00 17.60 28.80 24.00 17.60 Arcadis U.S., Inc.3 66.40 14.40 20.40 18.00 13.60 Birkhoff, Hendricks & Carter, LLP 4 63.20 11.20 20.40 20.40 11.20 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% HDR Engineering, Inc. 1 87.20 16.00 26.40 26.40 18.40 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc. 2 86.80 16.80 24.00 27.60 18.40 Arcadis U.S., Inc.3 67.20 12.80 20.40 20.40 13.60 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc.1 84.40 16.80 25.20 24.00 18.40 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Signature Automation, LLC 1 82.80 16.80 24.00 25.20 16.80 Weston Solutions, Inc 2 65.60 11.20 20.40 20.40 13.60 RPS Infrastructure, Inc.3 64.80 13.60 18.00 20.40 12.80 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Water Supply Planning RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Aquifer Storage and Recovery RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Recovery and Hazard Assessments RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Vulnerability Assessments Exhibit 2 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.1 82.80 16.80 24.00 25.20 16.80 Signature Automation, LLC 2 67.20 14.40 21.60 19.20 12.00 Weston Solutions, Inc 3 66.80 12.80 20.40 19.20 14.40 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Carollo Engineers, Inc.1 90.00 19.20 27.60 26.40 16.80 Freese and Nichols, Inc.2 90.00 17.60 27.60 26.40 18.40 Black & Veatch Corporation 3 79.20 15.20 25.20 22.80 16.00 HDR Engineering, Inc.4 77.60 15.20 24.00 24.00 14.40 Hazen and Sawyer, PC 5 74.80 15.20 25.20 19.20 15.20 Burgess & Niple, Inc.6 72.00 15.20 21.60 21.60 13.60 Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc.7 70.00 14.40 20.40 19.20 16.00 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.8 67.60 15.20 18.00 19.20 15.20 RJN Group Inc 9 65.20 12.00 22.80 16.80 13.60 Burns & McDonnell Engineering Company, Inc.10 61.20 12.80 19.20 15.60 13.60 Vendor Rank Score Key Personnel and Project Team - 20% Experience of the Firm - 30% Past Performance - 30% Adequacy and Availability - 20% Black & Veatch Corporation 1 86.80 16.80 27.60 26.40 16.00 Jacobs Engineering Group Inc.2 80.80 16.00 24.00 26.40 14.40 RPS Infrastructure, Inc.3 63.60 11.20 19.20 20.40 12.80 KSA Engineers, Inc.4 53.20 10.40 16.80 15.60 10.40 RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Asset Management RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Water Metering RFQ 8213 - Evaluation Sheet for Pre-Qualified Engineering List for Water & Wastewater - Emergency Planning