Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout10-23-1990 r~r p ~ . 7 f " AGENDA CITY OF DENT'ON CITY COUNCIL October 23, 1990 Special Call Session of the City of Denton City Council on TuesCay. October 23, 1990, at 5:15 p.m. in the Civil Defense Room of City Hall, 215 E. McKinney, Denton, Texas at which the following items will be considered: 5:15 P.M. 1. Consider adoption of an ordinance amending Chapter 26 (Vehicles for Hire) of the Code of Ordinances to provide for a temporary increase in taxicab rates. 2. Consider adoption of an ordinance approving a contract retaining R. William Wood to represent the City in claims against August International Company and Washington National Ineurance Company. 3. Consider adoption of an ordinance amending the schedule of electric rates by deleting Schedule RW (Religious Worship), and by adopting a new schedule TGS (General Service Time of Use Rate). 4. Consider adoption of an ordinance amending the schedule of electric rates by deleting Schedule RW (Religious Worship); and by adopting a new Schedule WK $ (Weekend Rate), 5. Receive a report and hold a discussion regarding an E update on the strategic planning session of the City3 of Denton Executive Staff. Following the completion of Item #5., Council will convene in the City Manager's Conference Room at which the following items a will be considered: 6. Executive Session: A. Legal Matters Under Sec, 2(e), Art. 6252-17 V.A.T.S. B. Real Estate Under Sec. 2(f), Art. 6252-17 V.A.T.S. C. Personnel/Board Appointments Under Sec. 2(g), E Art 6252-17 V.A.T.o. 1. Consider annual evaluations of the Municipal Judge, City Attorney and City Managec. 2. Consider an appointment to the Park and Recreation Board. 4 ti r V City of Denton City Council Agenda October 23, 1990 Page 2 C R T I F I C A T E i ~cca+ I certify that the above notice of meeting was Posted on the bulletin board at the City Hall of the City of Denton, o'Texas. clock day of 1990 at on the (a.m.) CITY SECRETARY 3307C u k Fj 1 i i 1 U N j i1 1 i ♦r ty ~ I a C I TY -MM COUNCIL -t MMITM Yi 1 o~ a~ i 'o I M~ it Oo 0 xxx T-M O~ pb 1 r ° " ~ ~ 0000 + TM: 1 i I ~yl !1Lf 11L I[1r■ ~ ! f r i ORDINANCE NO. I AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DENTON, TEXAS, AMENDING CHAPTER 26 (VEHICLES FOR HIRE) OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES TO PROVIDE FOR A TEMPORARY INCREASE IN TAXICAB RATESr AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, in 1989 the City of Denton set the present taxicab mileage rate ct $1.10 a miler and WHEREAS, since then gasoline prices have risen by approximately thirty percentr and structure that WHEREASt t for City is the volatility studying of gasoline t prrate ices; and i would accou WHEREAS, the City Council desires to grant a temporary increase pending the completion of the studyr NOW, THEREFORE1 ti THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DENTON HEREBY ORDAINS: That section 26-52 (a) of the Code of ordinances is I nxCTION i. amended to read as follows: See. 26-52. Taximeters) rates to be obarged, a) Passen ars will be charged as determined by the taxi- meter a miniLum fare of one dollar and thirty cents ; ($1.30) including the first one-tenth (1/10) mile plus ` thirteen cents ($0.13) for each additional one-tenth (1/10) mile from the point of pickup to destination. SECTIQK II. That this ordinance shall become effective ! immediately upon its passage and approval. j F PASSED AND APPROVED this the day of 1990. I BOB CASTL£BERRY, MAYOR i T7"~'r F, r j Y r'V:: -w.II f ATTEST: JENNIFER WALTERS, CITY SECRETARY BY: APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORMS DEBRA A. DRAYOVITCH, CITY ATTORNEY il r i BY: Ln~ 1+ {Y v taxlnrterord l r ti. (I awl 1 wry of DffNTON, MAS 215 E. MCKINNEY/ 0ENTON, TEXAS 78201 / TELEPHONE (817) 6f1"M 6 'd v MEMORANDUM DATE: October 19, 1990 TO: Lloyd Y. Harrell, City Manager FROM: Max Blackburn, Risk Manager#pS SUBJECT: TAXI RATE INCREASE ORDINANCE The ordinance was discussed with Legal and it was decided to eliminate an ending date for the temporary rate based on the uncertainty of time involved in passing a permanent ordinance (eg., City Council agenda, public hearings, etc.) I anticipate having the permanent ordinance available for the the November 6t 1990 Council meeting. The $1.3u per mile ($0.13 per 1/10 mile] rate will be viable under either ordinance unless there is a dramatic increase or decrease in gasoline prices within the next few weeks. +V1, " MB:af a' 5483F E v{ ' Ole T WWI ~ l l^'"•"" DATE: October 16, 1990 r CITY COUNCIL REPORT FORMAT TO: Mayor and Members of the City Council FROM: Lloyd V. Harrell, City Manager SUBJECT: TAXI SERVICE RATE INCREASE REQUEST } ' r Background: In 19890 the Denton Taxi Service requested an increase in their rates based on inflation, decrease in profits, and the lack of an increase since 1980. The City Council, after public hearings, approved a rate increase to: Pickup: $1.30 Time: $0,25/90 seconds Mileage: $1.10 At the time of the 1989 rate increase, gasoline was available at approximately $0.97 per gallon resulting in taxi cab companies using about twenty-two 1221) percent of their net income for gasoline. Taxi cab companies now pay $1.27 per gallon after discount. f Evaluation: All cities in the metroplex who regulate taxi rates are confronting the problem. For example, Dallas taxi cab companie: have requested a temporary per mile). Dallas is in the process of 1 rate increase ($1.00 to ,11.50 convening a public hearing on the subject. Since the 1989 rate increase, gasoline prices have increased by thirty 1301) percent resulting in taxi cab companies using about one-third of their 'after driver' income for gasoline. i Denton Taxi Service is requesting a temporary rate increase of $0.20 per mile to a $1.30 rate based on current and projected gasoline prices. As we well know, gasoline prices will endure extreme volatility for the foreseeable future depending upon world events and it is possible that gasoline prices could decrease as rapidly as they have increased. It would appear that a sliding scale would be appropriate. Recommendation: 1. Recommend approval of a rate increase to the requested $1.30 per mile for a period of thirty (30) daps. yc 1 1 i City Council Report Format Taxi Rate Increase Request E Page 2 I 1 2. Recommend that the Risk Manager work with legal to draft an ordinance change to incorporate a sliding scale. An example of a scale is located below: Gasoline Price Milea, eq Rate 4 up to $1.00 $ 1.10 S 1.00 to a1.20 1.20 $1.20 to $1.40 1.39 etc The Risk Manager will be respovalble for verifying gasoline prices paid by 4 ' the taxi companies. f ~ s J ATTACHMENTS: {I Memorandum on 1939 rate increase k Denton Taxi Service Request Denton City Taxi Request Respectfully submitted: k Lloyd V. Harrell City Manager 1 Prepared by: J t V Approved: f Ncarane , I x Oecut n Fi v e e Director of Finance t 5411E ~ ~ } 1 F 1 r ~ ~N Rf I a COPY n L~ J 1 CITY of OsNTON / 215 E. McKinney / Denton, Texas 76201 y n~n~aan~~tn DATE: July 120 1989 TO: Lloyd V. Harrell, City Manager FROM: Haclan L. Jefferson, Risk Manager SU&IECT: DENTON TAXI SERVICE RATE INCREASE REQUEST RECOMMENDATION A After evaluating the Denton Taxi Service's request for an increase in their rates (Attachment 1), we recommend increasing their present pick-up cats, time rate, and mileage rate. 1 EVALUATION r There are basically four factors that contribute to the need of a rate increase by the Denton Taxi Service. These factors are as follows: j o The level of inflation since the last taxi service rate, increase 1 3 1 o A decrease in the company's net profit while their gross income increased substantially 14 o A survey of taxicab rates among metropolitan titles o The frequent change in owners of the Denton Taxi Service during the 1980's The present taxi rates were enacted in 1980. Since that time, the Consumer Price Index foe the Dallas/tort worth area (which is a measure of inflation) increased 48.21. Although they probably did not experience an increase in all of their expenses that corresponded with the Consumer Price Index, increases r i certainly occurred in wages, rent, utilities, advertisement, licenses, maintenance, materials, supplies, etc. Secondly, a review of Denton Taxi Service's financial records indicate that I i their gross income increased by 261, while their net profit decreased by 21%, it 1 1++ I i Y e i V Memo to Lloyd V. Harrell July 12, 1989 1 page 2 of 3. 1 This was primarily caused by more than a 1001 increase in auto insurance, from approximately $50400 to $10,865e Additionally# their auto maintenance cost increased by more than 8001, from approximately $1,338 to $11#531. When one considers the 261 increase in their growth margin, you have to conclude that they are being utilized by more citizens and making less money while doing so. Thirdly# we conducted a survey of taxicab rates in the metroplex to determine how compatible the proposed rate increase is to other rates in the area. The following are the results of the aurveyi TABLE I RATE CATEGORIES _ CITY Pick-Up Time Mileage Addison $1.30 $0.25/90 Sec. $1.00 Arlington $1.30 $0.25/90 Sec. $1.00 Dallas $1.30 $0.25/90 Sec. $1.00 Denton (Current) $1.20 $0.20/90 Sec. $1.00 Denton (Proposed) $1.30 $0.20/45 Sec. $1.10 Irving $1.30 - $1.00 .80 $ Lewisville $2,50 $0.30/90 sec. $1.00 Plano ' Of the proposed rate change, the pick-up rate is consistent with other citiesi however, the time rate is higher than that of other cities and the mileage rate is slightly higher than that of other cities. These rates must be i compared with two points in mind. First, other cities are also considering I adjustments in their taxicab rates. Secondly, each city has to design its rates according to the characteristics of its community. In Denton, i passengers often stop at several locations during one trip and ask the driver to wait. Under the present rate structure, the taxi brings in considerably f less revenue while waiting for passengers, as opposed to transporting them. q The impact of the time rate increase is exhibited in the table below, which 4 1 compares the average cost of a five-mile trip between the present rates and proposed totes, TABLE It Denton Taxi Rates i i Present Proposed Diffet-ince i Pick-Up 51.20 $1.30 $0.30 .j Time 0.18 0.37 0.19 Mileage 5.00 5.50 0650 Total $6.38 $7.17 $0.79 ? I Tic Or" Memo to Lloyd V. Harrell July 12, 1989 Page 3 of 3. Fi,ally, It is possible that the frequent change in ownership of the Denton Taxi Service may be related to the profitability of the company. (During the last nine years, the company has changed owners thcea times.) Without taking steps to improve their profit margin, they will continue to experience difficulties. Apart from a rate increase, the owners should also consider methods of reducing their expenses. Although they have limited control over their insurance premiums, an expense reductiaa can be accomplished by implementing a vehicle replacement program for older taxicabs with high maintenance costs. It is recommended that the City Attorney's office be asked to prepare an ordinance implementing the request as made by the Denton Taxi Service. We have provided you with a copy of the present ordinance (Attachment II), j council may want to schedule a public hearing at the same time the ordinance is formally considered. i If you have any questions or cociments, please do not hesitate to contact me. i r ~t Harlan L. Jet e n HLJssfn r 4663F . ri a r I v Jw , ATTACHMENT II c 126-43 DENTON CODE 126-43 ARTICLE IV. TAXICABS' J 1 See. 2843. DetWdoas. City. The term "city" as used in this article shall mean the City of Denton, Tema Driver. The term "o,iver" shall is held to include every person in actual charge of the operation of a taxicab, as herein defined, whether as owner or agent, servant or employee of the "owner" as herein defined. J~ Owner. The term "owner" when used In this article shall be construed to mean any person, firm, corporation, association, partnership or society who has the control, direction, mainte• nano* and the benefit of the collection of revenue derived dram the operation of taxicab, on or over the streets or public ways of the city, whether as owner or otherwise, except as "driver" as herein defined. - PvwrL The term "person" shall include both singular and plural, and shalt mean and include any individual. firm, corpom• ' tion, association, partnership or society, and their ageats, ser. wants or employees. Streed The term "street" so used in this article shall mean and include any street, alley, avenue, land, boulevard, drive, public place or highway commonly used for the purpose of public trawl - within the incorporated limits of the City d Deatan. raxicA The term "taxtcs► as used in this article shall mesa i every automobile or mow-propelled vehicle used for transports- 4 i 1 Lion of passengers for hire over the public -hem of the City of 3 Denton and b7sopeetive of whether or ant the operations extend beyond the incorporated limits of the City of Denton; provided. however, the term "taxicab" shall ant apply to motor buses open. S 1156MV's sob-" Na UA 11, wAed net l9, lot anwbd CL 2C ~t AR N fo ks eating, is and n Irma w eat Tlr saheteedw FROWN, OU Art N. eeertettag of FI 7~ti-I/. wee MeiMi Ana orl Nw A70a . ti 4 adopted hk 2/.1907, OrL Ne. s&99. 11, WW" 8spt 10.191x, Ord Ne. 72. 11. I y 1 L adopeed APO 11. 197 " Na 7414 1 L ObOW April 16, 1974 and Ord Na 60,74.11, 66POW Aptl 2L 19/0. 1 Crew AM Mee of Wdeai etaade, 124. 130, Spp Ne 71 Iwo i ~ j 1 j i I ` y tlr?.' ~r i c i 12e-43 VEHICLES FOR HIRE 126-44 r ated within the incorpo►atad limits of the City of Denton under a i f4aachise from the city over a fixed or defined route, nor shall + said term apply to motor buses regularly operated over a fixed and defined route in the city to or from points outside of the incorporated limits. Taximeter. The term "taximeter" as used in this article shall mean a machine adapted automatically to calculate, at a pred♦ termined rate or rata, and to register, the charge for hire of a taxicab and such charges shall be indicated by means of figures. Waiting firms. The term "waiting time" as urnd in this article shall mean such times a may be consumed or !ost at the special instance and request of a passenger after such passenger has first entered the taxicab to make a trip and b-sAire reaching his final dest(sution. No charge shall be made against a passenger for any time lost on account of any other delay whatsoever. (Ord. No. 8280,1 1, 10-12.82) - ' See. M4C Taxicab licensee. (a) Required It shall be unlawful for any person to drive or operate, or cause to be driven or operated. any taxicab upon or y over any street in the City of Denton, unless there has ban obtained by the owner of and for such taxicab and existing in full force and effect, a lianas duly issued by the city secretary of the City of Denton 0-e hereinafter provided. i (b) Nettssify. No license to operate a taxicab shall be issued by pN she city secretary until the chid of police of the City of Denton has cartilied thst: (1) The taxicab has boon properly inspected as required by the laws of the State of Texas; (2) The liability insurance required by this article for each 1 1 taxicab is in ku fora and effect; and, . (3) 91e taxicab or taxicab service has • definite and fired place of business in the city and has a telephone number in service at which requests for taxicab service can be made. (c) Reuocation or suspension of ifeense, Upon complaint against r a licansoo Ned by any person with the chid of police, or upon his l tlspp Na 38 1031 , t =r i i 'S i a I _ 1Yry ~ Y Y, r,o i r ` 12644 DENTON CODE 12845 i own motion, charging violation of any of the terms of this article, or any ordinances of the City of Denton, or laws of the State of Texas regulating motor vehicles, the chief of police after giving five (b) days' notice of the grounds of said complaint to such licensee against whom complaint is made, may hear evidence with reference to such complaint, and after such bearing the chief of police may revoke or suspend the license for good cause shown. i (d) Findings. After the chief of police has heard the complaint for the revocation or suspension of the license of any owner of a taxicab, he shall make his findings aced declare the same, and either the owner of such taxicab or the compisintant shall have the right to appeal to the city council as, hereinafter set out. (e) License contents. Said Ucense shall state the year for which it is issued, the name of the owner of said vehicle, shall designate that said vehicle is a "taxicab," shall state the make of said vehicle, the engine number of said vehicle, and the current Ii. cones number of said vehicle, and shall state the amount of license tax paid for the operation of said vehicle and shad further ' state that the owner of said vehicle has deposited with the city an insurance policy for the protection of the passengers thereof and of the general public as provided for in this article, and said - " license shall be signed by the city secretary. (Ord. No. 8280, 11. 1s. 12-82) _ ✓ Sen. 26AL Public iiabWty Insurance. (a) Required Before any license shall be issued to any owner of a taxicab hereinbefore defined, or before any renewal of liceasse I shall be granted, the owner shall be required to file with the city secretary, and thereafter keep in full force and effect, a policy of a public liability Insurance approved by the city attorney executed ' by an insurance wmpany duly authorized to do business in the l j State of Texas, and performable in Denton County, Texas, lase. I ing the public against any loss or damage that may result to any person or property from the operation of such vehicle or vehicles, and tle maximum amount of recovery in such policy of insurance speciAed, shall not be less than the following sums, to wit' i, 4 SuM Na 35 1032 G r y I 1 I I F i 128.15 VEHICLES FOR HIRE 126-46 3 r. (1) For total liability in any onu accident for personal injuries -or death, one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000.00). (2) For the injury or death of any one person in any one accident, three hundred thousand dollars (3300,000.00). (3) For Injury or destruction of property in any one accident, fifty thousand dollars (160,000.00). Provided, however, that if it be shown to the satisfaction of the chief of police that policies in the above amounts cannot be ob- tained, then policies in lesser amounts msy be secured and filed (a lull compliance with the provisions hereof, upon certificate to that effect being filed with the city secretary by the chief of police, and upon approval of the stated leaser amounts by the city attorney. (b) Esreption; employaa The above4secribed public liability Insurance shall be for the protection of the passengers of said vehicles and for the public, but shall not cover personal injuries - k sustained by the servants, agents or employees of the person j filing the same. (c) Continuing liability. All policies of public liability insur• 1 am shall contain a provision for a continuing liability thereon up to the full amount thereof, notwithstanding any recovery thereon. _ t (d) Cancellation, In the event any policy Is so cancelled upon the request of the surety or insurer, and no insurance policy to filed by said llcensse before the cancellation of said original assurance, then the license to operate taxicabs granted to said licensee shall be automatically revoked. (a) City not Wis, Neither said city nor any oQlcer thereof shall be held liable for the pecuafary responsibility or solvency of any such Insurer, or in any manner become liable for any sum on account of any such claim or act or omission relating to any such motor vehicle, nor shall the liability of the owner of any such motor vehicle be in any manner limited or changed in connection with this article of such license or assuraswo but the judgment creditors having causes of action secured thereby shall be author. I iced to sue directly on such policy of Insurance without implead- ! Sayp Na 38 1033 'r 1 I I (a M--j 1 t 28 ~b DENTON CODE 12846 r 1 r ing the City of Denton, and all persons known to any insurer to have been injured or damaged in the same accident and claiming damages thereunder may be made parties without priority of c:aim on payment in any suit had or instituted on account of such matters. (Ord. No. 82.80, 11. 10.12-82) Sec. 264& hearers and inspection tee. (a) Amount terns. In order to defray a part of the expense necessary to provide surveillance, supervision wad inspection of I taxicabs required under the terms and provisions of this article, there to hereby levied a license and inspection fee of one hundred dollars (1100.00) per annum for each "cub so operated, which fee shall be collected from every person, firm or corporation own• ing and operating taxicabs on the streets of the city by the city secretary before said license or renewal thereof is issued. Said fee ~lJ shall be payable In advance on an aanual bads, and shall be due and payable for any year not later than the first day of January _ of any year, such fee to cover the calendar year. If a license to operate any taxicab is granted during a current year the fee shall , be paid for the balance of the year ending December thirty-first. (b) Sold wredkrd dat eyed vehicles. In the event a tasiab on which the fee has been paid for the thsneurrent year is sold, s wrecked or destroyed, the owner thereof shall have the right to replace aid taxicab with another, and upon written application _ to the chief of police, the license and inspection fee therefor paid on said taxicab so sold, wrecked, or destroyed shall be made 1 applicable to the vehicle designated to replan such taxicab so sold, wrecked or destroy4 and the licensee shall surrender the J license certificate on the vehicle so sold, wrecked or destroyed before receiving a new license certificate. j (c) Lost 8cense c orkates. In case any licensee shall lose his f ~I license certificate, said license shall forthwith and before doing may ftutthm business procure a duplicate license certiAats from the city secretary, and shall pay for such dupliats license certin- ate the sum of five dollars (18.00). ti 1 (d) Rends: There shall not in any event be any refund of license and inspection tees paid under this article. M SaW No. 76 1034 2 e 1 3 S Y. i 1 S I III 1 1 ~IY.M..r Bw,F~ 1 r ~ If' I ' r 12&18 > VEHICLES FOR HIRE i X m T ( (e) Reaipte The fees shall be paid to the city cashier who shall r• \ issue a receipt therefor which shall be presented to the city secretary before any license is issued. (Ord No. 8280,1 1,10.1282) Seo. 2647. Opeeatioa of taxicab UWted to Ilcenaee and approved chauffeurs. No taxicab for which a license shall have been issued &W be operated by anyone except the licensee thereof, or any employee Properly qualified, and approved by the chief of police of taxicabs. LIa110es shall obtain the came, address and last place of am. ployment of ach and every )iceaesd chauffeur applying before hieing him; and further said tiacses ahalforthwith fur. 111013 to the Chief of police the name and address of every licensed chouffeur before his being hired. and of every licensed chauffeur s that may be discharged, (Ord. No. 8280, 11, 10.1282) . Sec. 2448. Tmasfer of flcomm. i No Manes issued under the terms of this article shall be trans. fined to any uthm person, nor shall such license be used for the operatfon Of any vehicle except for the vehicle for which said license Is Issued. (Ord, No. 8280, } 1, 1012.82) 1 Sao. 2448. license to be posted in cab.t The license tasted for the operation of a taxicab under the I terms of this article shall be posted within said taxicab in a cowpiCUOUS place, and it shall be a violation *(this article for a fallum to do w (Ord. No. 8240.11,10-12-82) Bee. U." Owwr's ruses, eton required on cab. Every taxicab shall have painted or affixed by deal on the door d the Cab the name of the owner or the trade name under which the owner operstaa. together with the ownses telephone i number, aid the cab number, and the number o (the cab sad the f telepboae number of the owner shall be &MAW upon the rear of all such vs13iolea. All the lettering meationed in this paragraph &W be 40 Im than two (2) inches oae•fourth M inch in stroke. (Ord. No. 8240, 11, IM2 ~ than Son Na 19 i 1035 • !r i 4 I r r. a /w..... 12g81 DUMN CODE 12f-62.1 . Sec. 2681. Rights ot pasangere. Any driver employed to carry passengers to a definite point shall lake the most direct route possible that will carry the passengers safely and expeditiously to their destination. (Ord. No. 82.80, 11. 10.12.82) See. 266L Taximeters; ratan to be chsuged. All fares shall be determined by a taximeter installed in each taxicab and a driver shall charge only a fee as computed by such taximeter. Every taximeter so installed shall be kept in good operating condition and the taximeter or its drive system shall be Baled at all points which the components, if manipulated, could affect the ftuation or a msey of the taximatsr. A driver shall not charge a fare for operating a taxicab in the city that is inconsistent with the following established rata: s W Passengers will be charged as determined by the tWino. ter a minimum fan of one dollar and twenty ants ($1.40) - including the Bret one-tenth (1110) mile plus ton ants t ($0.10) for each additional one-tenth (1/10) mile from the point d pickup to destination. (b) An extra charge of filly ants ($0.60) will be charged for ' each additional passenger. (e) A nucharge d filly ante ($0.60) will be charged for any pickup offing between the hours of 8:00 p.m. and 8.00 a.m. (d) Pas engm will be charged as determined by the taxime- ter a fan of twenty onto ($0.40) for each one and on*balf (1%) minutes d waiting time or trafYic delay. (Ord. No. 82-60,1 1,10.14-64) Sao. 96611. Laoaeine exemption. Notwithdanding the provisions of Section 2660 and Section ~ 2664 d this article, it shell not be mandatory that a motor vehicle operated as a limousine mrvice and charging a set trip fee or an hourly fee, by advance reservation, to have the aarae of € the owner or trade name printed or affixed to the door or rear of 8eol. No. 14 1038 V, t Ile- k ~ I ~.a , . 17681.1 VEMCLE9 FOR tntz 12643 the vehicle or be required to have a taximeter installed in such ` vehicle;, provided. that all tripe or hourly tea shall be filed at all times with the city secretary of the City of Denton. (Ord. No. 88.98, Pt. 1, 9") See. 2644 dates and chauffeur's name and license to be posted In cab. There shall be posted In a conspicuous place on the inside of each iioeased taxicab, In addition to the license issued to Hceosee a required by this article, a card showing the rates charged by said taxicab. There shall also be placed in a conspicuous place inside j jj I I i i I • i i says. Na 12 1088.1 i 1 „y u 14, I Ile- err 4V 12653 VEHICLES FOR HIRE 1 26M F r1:.,. of each licensed taxicab a card bearing the name and chauffeur's r license number of the driver of said taxicab as issued to him by r the city secretary. (Ord. No. 8280, 11, 10-12.82) Sec. 2644. Paawn`ers requirtd to pay fan. It shall be unlawfW for any person to refuse to pay the legal fan of any of the vehicles mentioned in this articlo after having hired the same. (Ord. No. 82.80, 1 1, 10.12.82) See. 2645. Passenger's receipt, may be required. It shall be unlawf d for the driver of any taxicab upon receiv. ing fWl payment of a fan to refuse to give a receipt upon the nquat of any passenger making said payment. (Ord. No. 82.80, 1, 10-12.82) See. 2665. Charging excessive fares uWaw6d. It shall be unlawfW for the owner or driver of any taxicab to R nAw to convey a passenger at the rate specified on the rste card displayed in said taxicab. or demand or receive an amount In , excess of the rates displayed on said card. Except that such owns or driver may refuse to convey a passenger then being guilty of misconduct or breach of the poses. (Ord. No. 82.80, 11. 10.1282) Sea. 2647-2684. Reserved. y 9 ARTICLE V. AMBULANCff,9e Y Elec. 2656. Definitions. For the purpose of this article, the following words and phrases shall have the msaniags respectively ascribed to then in this section: •U*Ws sob-•4rdineea Na 8&13. 11. adopW Feb. 1, 1963. amended Art V, Ambulasaw is Its entirety to rood w home set out The wbetaative provi. does of forma Art V. 1 MC wen dwind hem Cvt No. 69.74, 1 t, ossew Segel. 14. 1669. Cross ratinnsse-C~vit deteess 1 T•1 N seq.: Mt pnventSaa 11o-1 of eq privllgb and asomptlea hem b%ft repleti m reprdie6 authwissd amor• l "my vebklb.124-19., prowdun d Odw vehkks upoa apprenh er eawsessy R. vehicles, 1 24491 Wowing authorized emsrlsasy nhkles Is ewrteoein, 1 7467; eesmgtin of wtbaeiud omer6oaay vohkks haste VOW n6ulatkas. I E 24106; r rodtam 127.1 It eaq. 4 Sam Na 36 1037 , . i "d A 3 +,a it f Illj J 77 ~ . ~ /'..-tic. ~-t ^--^-1 • rv4 ~ CL -¢-4-~ "k-Q . ~J O"(c^O. s~^ -•-t. j l L: rat ~l- 13 J - 3 0.7n 9 31.5' I Y y ~3.;2 s~ eti, cJ il*i /Lt-~h2Ld$4+-~-araG•~-~...[~~y r+,/~Ls.,.:.I~ t 3 406 J' _ C1 1 i ' I d ■ } ~p f I, i ~rv~~,e lD, ~syd AEO7 ; ',k rYIAn~Grr (,t'7y a-F 4-t?ran J r T C>3R y , ofr rgi , D UMLr of C n,o~ C-rY 14, , LA,Culd r, Kt 4u ydu~ 4-f l Pr')T1 d ✓7 )/f L 1~i 5E O t ink/RTio.~ dnc^4 i ><.S a~-fec' o/,-) /WC 0013 cemlu„y. The Ay C05T ~ r ALE / oQtkd ' o Ol e co s7 of " io {e,lance lice, our vehJoleS i,a.s i cJ6(l a b/) eco sf c%-va 4IV , tc AR(2 hereby ~ n yur'riny a 420- i nCiedse rtJoaco/ j, gre4 lc°Cia re. yOu✓ ~~te in tP~leu-) lq Ghl.f /Ybl~fc°~. 1 hAayow, c r .,e ly tar I i, 1 lpa,rI~ f Rrr ~ '1 I ~ i■y 1 i I 4 CITY COUNCIL ► d a r ° r t • ~00~ ~Q~OO0000~ ' e i 1 C4, i v f ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DENTON APPROVING A CONTRACT RETAINING R. WILLIAM WOOD TO REPRESENT THE CITY IN CLAIMS AGAINST AUGUST INTERNATIONAL COMPANY AND WASHINGTON NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE. i i THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DENTON HEREBY ORDAINS: SECTION . That the City Manager is hereby authorized to execute a contract between the City of Denton and R. William Wood to represent the City in claims against August International Company and Washington National Insurance Company under the terms and conditions contained within said contract, a copy ^f which is attached hereto and made a part hsreof. k=19N II. That the City Council hereby authorizes the expenditure of funds in accordance with the contract. SECTION III. That this ordinance shall become effective immediately upon its passage and approval. PASSED AND APPROVED this the day of 1990. BOB CASTLEBERRY, MAYOR ATTEST: I) JENNIFER WALTERS, CITY SECRETARY BY a APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORM: DEBRA A. DRAYOVITCH, CITY ATTORNEY BY: t t A / 1 TAX r A■■p 1 ..f 4C i 1 J • THE STATE OF TEXAS } CONTRACT OF EMPLOYMENT AND COUNTY OF DENTON ) POWER OF ATTORNEY The undersiyned ("Client") hereby omploys the law firm of R. William Wood ("Attorney") to do all legal proceedings which, in their judgment, are reasonably necessary to properly manage the following legal matterst Hardling a claim or suit against August International Corporation and Washington National Insurance Company for damages to the client arising from Washington National's failure to pay claims to the client in compliance with tha stop loss insurance policy. Attorney agree to exercise reasonable care and diligence in investigating the factual and legal merits of Client's claim. In the event that Attorneys' investigation leads his to the opinion that continued pursuit of Client's claim is not reasonably justified, upon reasonable notice by Attorney, this agreement shall be terminated and shall impose no further obligation on the part of Attorney or Client. In the event that such an opinion is rendered by Attorney during the pendency of a legal proceeding, Client agrees to execute any documents necessary to effect the withdrawal of Attorney from the case. In consideration for Attorney's services, Client agrees to pay ` Attorney a contingent fee equal to 33 1/31 of the total amount of any recovery made prior to suit being filed, and 401 of the total amount of any recovery made after suit is filed, whether by settlement judgment or otherwiie. If an appeal is perfected, Client agrees to pay an additional lot of the S recovery. Client sells, conveys and assigns to Attorney an interest, equal to the amount of Attorneys' fees, in and to the claim and cause of action, and any judgment rendered. Exhibit "A" attached hereto modifies this part of the agreement. Client acknowledges that the law requires it to be responsible for all out-of-pocket expenses) however, Attorney will pay these expenses as they accrue, and the amounts expanded will constitute advances of funds on its behalf. Client shall keep Attorney advised of any change of location, shall appear on reasonable notice at depositions and court ap- pearances and shall comply with all reasonable requests of Attorney in connection with the preparation and presentation of Client's case. NIEMEN! r"FF 1 Y r Client hereby grants Attorney its power of attorney to execute all documents connected with this claim, including pleadings, contracts, checks or drafts, settlement agreements, compromises and releases, verifications, dismissals, and orders1 however, it is expressly understood that Attorney shall not settle Client's case without Client's express consent. ? Client acknowledges that Attorney has told it that they make no guarantees of successful recovery or satisfactory outcome of this matter. SIGNED this day of , 19 ,t ~S ACCEPTEDt CLIENT a' R. William Wood CLIENT I ! ~I J i ~ III 1 Ir} 1Y I ,r 7717. F I` ` EXHIBIT "A" On any recovery for any portion of that part of the claim based upon prescription expense/reimbursement, the attorney's fee shall be limited to 20% of the amount recovered on that portion of the claim. I i i i I r 1 w E lilt s I 'I CITY i COUNCIL , 1 a i ~ff 4 ~0 / C f ` hr 0 { Q ~ / ' ~r0 N t~ 000 ~a4 C GGfl~ a 'k 4 Ole h . October 23, 1990 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM { TOt MAYOR AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL " FROM Lloyd V. Herre11, City Manager RE: CONSIDER "WEEKEND USE" ELECTRIC RATE a SUMMARY Subsequent to a City Attorney's office opinion that the Religious Worship (RW) electrical rate is probably unlawful, the Utility Board, at the request of the Council, reviewed (Exhibit develop board twmeetin. o alternativest this . issue The Board their directed b staff , to 1990 11). The Board directed staff to develop two altgernativest 1. Conduct further investigations into and, if possible, develop a "weekend use" rate that would be applicable to any adversely caffect rexisting rate structures and revenuesf and, 2. Develop an administrative procedure for determining qualifications for placing customers on the existing Religious Worship rate, which would be renamed "Weekend cost that of those service taseis now would the came continue with Use Rate" pay their full such the RW customrirs. z R~ y~ RWRATE.ALT 011 Fty. Y "WEEKEND USE" RATE; ALTERNATIVE The first alternative can be met by some modification of Denton's existing "Time of Use" rate for General Service, (TGS) i.e., commercial customers. This TGS rate would be as follows and is compared to the GS (Commercial) rate and the RW rate: TGS GS RW Facility i Charge Single phase $25.00 $15.00 $15.00 Three phase 30.00 25.00 $20.00 F Demand y Charge On Peak $12.50 (1) $ 7.00/KW (3) $3.75/KW (4) System Peak 4.00 (2) Energy Charge All KWH 10/KWH , let 2500 KWH 6.560/KWH over 2500 KWH 3.500/KWH lot 700 KWH 7.500/KWH Over 700 KWH 2.920/KWH Fuel Ad)ustment Charge 1.90/KWH 1.90/KWH 1.90/XWh (1) Charged to maximum We occurring during "on peak" hours which are defined as those hours between 1 PM and 8 PM weekdays, + 4 during the summer months of June, July, August, September. (2) Charged to the maximum KW's occurring on any hour of the month 11 other than "on peak" hours defined above. (3) Charged to the maximum KW's occurring on any hour of the month. No charge for the first 20 KW. (4) Charged to the maximum KW's occurring on any hour of the month. No charge for the first 5 KW. I Exhibit III includes usage graphs of several existing RW E customers and a graph and associated tabulation of bills with the above-listed rate schedules. The TOS rate 16 very ~ I comparable to the RW rate for customers who have the peak requirements on the weekend and do not exceed 201 of that peak during Denton's system peak usage time. ) ~i i I~ v 4 }t r P ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE ALTERNATIVE A possible administrative approach would be to conduct an on-site investigation of each customer who requests the "Weekend Use" rate and test or estimate their proposed summer peak usage as compared to their non-peak usage, and if their summer peak usage was less that 501 of the non-peak rateage, they would be allowed on the "Weekend Use" rate, would be the s as the existing Religious worship rate but would have a 131 $ increase to the Demand cost, On all such customers, the Utility would install a time of use meter which would require a $10 per month increase in the Facility Charge. If, during the months of June, July, August } and September, the customers "on peak" demand exceeded the off peak demand by 501, the customer would be automatically transferred to the GS rate unti- the following June billing when E they would be automatically transferred to the "Weekend Use I rate provided they did not exceed the 501 rule. ± The Utility could, for a fee, also install a sensor device on the meter so that if peak hour usage approached the 501 rule, it could either provide an alarm at a designated location or automatically shut down selected large loads to prevent exceedlny the 501 rule. The Utilit devices. The pcustomer mustidinstall e their oownsalarmhortload control system that operates from signals produced by the device on the meter. AGENCIES AFFECTED Citizens of Denton, Church Organizations, City Council, Public Utilities Board, Legal Department. FISCAL SUMMARY Transferring all RW customers to the GS rate would increase revenues by $75,465. Customers with less than 25-30 KW will experience a reduction in electric bills; larger customers will experience increases from 20-301. Providing a "Time of Use" rate will provide approximately the same revenue for "weekend use" tifetheiruuseoisdsimilar in rates of 2 200-3030%1 more than presently to Denton's commercial customers. i f t o., r~ i 4 Utilizing an "Administrative" solution would have no change in Denton's revenues or to the customers provided they qualified under the 50% rule. Both latter alternatives would require installation of a $700 electric meter but this cost would be recovered via the $10/month higher facility charge, 'ape ally, 3 Ll yd V. Harrell City Manager II Preparod/Appr ved by: Nelson, Executive Director Department of Utilities Exhibit I Legal opinion II Rate . Schedules III Rate Comparisons IV Proposed Ordinance 4 E a ~ i I t r rte, • DRAFT SCHEDULE WK WEEKEND RATE APPLICATION Applicable to any commercial and industrial user whose maximum demand load occL,9 during the period from Friday at 12 midnight through Sunday at 12 midnight and does not experience a demand load III during the period from Sunday 12 midnight through Friday 12 midnight that exceeds 50% of the maximum demand load. Not applicable to resale service in any event, nor to temporr,ry, standby or supplementary service except in conjunction with applicable rider. 3 NET MONTHLY RATE d (1) Customer Facility Charge 25.00/30 days--Single Phase ! 30.00/30 days--Three Phase (2) Demand Charge $ 4.25/KW (first 5 KW not billed) { (3) Energy Charge First 700 KWH 7.500/KWH 3 All over 700 KWH 2,920/KWH (4) Energy Cost Adjustment Per Schedule ECA MINIMUM BILLING An amount equal to the demand charge as calculated below but ~I not less than fifty percent (50%) of the maximum monthly demand charge for an month during the preceding months of May through October plus 25/month for single phase service or $30/month for three phase service, per 30 day billing. TYPE OF SERVICE The City will supply single-phase service (or three-phase service if available at the point of delivery) at sixty (60) cycles and at any standard voltages available from the City's distribution system through one standard transformation. Where service of the type desired by the customer is not already available at the point of service, special contract arrangements between the City and the customer may be required prior to its being furnished, PAYMENT Bills are due when rendered and become past due if not paid within 15 calendar days from date of issuance. PAGE 1 ti 6496U:6 + EXHIBIT. -imp 4 s t i DETERMINATION OF DEMAND The demand shall be the KW supplied during the fifteen (15) minute period of maximum use during the current month as determined by the City's demand meter, but not less than 50% of the maximum monthly KW similarly determined during the previous billing months of May through October in the 12 months endi-tg with the current month. The KW demand used for billing shall be adjusted by subtracting 5 KW. The adjusted KW demand will subsequently be used for billing for the demand portion of tho utilitiy bill. In no e case, shall pilled demand be less than 0 KW. SPECIAL FACILITIES r All services which require special facilities in order to meet customer's service requirements shall be provided subject to the special facilities rider. a PRORATION OF UTILITY BILLS y Bill.ng for consumption and demand shall be calculated on a 30-day basis and prorated for longer or shorter billing period. (a) Billing for the Facility Charge shall be based on 12 billings annually. Formula: Actual days In reading period x customer charge ENERGY COST ADJUSTMENT A charge per XWH of energy taken for fuel cost calculated in accsordance with Schedule ECA. t A 1 11 PAGE 2 6496U:1 a i yr¢aa.I~ {fir wy[ir~ i I! . ' rw r i 01 b f I'n . r. DRAFT* SCHEDULE TGS GENERAL SERVICE TIME OF USE (TGS) APPLICATION Applicable e to any supplied at one poiand nt of industrial delivery users and measured through one meter who have peak electrical loads during weekends or off peak hours, <<ny Not applicable to resale service in any event, nor to temporary, standby or supplementary service except in conjunction with applicable rider. NET MONTHLY RATE (1) Customer Facility Charge 25.00/30 days--Single Phase 30.00/30 days---Three Phase (2) On-Peak Demand Charge $12.50/KW of On-Peak Demand a (3) System Demand Charge $ 4.00/xw of system Demand (4) Energy Charge $ 0.01/KWH (5) Energy Cost Adjustment Per Schedule ECA MINIMUM BILLING The minimum monthly bill shall bt the sum of the Customer g Facility Charge, the On-Peak Demand Charge, and the System Demand charge but not less than 701 of the maximum monthly total demand charge for any month during the preceeding months of May through October. TYPE OF SERVICE ` Secondary service available to commercial and industrial customers. 1 The City will supply single-phase service (or three-phase service if available at the point of delivery) at sixty (60) cycles j and at any standard voltages available from the City's distribution ` system through one standard transformation. Where service of the h of service, special contract arrangements between ache City the point customer may be required prior to its being furnished. DETERMINATION OF ON-PEAK DEMAND The on-peak demand shall be the maximum KW demand supplied ! during th3 fifteen (15) minute period of maximum use during the F ` on-peak hours as recorded by the City's demand meter and adjusted for power factor, but not less than one hundred percent (1001) of the maximum on-peak demand similarly determined during the previous billing months of June through September In the twelve (12) months ending with the current month. XH I BIT ~ PAGE ONE 6496U:5 `r i `NN r ' Mp YUy Aj■w I r" 40 t F} i i 7 i DETERMINATION Of SYSTEM DEMAND The system demand shall be the maximum Ku demand supplied during the fifteen (15) minute period of maximum use as Cecorded by the city's demand meter and adjusted foe power factor, but not less than seventy percent (701) of the maximum system demand similarly determined during the previous billing months of June through September in the twelve (12) months ending with the current month, POWER FACTOR PENALTY The City reserves the right to determine the power factor of the customer's Installation served during periods at maximum demand or by measurement of the average power factor tot the monthly billing period. It the power factor is below ninety percent (901) on-peak and average demand for the demand for billing pucposss will be determined by multiplying the unadjusted billing demand by ninety percent (901) and dividing by the determined power factor. DEFINITION Of ON-PEAK HOURS The City's on-peak hours, foe the Qucpose of this cape schedules are designated ad b4tAt !Cots 1100 I,M, to 0100 PA, each Manday th:ough Friday, staring on June 1 and continuing through September 20 each year, The City's on-peak hours may be changed from time to time and the customer will be notified twelve (12) months prior to suds changes become effective, DEFINITION OF Oft-PSAR HOURS { The City's off-peak hours, toe the purpose of this rate schedule, shall be all hours not designated as on-peak hours. i SUPPLEMENTAL P011RR RMA Customers requesting standby or supplementary power shall be allowed service under this rate sehedulsr however, the determination of system demand shall be adjusted to reads The system demand shall be the sus 49 the maximum Kai demand supplied during the fifteen (15) minute period of maximum use as recorded by the city's demand alter plus the KW nameplate rating(s) of the customer's generator(s), In the event the customer's generator(s) is/are oft-llae at the time of the establishment of the maximum system demand, the KW nameplate rating of the generator(s) unavailable for service shell be removed from the determination of the system demand. In no event shall the system demand be less than seventy percent (70%) of the maximum system demand similarly determined during the previous billing months of June through - September in the twelve (121 months ending with the current month, ~f. / - r r ~t t E SPECIAL FACILITIES All services which requlrelapecial facilities to order to meet the customer's service requirements shall l provided subject et special facilities rider. PRORATION OF UTILITY BILLS (a) Silling for the Facility Charge shall be based on 12 billings ann6ally using the following formulas Actual da s in read n e d x Customer Charge (b) Billing for demand shall be calculated on a 30-day-ac. month basis and pro rated for longer or shorter billing periods using the following formulas A d a x KW Demand x Aats ENERGY COST ADJUSTMtMT t A charge per AWH of energy taken for fuel cost calculated in accordance with Schedule I.C.A. PAT (ills are due when readJrsd, and become 4ithln 15 calendar days from date of issuance. past due if not paid { I ~ ` 1 Fi 1 F,. n N Y AVERAGE CENTS KW-H P 4 ~ ` s m o ~ ~ m ~ I v , ~ N ~ m i i J Awl I t y s x t q x k 4`''r A, QQo C Cp Q Ov m P P N V A N p w{ 0 F ~ ~ v 3 Z ~ N 1 ' i 1 i AVERAGE CENTS KV M Y` P P P O P P P P P P P p Q ~ ; $ 8 Q ~ ro ~ n a a. ~ m o 133 i o j 1 n r r m t ~ m i z a ' It I Ims a I p: CCITY-M-- 4fffFp COUNCIL 11 Ll I ~o~,~ao pad, ~ i S N 1 pQ ~ a I i Ole y wrw~ r ti r r v ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DENTON, TEXAS, AMENDING THE SCHEDULE OF ELECTRIC RATES BY DELETING SCHEDULE RW (RELIGIOUS WORSHIP); BY ADOPTING A NEW SCHEDULE TGS (GENERAL SERVICE TIME OF USE RATE); AND PROVIDING FOR AND EFFECTIVE DATE. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DENTON HEREBY ORDAINS: r SECTION 1. That the existing Schedule of Rates for electrical services, as adopted by Ordinance No. 89-122 is amended by deleting Schedule RW (Religious Worship). GECTION II. That the Schedule of Rates for electrical ser- vices, as adopted by Ordinance No. 89-122, is amended by adding a new Schedule TGS (General Service Time of Use Rate), a copy of which is attched hereto and incorporated by reference herein. Q ECjION III. That this ordinance shall become effective immediately upon its passage and approval. PASSED AND APPROVED this the day of , 1990. ;I BOB CASTLEBERRY, MAYOR 'v ATTEST: JENNIFER WALTERS, CITY SECRETARY BY: APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORM: DEBRA A. DRAYOVITCH, CITY ATTORNEY `f' f / r BY., ~X r y i CITY Err= COUNCIL a 4 t Oi YQJ a T M, °ooeeaacaa~' ` 1 7 F ORDINANCE NO. AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF DENTON, TEXAS, AMENDING THE SCHEDULE OF ELECTRIC RATES BY DELETING SCHEDULE RW (RELIGIOUS WORSHIP) ; BY ADOPTING A NEW SCHEDULE WK (WEEKEND RATE); AND PROVIDING FOR AND EFFECTIVE DATE. THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DENTON HEREBY ORDAINS: SECTION I. That the existing Schedule of Rates for electrical services, as adopted by ordinance No. 89-122 is amended by deleting Schedule RW (Religious Worship). SECTION II. That the Schedule of Rates for electrical ser- vices, as adopted by Ordinance No. 89-122, is amended by adding a new Schedule WK (Weekend Rate), a copy of which is attched hereto and incorporated by reference herein. 'c SECTION III. That this ordinance shall become effective immediately upon its passage and approval. J PASSED AND APPROVED this the day of , 1990. + { BOB CASTLEBERRY; MAYOR ) ATTEST: l JENNIFER WALTERS, CITY SECRETARY x I BY: APPROVED AS TO LEGAL FORM: i DEBRA A. DRAYOVITCH, CITY ATTORNEY BY: r 1 i 1 ~ ME } ~ z z I~ a V 71 1 CITY COUNCIL k TTT i 1 t d ~~ooeooLO~° I a s r. A CITY OF' DENTON MEMORANDUM DATE: October 19, 1990 TO: Mayor and City Council FROM. Lloyd V. Harrell, City Manager SUBJECT: RESULTS OF ISM EXECUTIVE PLANNING SEMINAR As you may recall, the City's Executive Staff, along with the Personnel and Information Services Director, participated in an Executive Planning Seminar provided by IBM on July 24th, 25th and 26th. ISM provided the complementary training to give our staff strategic planning skills that will strengthen the council- management team and help us jointly implement initiatives that will guarantee future organizational success. While it would have been ideal to have had Council along to participate and provide immediate feedback, it would almost impossible for everyone to devote the required time to the task. Therefore, it is hoped that our strong sense of teamwork allowed the staff to reflect Council sentiments. This was our intention. The session had several objectives. The first was to develop a foundation and common terms for planning so that we could incorporate strategic planning into our everyday organizational life. The second was to develop visions of a successful city organization at the planning horizon 1995 based on the common sense of direction that Council and staff have worked together to accomplish. Third was to develop or refine a mission statement I that will enable us to be successful. Fourth was to identify strategic opportunities to achieving success by evaluating our governmental competitors, service markets and service menu. The a 3 fifth and final objective was to introduce high impact planning to activate these changes. 9 } These objectives were met by undertaking three days of intensive work (averaging 10 hours per day) involving an assessment of the current organization, identifying strengths and weaknesses, seeking opportunities to do new and better work and formulating strategies to pursue those future opportunitie3. i The session provided numerous benefits for the management staff. We were able to build consensus on where the organization currently is, consensus and direction on where the organization wants to be, and agreement on the strategic opportunities that we feel will lead to future success. The next step is to make sure that we as managers are on target, with City Council's direction, F . ; r ~a j 1 b ` Memo to Mayor and Council IBM Executive Planning Seminar Page 2. regarding the outcomes of the session. Attached is the outcome of the session. Attachment I includes a mission Statement that we believe best articulates where City Council and staff would like to be in five years. This is followed by a list of five success elements that we feel are necessary to make the mission statement a reality. These success elements then outline strategies which will allow us to take advantage of opportunities and accomplish our goals. Attachment II is a package of other materials that provide detail to the mission statement, success elements and strategies. It is i a paper trail of the process that we undertook to establish our goals. The Executive Staff has met with the Department Directors to discuss the results of the session. They concur with our assessments and are prepared to begin work on action plans. However your review and approval is needed in order to ensure that we are properly articulating the desires of the Council. We are prepared to visit any of these subjects and make any revisions that s you deem necessary. Since ly, Lie~, V. Harye 1 Ci, aanager Attachments f i i i e i 0 r ATTACHMENT I,_ RESULTS OF THE IBM EXECUTIVE PLANNING SEMINAR OUR MISSIO , To be a leader among cities in delivering outstanding auality services and products through citizen involvement, i novation and efficient use of resources. 1 SUCCESS ELEMENTS AND STRATEGIES FOR 1925. To be successful and achieve these ends we are committed to: o Involve pitizens and businesses to help deliver services Create neighborhood and business owner organizations Implement a volunteer program i Implem•.vit an "Adopt-A- Program" J - Implement a work release program i Implement training programs for citizens that will reduce city costs and/or improve service delivery 1 o Aggressively involve citizens in mutual goal setting process of the selection an deli erv_ of services and products - Conduct citizen surveys j - Initiate a comprehensive neighborhood planning program Establish a 2000 Committee Conduct periodic town meetings Perform the function of a public information officer i , I ; 1 Y I A 4 f dew... s r:c• e , d ' V S o Identify and S3NZleme^t new revenue sources Implement a demand side energy and water program Implement a drainage utility Implement special and public improvement districts Establish payments in lieu-of-taxes and other state aid o B~eme a uniaue and sn e~o al city in the metromlex Promote unique architecture s { Aggressively market University activities and i opportunities - Emphasize cultural attractions - Promote entryway regulations and beautification programs - Implement greenbelt including water feature in Civic Center Park - Make Jazz Feat and Festival of Lights regional events o Expand and diversify logal economy by a trutina and expanding destr ble commereia~industrial and education enterprises. Develop partnerships with large developers 1 Locate a research center in the City limits Establish an aggressive marketing program including the I-35 corridor - Complete utility expansion program 1 I - Implement an aggressive business retention program e S Complete Hwy 2499 arnl Loop 288 Y ~ l I 1 a r I 1 j { i f Y 6 i I q; S 11 r CITY OF DENTON EXECUTIVE STRATEGY SESSION i July 21-26, 1990 1 'I I 'a i r; I I 1 i ~J 3 T - , Ile L 1 r; I` I r~ 6 - r ENTITY DEFINITION i Our Strategy Ses3ion will consider/include this part of our Enterprise. City of Denton Municipal Corporation I y Specifically including: All I Specifically excluding: None Our planning horizon will be 5 years: 1995 f 4 ~ j s I Mfr I I M1 II y !I 1 a If{ R i PARTICIPANT'S EXPECTATIONS Our expectations for the session are to: o Game plan for organization o See how everyone functions together o See how mission changes 1 o See how one year's strategic plans differ from session # 1 results o Consensus of 'Vision for 1995' o Have lots of visions - How will we come to grips with limited funds yy o Acknowledge needs of others i o Commitment to fulfill needs of others as beat as possible o Want to see way to measure how we are doing a 4 o Better define who carries what burden and when o Gain insight and understanding of other players - Allocate people/assets to do the job r ff~ f ~ i } r 1 i I t • Y I r• ' a e I t , PRODUCTS I What are our PRODUCTS today? o Water o Electricity o Waste water r o Public health, safety, and welfare o Curbs, streets, sidewalks o Parks o Tax bills` I o Transportation systems o Reports/information o Libraries o Recreation centers i 41 Flood condition, drainage I 1I { ~J 1 ~ J a I a a f ~t ell- -cwr i i~ •awc t 1 r SERVICES What are our SERVICES today? o Police protection o Fire and emergency medical o Leisure services o Law enforcement o Airport services a o Solid waste o Energy and water conservation o Environmental protection o Land use o Economic development assistance o Code enforcement o Historical preservation o Downtown revitalization o Housing rehabilitation h o Governance t o Development services z f ' a y~ FF Q 3 t MARKETS What are out MARKETS today? o Citizens of Denton r o Outside developers d o Relocating corporations o Rate payers o E.T.J. area 4 { 14 1 o Taxpayers o Tourists o University students o People will work and go to school in Denton o Other cities (Electric) o County region (Water) o Bond holders o Potential job applicants 1 A. i I i IJ I 3 APPROACHES I What are our APPROACHES today? I i o Quality service P o Monopoly 7 j o Lost based pricing j o mandate/legislate 1 o Find out what the customer wants I o Purchase new technology o Generate data i o Advertising o Networking o Municipal elections o Market driven responses { f o Squeaky wheel ' 1 o Cut deals s + `I 1 J I i I I i I I I 1 4 r r INDUSTRY What INDUSTRY are we in today? j o Local government o Utilities o Transportation 1 o Entertainment o Medical o Security o Finance o Development o Information i~ I ,a 5 q r t .y f FUTURE ENVIRONMENT Stake in the Ground rI o More people o Higher rate of growth 1 o Higher energy costs ' t o Greater racial diversity s o Higher labor costs o significant environmental concerns 1 o Greater federal and state mandate o Less federal money t o Older work force o Higher medical costs o Higher housing costs o Broader tax base o More communication with the metroplex o More residents o Different local politicians j o Bigger difference between have's and have not's o Much larger university population o More privitization o Mix changing - Less university dominance I o Less farm land o Major regional utility organization o 2499 is done I a ' I Z Y q 1 p -snap ~pA..r f y y,. Q e i FUTURE ENVIRONMENT u Page 2 i o Greater child care needs of employees o Older infrastructure o More retail business i r o More conservative politics o More resistance to rate and tax increases h o More competitive electric rates ti F „r i~ ix s: i fi66~ l J COMPETITIVE FORCES IN OUR INDUSTRY TODAY r A. Traditional Rivals -Other cities -Ft. Worth -Plano -Other governmental agencies -Other utilities -Private enterprise -Universities B. New Entrants -Corinth -Upper Trinity River Water District -Planned communities -Lake Ray Roberts -Big developers C. Substitutes -Product recycling -Upper Trinity River Water District -Co-generation -Private security -Sprinkler systems -Private enterprise j D. Regulatory Agencies 1 -Civil Service Commission -City Council -Boards and Commissions -Courts -Audits E. Suppliers -Gas companies -TMPA J -City of Dallas -Telephone companies -Appraisal District Paper companies -Texas Utilities -Developers j Taxpayers f s I i I ell- 1 .rrl i COMPETITIVE FuRCES Page 2 F. Consumers -Rate payers -Home owners -Students -f:itizens -Other cities -Denton County -School District -University Upper Trinity River Water District -Developers -Business owners -Industries Tourists i -Development -Citizen groups -Chamber of Commerce y , I fi i` f (`1 • 4 F- { I' eF I. M 6 I i f ' yr i i! 4 BUYER VALUE In our industry today, what are the sources of BUYER VALUE? o Monopoly o Prompt response o Courtesy i ti o Empathy o High quality e' o Fix it fight I o Reliability i o Aesthetics o Pride o Extra service - No extra cost o Hard work I o Effort - Image o Financial responsibility o Trust o Accessibility o minimum bureaucracy F r o Efficiency i j i J of I I c ~ i J ,l l Ole- s ut d ~ qw] I f $ ~ S ~3w COMPETITIVE STRATEGY i Our COMPETITIVE STRATEGY today is: Citizens and Business in Denton Whole Market i ti Cost Leadership Differentiation } i s Focus (Differs Some) 1 f I Y a G A' I 1 Ja( i ~ e4. r INDUSTRY STRUCTURE Key characteristics of our industry's STRUCTURE today: o Stable - need a charter o Can't easily start your own city o High investment required n,e o High labor intensive o People important 1 o Experience to follow a a o Operational information critical o Business conditions change rapidly g o Elections can change all o Groups have intense interests o Everyone watches what you do o Expectations high - easy to second guess t i Y~ ` o Diverse expectations Council vs Staff o Development business 'Poker" 4 o Government risk taking like chess - Could lose the game ` not just the hand / f I ~ N ~r f Ae p i y ji 1 i I S I I i~ l Y S d r'IaYy I, 1 d VALUE SYSTEM I For our enterprise, who composes the VALUE SYSTEM today? o Suppliers: o Channels: -TMPP -Contractors -Citizen committees -News media -Council -Boards -Chamber of Commerce -Citizens -Other advertising -Regulatory agencies -Neighborhood groups -Youth sports leagues $ o Consumers: t~ i j J g Mimi s SMALL GROUP ASSIGNMENTS 'Reach for the sky' John Lloyd Tom 'If it is to be, it is up to me' Betty Bob Jesus 'Obstacles are what you see when you take your eyes off the goal' Debra Frank Gary Rick 1 f. P E tiff I' 1 rvrr~ t rY, MISSION STATEMENT Our MISSION is to be a leader among cities in delivering outstanding quality services a.id produ.ts to all citizens through innovative and efficient use of resources. i We will achieve this throughs nrsiT o Developing a strong and diverse economy o Providing services in response to the citizens' needs } o Fostering citizen participation s' o Developing and recognizing employees o Enhancing citizen trust and respect for city government 'p o Providing a safe, attractive and unique community } we will measure our achievement/progress by: o Increase in tax base o Citizen satisfaction o Bond pt,kage approval o City election results i o Recognition and awards by peer organizations o Improved employee productivity f i ~fylr !t M~ Yl`■ 1 1 C 1 w 1 1 i 9 ' pert e, 7 y Y THREATS Rivals - 1995 o other cities will compete with us for unannexed land o Others will get reg utility - be better positioned to get tax base vtr o Fight over tax dollars with other tax districts t o Health care costs o other utilities take away our share o Dual certified electric areas o Shrinking of traditional resources o General federal and state mandates without money (social, transportation, environmental, etc") o Aging infrastructure o Political movement successful - Against tax increases Suppliers_- 1995 ~e o Pressure to extend services to developers o Reduce "Scft Services" to reduce tax o .sigh price of supplies and commodities wt need to operate o ,sigh coats of people o High coats of insurance coverage "i o People will sue us more J k 11 o Lone Star Gas monopoly on gas supply will continue substitutes - 1995 o Independent power suppliers and co-generation will take away our big load 1 i t THREATS Page 2 Regulatory Agencies - 1995 o Increasing mandates o Increasing costs of meeting mandates o Less ability to make decisions about what we want to do ~y - us being told what to do by the courts i o Cities home rule authority will erode o Labor unions will come into the city o We will have to pay for cleaner air and water New Entrants - 1995 +i o Planned communities may attract the 'Have's' f o Argyle for industrial development along I-35 o Independent power producer steal our load o Private corporations provide services we traditionally provide y consumers - 1995 o Desire for greater services without increased costs o Greater Scrutiny of government operations nt o Greater strength of Denton Taxpayers' Association o increased emphasis of County resources toward South Denton County o Universities implement co-generation a o Decrease in decent and affordable housing o Lack of available c.Jital for development o students take over in City Council elections o Loss of reta:.l business to other areas r ,c ti 77 l ,y THREATS Page 3 i o Other cities compete for industries with increasing success o Chamber of Commerce becomes increasingly influenced by Denton Taxpayers' Association o School District just 'looks out for itself' o Increase in autonomy attitude of universities o Greater drug related crimes Y o Desire for senior programs and services o Loss of oomsntum in beautification legislation o sack-lash to increased building costs - caused by government regulations S o Greater student and worker commuting I f x 3 a a "i ..,j W~ 1 Z I OPPORTUNITIES Rivals - 1995 o Many alternative energy markets o Regional utility must come to Denton o Work with Ft. Worth aggressively to develop the 1-35 corridor o Wellness program3 are successful , r o Private waste collection dumps k o Build industries around knowledge base of universities °I o Utilize our universities for technical and professional development of our people i o Expand resource base by implementing storm water utility o more people unwilling to live in metroplex o secure lien/tax payments fro, state for university J o Influence state civil service law to our advantage 1 M o Computer automation equipment cheap enough for everyone o Stable, innovative, creative work force in the h organization 3 o Master planning on 'Green Belt' done o They are running out of reasonably priced land for prime industrial development o Working, trustful relationships with big developers suppliers - 1995 o Taxpayers willing to fund infrastructure improvements { via bonds o impact fees o Attract labor force of other cities to work in ours 1 NIC ~W r OPPORTUNITIES Page 2 s Suppliers - 1995 (continued) o Get more contractors to locate in our area - Bid on city contracts o TMPA's diverse energy system - negotiating strength (we can use it for our own supplies) o Upper Trinity River Water District will operate a solid waste incineration plant r, o Greater communication - telephone and information - link up with metroplex o Improve transportation system through highway department Substitutes - 1995 i o More manufacturers of recyclable products o Apply technology used by banking to our Customer Service and Cashiering o More regional governments o Technology to replace people 1 j o More intergovernmental cooperation ` o wider use of sprinkler systems 1 o Greater use of public mass transportation I o Greater proliferation of neighborhood groups to provide service - I o Developers will look at long range use of land Bring us their needs o Developers install utilities - We do not have to 1 o Federal of Engineers run more government/Corp oto us recreation o Get State Department of Wildlife to the city green L,, 1t - With green belt between the lakes o start plans/programs for major recreational park 4 o More citizen involvement in beautification - Less cost to us a I , a k i OPPORTUNITIES Page 3 r Substitutes - 1995 (continued) o Greater use of jail inmates in maintenance activities o Main street program funded by public improvement district and run by non-profit corporation o Low/non-profit housing by non-profit corporation Regulatory Agencies - 1995 o State enabling legislation will 'Loosen +:p" giving us more flexibility 3 Y o State legislative will provide more pass-through funds to attract business o More state aid in general o Some legislation will help us rid our organization of undesirable influences (drugs, alcohol, etc,) o Continue supervisor/management training programs - keep unions out o we will have cleaner air and water - due to legislation o Greater involvenent by staff with regulatory agencies F and the legislature , o Less air traffic flying over Denton New Entrants - 1995 o Solid waatel landfill done by Upper Trinity River Water District - Water supply, drainage o Buy peak power from independent power producers o Developers pay for things we would have to g o New people move in and change the politics of Denton 9 o Federal government in national health insurance , F' J 1r'- i w/.6 I I r F OPPORTUNITIES " Page 4 c Consumers - 1995 t ti o Electronic products sold to our citizens o 24 hour City Hall o Better education through electronic media o Reduce labor costs through automation i o Greater entertainment industry due to university students o More competitive electric rates o Grater involvement of citizens in programs, etc, o Greater working relationship with chamber of Commerce, civic groups, neighborhood organizations o Nurture employees to become active citizens too ' o Citizens more receptive to government involvement and i government pcograms fl o Large developers 'Buy in' to our mission and further it § o Aggressive marketing program for economic development stabilize funding for partnership o Greater cultural, racial and social involvement - 1 Actively working with the citizens o The community 'Buys in' to the mission' I o We will have 60% of the home business in summer sense programs o Sale of electric capacity/energy to markets in Texas o Sale of water/waste water service/environmental services/expertise to tipper Trinity River Water District N o Reap results of DARE Program (less crime) o Implementation of residential sprinkler systems G; o Greater desire to use public transportation `e i 1 4 4 1 l l 6 1 1 i 1 2 1 ra1`.'AIf 1 Z WEAKNESSES o We are still understaffed o Limited resources o we still have Civil Service constraints - our employees want this o Lack of convention facilities s` o Squeaky wheel still gets the grease ; p~ E i I i 1 j i ~gylry/~Yil~ l I I I MW^S I F~' a }t1 STRENGTHS o GIS will be implemented o We are effectively utilizing information technology to meet our mission o We are better utilizing volunteers in the community o Strong, professional work force o Improved, stronger and decentralized human resources management services o Improved human resource management information o Have in place a succession and manpower plan r o Strong and progressive management team o Outstanding professional development program for all employees o Strong employee assistance program] wellness I ~ o Strong recognition compensation and benefits programs o New municipal facilities and adequate space for many offices I a o Consistent implementation of the Strategic Action Plan o Knowledgeable and Informed City Council o Diversified work force reflecting the makeup of the community 4 o Strong employee involvement r program i o No illiteracy among City employees o Good computer literacy among City employees o Greater physical health among City employees S1 I j o Strong political leadership o Newly constructed water, waste water and electric facilities o Low accident rate 0 Acceptable level of sick leave usage I' narvan~ i f I i J CONSUMERS o Contract with neighborhood groups -Maintain right-of-ways -Litter pick-up -code enforcement -Right-of-way grass cutting/beautification -Crime watch o Incentives to reduce demand a0`~ -Side electric -Summer sense -High efficiency light bulbs -Insulation o Incentives to reduce water/waste water t o Recycling programs o Expand voluntary recycling p o Volunteers to supplement city work force -Library page -Parks maintenance ~ -Crossing guards -Senior Center -Recreation Center -RSVP -Jail in-mates -Denton County Taxpayers' Association o Intergovernmental cooperation s" -Joint purchasing program -Police -Industrial recruitment -Computer training City employees a -Common market program - 1-35 with Argyle ;y o Customer Incentives to transmit meter reading (no meter reader) ,i -Information to turn on/off utilities -Developers call in order for inspections o Develop and use Special Improvement Districts' -Neighborhood needs: Flooding Maintaining and landscaping o Metropolitan parks district o County-wide Library System 1 I 5 CONSUMERS Page 2 rte,, o Neighborhood planning and self-help o Establish long term contracts with agencies such as TMPA, UTRWD o Adopt an eye sore o Use neighborhood groups, special interest groups to specify specific servicea (rather than using shotgun approach) o Christmas catalog t o Citizen strategic planning task force i ~I 1 ~ i a ,z .sr / I 1 /I F C. 66} r CHANNELS o Commit staff involvement in Chamber of Commerce o Commitment to customer relations training to all city employees o Commitment to more planning/needs/service delivery issues meetings (dialogue) with neighborhood groups and associations I o More favorable marketing delivery of electric capacity/energy thru TMPP/TMPA 14 1 o Review contract arrangement for infrastructure construction -and maintenance Y o Agreement with neighborhood groups for neighborhood watch programs o strong economic development marketing program o Prompt creation Business Association -Mall -Denton Center i o Data transfer over phone lines o Expertise to SPAN in running transportation syetem r o more opportunity for suppliers to locate within the city o Lack of competition - others coma to Denton o Contract on l+jrge scale for business supplies and material i I w st ; I` M l { 1 a --w- - - - Ile- a j T WC^N~ I .:u t; i SUPPLIERS o By contract o By contracted or other agreement with developers to fund infrastructure and parks (buy into City's mission) o, Get taxpayers to supply labor/materials for f products/seminars o Talk to our suppliers and their "network' to develop in Denton o Cooperate with others whc, have same suppliers to effect ) } volume discounts { o Work with Appraisal District f.o buy into GIS o Utilize 'high tech' roles for negotiating lowest costa o Utilize multi-year contracts for controlling inflation factors o Get other suppliers to give special rates to entice new industrial development o Provide Appraisal District data to public developers at City Hall o Purchase recycled products o Buy more spot gas from independent gas producers o Agreement with RTC to provide low cost, vacant, housing units for rehab into low-moderate income housing 1 (RiFlI1]■ ~I '4 i~t ryp~~■ 1 ES4 ~I i r t SUCCESS ELEMENTS (FINAL LIST) For us to be successful, we have the opportu,tity to: A. involve citizens and businesses to help deliver services i B. Aggressively involve citizens in selecting services # and products } C. Identify and implement new alternative revenue sources D. Become the unique and special city in the metroplex E. Expand and diversify the local economy by attracting and expanding desirable commercial, industrial and educational enterprises 1 ii { P { 'Ii 1 r ~I rw s r SUCCESS ELEMENTS (INITIAL LIST) A. Involve citizens and businesses to help deliver services. 8. Communicate mission and activities to citizen/bus - involve. C. Capitalize on University presence in Denton. >i D. Partnerships - public/private, develop that will help a mission. { E. Alternative revenue sources, identify and implement. f F. ?romote Denton I/D, develop, promote characteristics. G. Quality all service minimum cost plus maximize D reliability. H. Attract enterprises desirable commercial expand economy by 1. Expand existing bus help. J. Links with metroplex cities 0 improve trans plus communication. K. Partnership focus all major decisions implement. L. Promote technology efficient use of aggressively. M. best work force of any city - trained motivated. i i I~ i ,i I f I r CITY OF DENTON STRATEGIES FOR 1995 LIST ENTIRE GROUP A. Develop partnerships with large developers B. Locate research center in the City limits { C. theaI135hW cor idor ssive mrrketing program including D. Complete 2490 and Loop 288 E. Complete utility expansion program 1 F. Implement an aggressive business retention program G. Conduct citizen surveys H. Create neighborhood and business owner organizations 1. Initiate a comprehensive neighborhood planning program J. Establish a 2000 committee I K. Conduct periodic town meetings L. Perform the function of a public information office 4 ~ M. Implement a volunteer program N. Aggressively implement a demand side energy and water I~ program I 'f 0. Implement 'Adopt a Program' ` P. Implement a work release program I Q. Implement training programs for citizens which will i I reduce Ci y t costs and/or improve service delivery R. Implement a drainage utility S. Implement special and public improvement districts T. Implement 1/2 cent sales tax U. sell services to external entities V. Implement impact fees i .y ~ ;.rc 1 {i~`pM a Now~ C e STRAGEGIES FOR 1995 Page 2 ~(rc W. Establish payments in lieu of taxes and other state aid r X. Emphasize cultural attractions Y. Aggressively promote beautification programs and entryway regulations Zr Implement green belt including water feature in Civic Center Park a. Make Jazz Fest and Festival of Lights regional events b. Promote unique architecture r cr Aggressively market university activities and opportunities? i 7 J 4 f COMPETITIVE FORCES IMPORTANCE TODAY t 1 2 5 A. Rivals 1 5 4 B. Entrants 2 6 Z C. Substitutes 1 b 3 D. Agencies 2 9 t I E. Suppliers 1 5 4 _ F. Consumers 1 4 i 9 3 r i~ f { i a ei I 4WJ I Y Fk IC'F s MISSION STATEMENT ASSESSMENT 1 2 4 5 6 7 A. Challenging 1 2 7 B. Committed 1 3 6 C. Confident 1 1 1 4 3 I A I } f x I! 1 ~r 1 a f~ i 1 F ' J !'I v 1760s I Y.F City of Denton 3trategiee for 1995 ENTIRE GROUP I 100 + - - - - + - - - - + - - - - + - - - - + w p I I I c I h 0 i r 75 + + + + R24+ c t h a I l e F ANTW n 1 I DHSY Z i t. 50+----+----+--G--Uav---+ t s I I H 0 t I I c j I m o I I G 0 25 + + +K YL+ + 's r 1 I I e 9 b 9 I Pj 5 0 + - - - - + - - - - - - I 1 2 3 4 5 Improvement needed to be eucceeeful Fioure 0-0-A Voters = 10 DII/III RUTS ,055 07.21.1110 Vitt lots Date = St1Af1 l?A 01.11.1110 Borg late Date a St1Al8 M 02.11.1110 Vote letloee MATS ."I lattlti;sata , 110ps JAB i I ~I ` i 1 I V., 4 1 _ -TWA ii II i a i 1 Data for Figure 0-0-A vbicb 11 1or1 Aproveltat m1ad reportaat to 1991 to be Incc111fa1 Group Gr;ap 70to It11 Average Average f 11,0 1.1 A Partambipl with Iu4a devllmrs, develop b 11511rcb clater in 12,0 {.I city tioltl, locate 4 C sgrketial progris, li•0 1.1 egressin utgblUb liol I•i1 corridor D 2190 aid Loop 211, 11.0 1.f J rosplete Dtitity eepaalias 69.4 1.1 progru, cosplltl I f baliaeu rltlatiaa 6S•0 3.1 progru, 11pluert to alrelelve 0 citirea 14tvill. loll coadnet 1 1e14bborbacd1Da10ra 11,0 1 0 1 I or411ialticat, , k create t 1 I60barb'd Plam. 14.0 1.1 Proqul, ioitieta 1 casprelueive { ! 2400 Coulttu, 11,4 1.0 utgbltlb 1 I Ion 944 logs, 21.0 l,1 coadact periodic j Z Pablic Into MICA 11.4 7.1 perfors fuctioee oI g ' M 9ollateer Proqus ILO f,l 11Pllelat 1 I onlad fide uer4y 1l,0 1.1 gad Ater proffill IgtllplHly llplelt i r z c t Data for Figure 0-0-A a flit! Sa lorl igprovl11lt a11did Imitlat to 1155 to bl larcllliol Group Group Yotl Itil a}rlrigl 11tripl Adopt Ilnlca 13.0 1,3 Prooru, Up1mat 'x I fort raliatl Proq. I.0 7.1 Iapllglot € 0 Trilailq promil 31,0 111 for Citimi, liplaNat D 0rl13114 0tilitf 76.0 116 1lP]il11t 1 g Ilprorirllt dilt'l 55.0 1.1 101clll lad public tapiuiat t 80.005 11111 tit, fa•0 (15 , IlpI1111t I u garlon to Irtua1 13,0 {,p IvOlli, 0111 4~i !1 V Ilplct flit, a 1lP]uiot I710 f Itln•til 1 ottir ILO 1,6 ititl lid, litibllt i rlltiral ittrictlll 70,0 3,1 111 llpbuirl f gultSfiatSoa hoq 55,0 4.1 aid 11tr5ilr riq'l prooott I Craig kilt lgclidl Sl,a I,I gatat flititt Civic ctr It • Iipligigt ' l ligiolll !nett li,a I,g lair / tioltl gall to b him 1rclitictotl 1510 1,T . prolotl ; 4 I 'M / b k Y.N.. Mfa►t~ { \\Yy~ 1 ■fi Ii 6 V k Data for Figure 0-0-A r 0 Yhic! it Note bptoreuot Ieeded :Iportiot to 1995 to he enuetefel Rap Mop i s 'Dote It:I Average Antics e pnirueitf eotirtte OA opportneitiee urket i E ~ I k~ I i 1 i J WTI f r yJ4.. Yn}cj~ ry`! IE I i. • L% Mel 1 F V I I t I 1 ti e{ +I t F; i E F r r' I ` t E, FILE n I