2017-04-10 Agenda with Backup HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION
AGENDA
April 10,2017
The Historic Landmark Commission of the City of Denton,Texas will convene in a Work Session
on Monday, April 10, 2017 at 5:30 p.m. in the City Council Work Session Room at City Hall,
215 E. McKinney Street, Denton, Texas at which time the following items will be considered:
WORK SESSION
1. Receive a report and hold a discussion regarding the Jagoe House located at 2212 West Oak
Street.
2. Receive a report and hold a discussion regarding the status of the Historic Preservation
Ordinance update.
NOTE: The Historic Landmark Commission reserves the right to adjourn into a Closed Meeting on any item on
its Work Session or Regular Session agenda consistent with Chapter 551 of the Texas Government Code, as
amended, including without limitation, Sections 551.071-551.086 of the Texas Open Meetings Act.
Following the completion of the Work Session,the Historic Landmark Commission will convene
in a Regular Meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission in the City Council Work Session
Room, 215 E. McKinney at which time the following items will be considered:
REGULAR MEETING
1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:
A. U.S. Flag
B. Texas Flag
"Honor the Texas Flag—I pledge allegiance to thee, Texas one state under God, one and
indivisible."
2. CONSIDER APPROVAL OF THE HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION
MINUTES FOR:
A. January 9, 2016
3. ACTION ITEMS:
A. Determine whether the presented expenses resulted in a permanent improvement or
restoration of the landmarked property located at 2106 North Bell Avenue. The property is
within the Bell Avenue Conservation District and generally located at the intersection of
Historic Landmark Commission Agenda
April 10, 2017
Page 2 of 3
North Bell Avenue and East Sherman Drive. (COA16-0020, 2106 North Bell Avenue,
Roman McAllen)
B. Consider a preliminary application for Historic Landmark Designation for the property
located at 607 College Street, and make a recommendation regarding the appropriateness
of the property to proceed to a final application. (HL17-0004, 607 College Street, Roman
McAllen)
C. Consider a preliminary application for Historic Landmark Designation for the property
located at 917 Egan, and make a recommendation regarding the appropriateness of the
property to proceed to a final application. (HL17-0005, 917 Egan Street,Roman McAllen)
D. Consider making a recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Commission that the
O'Neil Ford Civic Complex, as defined by Resolution Number R92-040, be designated a
Historic Landmark. The O'Neil Ford Complex is bounded by Withers Street on the north,
Bell Avenue on the east,McKinney Street on the south and Austin and Oakland Streets on
the west. (HL17-0001, O'Neil Ford Civic Complex, Roman McAllen)
E. Consider approval of the procedures for awarding the Historic Property of the Month
Awards.
4. ITEMS FOR INDIVIDUAL CONSIDERATION:
A. Receive a report, hold a discussion and select a Historic Property of the Month.
5. HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION PROJECT MATRIX
A. Historic Landmark Commission project matrix.
6. CONCLUDING ITEMS:
A. Under Section 551.042 of the Texas Open Meetings Act, respond to inquiries from the
Historic Landmark Commission or the public with specific factual information or
recitation of policy,or accept a proposal to place the matter on the agenda for an upcoming
meeting and under Section 551.0415 of the Texas Open Meetings Act, provide reports
about items of community interest regarding which no action will be taken, to include:
expressions of thanks, congratulations, or condolence; information regarding holiday
schedules; an honorary or salutary recognition of a public official, public employee, or
other citizen; a reminder about an upcoming event organized or sponsored by the
governing body; information regarding a social, ceremonial, or community event
organized or sponsored by an entity other than the governing body that was attended or is
scheduled to be attended by a member of the governing body or an official or employee of
the municipality; or an announcement involving an imminent threat to the public health
and safety of people in the municipality that has arisen after the posting of the agenda.
Historic Landmark Commission Agenda
April 10, 2017
Page 3 of 3
7. ADJOURN:
CERTIFICATE
I certify that the above notice of meeting was posted on the bulletin board at the City Hall of the City of
Denton, Texas,on the day of ,2017 at o'clock(a.m.) (p.m.)
CITY SECRETARY
NOTE: THE CITY OF DENTON CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION ROOM, 215 E. MCKINNEY, IS ACCESSIBLE IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT. THE CITY WILL PROVIDE SIGN LANGUAGE
INTERPRETERS FOR THE HEARING IMPAIRED IF REQUESTED AT LEAST 48 HOURS IN ADVANCE OF THE
SCHEDULED MEETING. PLEASE CALL THE CITY SECRETARY'S OFFICE AT 349-8309 OR USE
TELECOMMUNICATIONS DEVICES FOR THE DEAF (TDD) BY CALLING 1-800-RELAY-TX SO THAT A SIGN
LANGUAGE INTERPRETER CAN BE SCHEDULED THROUGH THE CITY SECRETARY'S OFFICE.
Work Session Item 1
Planning Report
iT JC Jagoe House, 2212 West Oak
°Fv Historic Landmark Commission
DENTON April 10, 2017
REQUEST:
Receive a report and hold a discussion regarding the Jagoe House located at 2212 West Oak Street.
BACKGROUND:
This home has sat vacant for a number of years. The owner is in the early stages of a plan to
restore it and intends to apply for participation in the Texas Historic Preservation Tax Credit
Program. To assist the property owner, staff has begun researching the history of the property in
order to assist with Part A of an application to the Texas Historical Commission. This is the part
in which a determination of eligibility for listing on the National Register occurs. The purpose of
this report is to make the Historic Landmark Commission aware of the owner's plans to restore
the property and the potential for activity around the property associated with clean up and
restoration work. In the future, we will expect the homeowners to submit a Certificate of
Appropriateness Application.
w+
1940's image of the Jagoe House
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report Work Session Item 2
Status of Historic Preservation Ordinance Update
4()&IMMM
Historic Landmark Commission
DENTON April 10, 2017
REQUEST:
Receive a report and hold a discussion regarding the status of the Historic Preservation Ordinance
Update.
BACKGROUND:
The community expressed a desire to clarify the ordinance as they relate to administrative
approvals, painting, and landscaping. The Planning Division originally set a timeline to have the
proposed revisions before the City Council by September 20, 2016. During staff s work towards
this goal, further evaluation indicated a need to more comprehensively update the entire Historic
Preservation Ordinance and prepare it to more easily fit within the soon to be completed Denton
Development Code revisions. We are currently completing the internal review process and plan
to have a community meeting to present and receive input on the proposed update. Below is a
summary of the key changes that are proposed.
• Definitions have been aggregated.
• Multiple references to Certificates of Appropriateness have been centralized in one
cohesive section that clearly delineates administrative approval.
• The criteria and procedures for designations of Historic Landmarks, Historic Districts, and
Conservation Districts have been arranged sequentially and revised for clarity and
consistency.
• Procedurally oriented subsections were combined and sequenced into one section.
• Language relating to exterior painting, fencing and landscaping was inserted per the public
input process.
• Recognition of the Bell Avenue Conservation District as a Historic District.
• Presently, there is no distinction for an application for a historic landmark or historic
district designation for properties that have been recognized by the State of Texas or the
National Park Service. An abbreviated process was introduced for local designation of
properties and districts previously recognized with such a designation.
Below is a tentative schedule for bring the Historic Preservation Ordinance Update forward.
April 2017 -Hold a Community Meeting
May 2017 - Present to the Historic Landmark Commission for a recommendation
May 2017 - Present to the Planning and Zoning Commission at a work session and public
hearing for a recommendation
June 2017 - City Council meeting at a work session and public hearing for final adoption
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report
HL 16-0006
Page 2 of 2
I MINUTES
2 HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION
3 January 9,2017
4
5 After determining that a quorum was present, the Historic Landmark Commission of the City of
6 Denton, Texas convened in a Regular Meeting on Monday, January 9, 2017 at 5:30 p.m. in the
7 City Council Work Session Room at City Hall, 215 E. McKinney Street, Denton, Texas at which
8 time the following items were considered:
9
10 PRESENT: Chair Peggy Riddle, Vice-Chair Deb Conte, Commissioners: Helen
11 Bailey, Scott Campbell, Eric Pulido, Kenneth Williamson, Daniel
12 Abasolo, and Michele Lynn.
13
14 ABSENT: Commissioner Alyssa Stevenson.
15
16 STAFF: Munal Mauladad, Ron Menguita, Roman McAllen, John Knight, and
17 Nikole Chew-Jones.
18
19 REGULAR MEETING
20
21 Chair Peggy Riddle called the Regular Meeting to order at 5:35 p.m.
22
23 1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE:
24
25 A. U.S. Flag
26
27 B. Texas Flag-
28 "Honor the Texas Flag—I pledge allegiance to thee, Texas one state under God, one
29 and indivisible."
30
31 2. CONSIDER APPROVAL OF THE HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION
32 MINUTES FOR:
33
34 A. December 12, 2016
35
36 Commissioner Helen Bailey motioned,Vice-Chair Deb Conte seconded to approve December 12,
37 2016 Minutes. Chair Riddle "aye", Vice-Chair Conte "aye", Commissioner Bailey "aye",
38 Commissioner Pulido "aye", Commissioner Williamson "aye", Commissioner Abasolo "aye",
39 Commissioner Lynn"aye", and Commissioner Campbell "aye". Motion approved(8-0).
40
41 3. ACTION ITEMS:
42
43 A. Consider making a recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Commission regarding
44 an application for Historic Landmark Designation for the property located at 2106 North
45 Bell Avenue, located on the southeast corner of North Bell Avenue and Sherman Drive.
Historic Landmark Commission Minutes
January 9, 2017
Page 2 of 3
1 (HL16-0006, 2106 North Bell Avenue, Roman McAllen) This item has been continued
2 from the December 12, 2016 meeting.
3
4 Chair Riddle stated that Vice-Chair Conte has recused herself from this item.
5
6 Roman McAllen, Historic Preservation Officer, presented this item to the Historic Landmark
7 Commission. McAllen stated that this house was built in 1929 and it is architecturally intact. It
8 retains the majority of the original interior and exterior. This home was a part of the Historic
9 Resource Survey in 1996 and it was considered to be a high priority property in the Tudor Revival
10 Style. The applicants, Gary Hayden and Deborah Conte, have provided information that support
11 the historical significance of this property. The criteria for a Historic Landmark Designation are
12 stated in Section 35.7.6.4 of the Denton Development Code. This property meets the following
13 criteria:
14
15 Number 1. Character, interest or value as part of the development, heritage or cultural
16 characteristics of the city, state or the United States;
17 This home is located at a prominent location that allows it to act as a gateway structure to the
18 Bell Avenue area. The structure is prominent among the residences in the area and evolved in
19 scale from a more modest one story structure into a 2-story residence of significant attributes.
20 This evolution is photographically documented.
21 Number 3. Embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type or
22 specimen;
23 The home is a contributing home in the Bell Avenue Conservation District as indicated by its
24 architectural integrity and designation as a high priority structure in the historic resource survey
25 of 1996. The home has multiple front facing gables and more proportionally square windows
26 on the front facade which is a less common form of the Tudor style.
27 Number 11. Identification with a person who significantly contributed to the culture and
28 development of the city, state or United States;
29
30 From 1948 through 1963, Judge Ben W. Boyd and Ila Boyd owned and resided in this home.
31 The Boyd's were distinguished members of Denton's society. Mr. Boyd was an Associate
32 Justice of the Second Court of Civil Appeals in Fort Worth for 10 years as well as a District
33 Judge of both Denton and Cooke County for 21 years.
34
35 Staff is recommending approval of this request for a Historic Landmark Designation for 2106
36 North Bell Avenue.
37
38 Chair Riddle opened the public hearing.
39
40 The applicants, Gary Hayden and Deborah Conte, spoke in favor of the request. They gave
41 background about some of the previous owners that had occupied the property throughout the
42 years. Deb Conte explained that the small house that was in the back of the main house was
43 considered to be servant quarters. Gary Hayden showed some photos of the original house from
Historic Landmark Commission Minutes
January 9, 2017
Page 3 of 3
1 1929. He explained some of the various changes that had taken place within the house throughout
2 many years. He has spoken with some of the original owners families and they have shared their
3 memories and photos. The applicants purchased the home in 1996.
4
5 Commissioner Bailey stated that the renovations to the home were beautiful.
6
7 Chair Riddle closed the public hearing. There was no further discussion.
8
9 Commissioner Michelle Lynn motioned, Commissioner Helen Bailey seconded to approve this
10 request. Chair Riddle "aye", Commissioner Bailey "aye", Commissioner Pulido "aye",
11 Commissioner Williamson"aye", Commissioner Abasolo"aye", Commissioner Lynn"aye", and
12 Commissioner Campbell"aye". Motion approved(7-0).
13
14 Vice-Chair Conte returned to the dais.
15
16 4. FUTURE AGENDA ITEMS:
17
18 Munal Mauladad,Director of Development Services, stated that staff will provide a matrix within
19 each future packet. It will provide a timeline,who will be working on each item, and the status of
20 each project. This will allow staff the opportunity to prioritize each project. Mauladad stated that
21 if the commissioners have any items or suggestions, please forward that information to her or
22 Roman McAllen, Historic Preservation Officer.
23
24 5. ADJOURN:
25
26 Commissioner Daniel Abasolo motioned, Vice-Chair Deb Conte seconded to adjourn. Chair
27 Riddle"aye",Vice-Chair Conte"aye", Commissioner Bailey"aye", Commissioner Pulido"aye
28 Commissioner Williamson"aye", Commissioner Abasolo"aye", Commissioner Lynn"aye", and
29 Commissioner Campbell "aye". Motion approved(8-0).
30
31 With no further business, Chair Riddle adjourned the Regular Meeting at 5:53 p.m.
Planning Report Item 3A
4()
,�. 2106 North Bell Ave. Permanent Improvement
' COA16-0020
DENTONHistoric Landmark Commission
April 10, 2016
REQUEST:
Determine whether the presented expenses resulted in a permanent improvement or restoration of
the landmarked property located at 2106 North Bell Avenue. The property is within the Bell
Avenue Conservation District and generally located at the intersection of North Bell Avenue and
East Sherman Drive. (COA16-0020, 2106 North Bell Avenue, Roman McAllen)
BACKGROUND:
The applicants, Deborah Conte and Gary Hayden, have undergone an extensive restoration of this
property. Improvements to the property include the removal of synthetic siding and the restoration
of the original siding and windows. They have submitted the roof replacement as the qualifying
permanent improvement to qualify for the City's tax exemption for historic preservation of an
historic property.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1. Per the City's Code of Ordinances, Sec. 10-128 (c),Any property which is designated a historic
site after the first day of January 2009 may be exempt from real property ad valorem taxes
levied by the City of Denton to the extent of fifty (50%) percent of the assessed value of the
designated historic site if the property owner demonstrates to City qualifying expenses of
$10,000.00 or more for permanent improvements and/or for restoration of said property. The
qualifying expenses are limited to two (2) years prior to designation as an historic site. The
Historical Landmark Commission must determine whether the qualifying expenses result in a
permanent improvement and/or restoration of said property as a condition of receiving the
exemption. The exemption provided for herein shall apply for a maximum of then (10)
successive years,beginning with the first year the property is entitled to the exemption during
the specified years and thereafter during which the property is a designated historic site on the
first day of January of those nine (9) successive years.
2. The applicant has spent$10,590.00 to replace the roof of this structure, exclusive of additional
costs.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends a favorable determination that the expenses presented resulted in a permanent
improvement and/or restoration of the landmarked property located at 2106 North Bell Avenue.
OPTIONS:
1. Make a favorable finding of improvement
2. Make and unfavorable finding of improvement
3. Deny
4. Continue the item
ATTACHMENTS:
• Application of the applicant
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
Wi2�
— PQO
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report
COA16-0020
Page 2 of 2
CITY OF DENTON
HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION
APPLICATION FOR HISTORIC LANDMARK TAX EXEMPTION AUTHORIZATION
Name of owner
Address of owner
� I
Telephone/Email 'n �, l
This application is for property located at: l
List the completed repairs or maintenance work. Attach all receipts. (Please note all receipts for work
completed must total a minimum of$10,000 in order to be considered for the Historic Landmark City
Tax Exemption.)
ignature of Property Owner Date
Return to: Planning Department, 221 N Elm Street, Denton,Texas, 76201
Phone: 940-349-8541 Fax: 940-349-7707
CLASSIC ROOF SYSTEMS
PO BOX 952
Argyle, TX. 76226
940 239-7411
Deb Conte
2106 N. Bell
Denton, TX.
Replace roof as per agreement:
Completed: 08-2Z1=14
Amount Due 109'590:00
---------------
Thank You!!
Rep.:_MIKE BRISCOE Date: 9/11/14
eorAer PRI-B2G•305-592-2a3B inloCkprintecii com
*TD#1ST DISP/CONT
Green Tree Servicing LLC
Check Number 60603
The items listed below are managed on the following account:
CLASSIC ROOF SYSTEMS
440 HWY 377 N
ARGYLE
Invoice # Description Document # Date Invoice Amt
6218612410 'TD#1 ST DISP/CONT 1900019247 08/26/2014 6,99334
Sum Mal 6,99334
I
I Green Treeery Sicin LLC Bank of America
I 9 ' 16-66 r 122D cL
Claims Department
I Rapid
City,ie Drive
I Rapid City, SD 57703 08/26/2014
$6,993.34
I
Pay ***SIX THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED NINETY-THREE USD and 34/100**'
i VOID AFTER 90 DAYS
i
t� OOTHE
ER CLASSIC ROOF SYSTEMS
{ ORDER
I of *AND*GARY HAYDEN
2106 NORTH BELL AVE
f D.ENTON TX 76209
SIGNATl1RE RAS A COLORED BACKGROUND•EORDER COITTAR*MICROPRIrmu
• Zf CN.
my . ca
PJ • �. F .
CD yty
H zm
OZ c_n
� ZO1Dn Cnm v CD
Cp
(n �� CD �<
m fn o
o Z
N r w
�j
.-j
m z
n
m
cn
• ? �E F4 i f3J a �j4
Q 1 V o n Q I cn ,.
e "S D CD
cy
to
T my
• O \ Q7 CD
CAkA
N
V �
2• E
� F
K
Planning Report Item 313
4()
,�. 607 College Street-Preliminary HL Designation
HL17-0004
DENTONHistoric Landmark Commission
April 10, 2017
REQUEST:
Consider a preliminary application for Historic Landmark Designation for the property located at
607 College Street, and make a recommendation regarding the appropriateness of the property to
proceed to a final application. (HL 17-0004, 607 College Street, Roman McAllen)
APPLICANT/OWNER: James A. and Lizabeth A. Spoonts
BACKGROUND:
The applicant is seeking a recommendation of approval to move forward with a full application
for a Historic Landmark Designation for the property located at 607 College Street. The home
was constructed in approximately 1915. The Historic Resource Survey of 1996 indicates this is a
domestic bungalow. It has typical elements of a craftsman style house.
Attachment A includes basic information about the property. The purpose of the preliminary
application is to allow the Historic Landmark Committee to determine if the final application is
likely meet the criteria for Historic Landmark Designations, as provided in Section 35.7.6.4 of the
Denton Development Code.
CONSIDERATIONS:
1. Current owners have rehabilitated the property and live there now.
2. The criteria for Historic Landmark Designations are provided in Section 35.7.6.4 of the DDC.
3. In making the designations, City Council shall consider but shall not be limited to one (1) or
more of the following criteria:
1. Character, interest or value as part of the development, heritage or cultural
characteristics of the city, state or the United States;
2. Recognition as a recorded state historic landmark, a national historic landmark or
entered into the National Register of Historic Places;
3. Embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type or specimen;
4. Identification as the work of an architect or master builder whose individual work has
influenced the development of the city;
5. Embodiment of elements of architectural design, detail, material or craftsmanship
which represent a significant architectural innovation;
6. Relationship to other distinctive buildings, sites or areas which are eligible for
preservation according to a plan based on architectural, historic or cultural motif;
7. Portrayal of the environment of a group of people in an area of history characterized
by a distinctive architectural style;
8. Archeological value in that it has produced or can be expected to produce data affecting
theories of historic or prehistoric interest;
9. Exemplification of the cultural, economic, social, ethnic or historical heritage of the
city, state, or United States;
10. Location as the site of a significant historic event;
11. Identification with a person who significantly contributed to the culture and
development of the city, state or United States;
12. A building or structure that because of its location has become of value to a
neighborhood, community area or the city;
13. Value as an aspect of community sentiment or public pride.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
The designation of a historic resource in the City of Denton falls within Element 4, Community
Character&Urban Design and within Element 7,Housing and Neighborhoods of the Denton Plan
2030. Element 4 was developed to identify, preserve, maintain, and create character areas within
the city. Element 7 calls for being proactive in neighborhood conservation and using historic
district designations as a"defense mechanism to prevent`spillover' impacts from adjacent corridor
and center development, and from capital investments such as road widening".
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of this preliminary application for Historic Landmark Designation of
the property located at 607 College Street. This designation is consistent with the goals and
objectives of the Denton Plan 2030 and meets the criteria for Historic Landmark Designations as
outlined in the Denton Development Code.
OPTIONS:
1. Recommend approval as submitted
2. Recommend approval subject to conditions
3. Deny
4. Continue the item
ATTACHMENTS:
• Application
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
pgo-�Wt�- —
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report
HL 17-0004
Page 2 of 2
PRELIMINARY APPLICATION
HISTORIC LANDMARK ZONING PETITION
CITY OF DENTON,TEXAS
Site Address_
DQNTbg( (x -7t.
Legal description (lot and block or metes
and bounds—attach Exhibit A if necessary)
S U P-'q
Present use: Si+��L� FA►^ ��1 RsSlno�►r� - o., �tNt occa.�P'��
Current zoning: bq-2
Name of owner(s)_ .JAM 4s L t Tn b6fO S P o o(4(_s _
Address L' Lwxaa S 1 c r.-►e.J 1 V '-)L 2oq
Telephone number/E-Mail A4 b.3gs 6 3 01 j i M S P�oNrs GMrri�•ra M
Additional owners may be listed on a separate piece of paper.
Preliminary application-2
Construction/Description
1. Date built €,Sri Mph 1915�
2. Architectural Style or period:
ew%-s MA,
3. Distinctive architectural features(design, detail, materials or craftsmanship):
PtEll qy� QcJ �ou..1A�1-t1o�J fuL4 F(l-a,ir —
- - --� 1'OQ.LN w1S-c-+cPs 62��,yn�
4"kk.0 Qi.dE SiDi•�G�w�yDo.aS�Ono(L 1%9 EX1QA. WA%LS
- -� _ W Oofl 60T-"G � o RlP••M
4. Do you intend to apply for tax exemption? Yes ✓ No
S:\HLC\PRELIMINARY ZONING APPLICATION.doc
607 COLLEGE STREET
BEING LOT 8,BLOCK 2 OF WOODLAND ADDITION,AN ADDITION TO THE CITY OF DENTON,TEXAS,
ACCORDING TO THE PLAT THEREOF RECORDED IN VOLUME 153,PAGE 590,DEED RECORDS OF
DENTON COUNTY,TEXAS.
LOT 5
(68.00') FENCE
NLOT 6 g•U4'43" E 6 .98 CORNER LOT 4
—N
FOUND 1/2" WIRE FEN(,E
IRON PIN —4.0'
LOT 8 W
BUILLDIDI
NG v
W E Q-a x
Ir =PULING C. MAE r
1n CF. 95-006770 AR•• CD
s Q a)
•r
r O
r
rWIRE FENCE
LOT 7 S w 39.4 3 g LOT 9
607 COLLEGEKJ
STREET
1 STORY
I FRAME • O
d'I RESIDENCE 3.1
04 �' r
N cp
o l
O Of O
Z 21.3' 34.4' (77
ROOFED WOOD
Co
FOUND 112" (68.00)' FOUND 1/2"
IRON PIN WEST 68. IRON PIN
QLLE S
7
,.
NOTES.
OE
EASEMENTS SHOWN HEREON ARE AS LISTED IN TITLE RESOURCES GUARANTY
COMPANY'S GF# 261863,EFFECTIVE DATE 09/11/05.
NONE
BY GRAPHIC PLOTTING ONLY,THIS PROPERTY IS WITHIN ZONE"X",AREAS
DETERMINED TO BE OUTSIDE OF A DESIGNATED 100 YEAR OR 500 YEAR FLOOD PLAIN
AS SHOWN BY FIRM MAP COMMUNITY-PANEL NUMBER 48121CO360 E,DATED APRIL 2,
1997.NO SURVEYING WAS PERFORMED TO DETERMINE THIS FLOOD ZONE.
SURVEYOR'S CERTIFICATE
I,BRAD G.SHELTON,DO HEREBY CERTIFY THAT A SURVEY WAS MADE ON THE
GROUND THIS 16th DAY OF SEPTEMBER,2005 OF THE PROPERTY DESCRIBED HEREON
AND THERE ARE NO(VISIBLE)ENCROACHMENTS,PROTRUSIONS,OR OVERLAPPING
OF IMP ME EXCEPT AS SHOWN HER-ON.
OF...F v
BRAD G,SH 0 f e o
REGISTERED PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR BRADLEY GL�I'ShfflUN C
STATE OF TEXAS NO.5452 '4 5452 I i
.9
o
M et ra x °��sa'°?:
Surveying, Inc.
940-387.0506 223 W.HICKORY,DENTON,TEXAS76201 Inlo@rnetr loxsurvoyin .corn GF# 251853
DWN. AW JCKD. BGS SCALE 1"=30' DATE 09/16/05 JOB N0.34496
Item 3C
Planning Report
917 Egan Street - Preliminary HL Designation
HL17-0005
DENTONHistoric Landmark Commission
April 10, 2017
REQUEST:
Consider a preliminary application for Historic Landmark Designation for the property located at
917 Egan, and make a recommendation regarding the appropriateness of the property to proceed
to a final application. (HL17-0005, 917 Egan Street, Roman McAllen)
APPLICANT/OWNER: James M. Payne
BACKGROUND:
The applicant is seeking a recommendation to move forward with a full application for Historic
Landmark Designation for the property located at 917 Egan. The home was constructed in
approximately 1924. The Historic Resource Survey of 1996 indicates this is a Tudor Revival Style
home.
Attachment A includes basic information about the property. The purpose of the preliminary
application is to allow the Historic Landmark Committee to determine if the final application is
likely meet the criteria for Historic Landmark Designations, as provided in Section 35.7.6.4. of the
Denton Development Code:
CONSIDERATIONS:
1. Current owners have rehabilitated the property and live there now.
2. The criteria for Historic Landmark Designations are provided in Section 35.7.6.4 of the DDC.
3. In making the designations, City Council shall consider but shall not be limited to one (1) or
more of the following criteria:
1. Character, interest or value as part of the development, heritage or cultural
characteristics of the city, state or the United States;
2. Recognition as a recorded state historic landmark, a national historic landmark or
entered into the National Register of Historic Places;
3. Embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type or specimen;
4. Identification as the work of an architect or master builder whose individual work has
influenced the development of the city;
5. Embodiment of elements of architectural design, detail, material or craftsmanship
which represent a significant architectural innovation;
6. Relationship to other distinctive buildings, sites or areas which are eligible for
preservation according to a plan based on architectural, historic or cultural motif,
7. Portrayal of the environment of a group of people in an area of history characterized
by a distinctive architectural style;
8. Archeological value in that it has produced or can be expected to produce data affecting
theories of historic or prehistoric interest;
9. Exemplification of the cultural, economic, social, ethnic or historical heritage of the
city, state, or United States;
10. Location as the site of a significant historic event;
11. Identification with a person who significantly contributed to the culture and
development of the city, state or United States;
12. A building or structure that because of its location has become of value to a
neighborhood, community area or the city;
13. Value as an aspect of community sentiment or public pride.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
The designation of an historic resource in the City of Denton falls within Element 4, Community
Character&Urban Design and within Element 7,Housing and Neighborhoods of the Denton Plan
2030. Element 4 was developed to identify, preserve, maintain, and create character areas within
the city. Element 7 calls for being proactive in neighborhood conservation and using historic
district designations as a"defense mechanism to prevent`spillover' impacts from adjacent corridor
and center development, and from capital investments such as road widening".
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of this preliminary application for Historic Landmark Designation of
the property located at 917 Egan Street. This designation is consistent with the goals and
objectives of the Denton Plan 2030 and meets the criteria for Historic Landmark Designations as
outlined in the Denton Development Code.
OPTIONS:
1. Recommend to move forward as submitted
2. Recommend to move forward subject to conditions
3. Deny
4. Continue the item
ATTACHMENTS:
• Application
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
0// —�Z
-— PQO - —
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report
HL 17-0005
Page 2 of 2
PRELIMINARY APPLICATION
HISTORIC LANDMARK ZONING PETITION
CITY OF DENTON, TEXAS
Site Address:_
917 Egan St, Denton, TX 76201
Legal description(lot and block or metes
and bounds—attach Exhibit A if necessary):
High School Addition
Block 15, Lot 7
Present use: Single Family Residence - Owner Occupied
Current zoning: NR-3
Name of owner(s) James M. Payne
Address: 917 Egan, Denton, TX 76201
Telephone number/E-Mail: James M Payne<jmpayne43(a,gmail.com>
Additional owners may be listed on a separate piece of paper.
Preliminary application-2
Construction/Description
1. Date built: 1924
2. Architectural Style or period: Tudor Revival
3. Distinctive architectural features (design, detail, materials or craftsmanship):
Large timber columns supporting front porch roof,protruding copper or tin front facing
attic vents, plentiful cast stone detailing, half-circle front door, 6 pane over 6 pane
wooden double hung windows, prominent fire place chimney rising on west side of house
and west facing narrow, French doors.
Ownership includes: William"W.F."Brooks, a Pharmacist who was President of
Kiwanas, the Texas Retail Drug Association, the Denton Chamber of Commerce, the DHS
Board and briefly served as Mayor of Denton in 1912.
4. Do you intend to apply for tax exemption? Yes No
S:\HLC\PRELIMINARY ZONING APPLICATION.doc
Item 3D
-�� Planning Report
4()
, O'Neil Ford Civic Complex
' Historic Landmark Designation
DENTON HL17-0001
Historic Landmark Commission
April 10, 2017
REQUEST:
Consider making a recommendation to the Planning and Zoning Commission regarding
designating the O'Neil Ford Civic Complex as a Local Historic Landmark. The O'Neil Ford
Complex is bounded by Withers Street on the north,Bell Avenue on the east, McKinney Street on
the south and Austin and Oakland Streets on the west. (HL17-0001, O'Neil Ford Civic Complex,
Roman McAllen)
APPLICANT/OWNER: City of Denton
BACKGROUND:
Among the many contributions of O'Neil Ford to the architecture of Denton are the City of Denton
Civic Center that was built in 1966 and City Hall that was built in 1967. O'Neil Ford and his firm
also designed additions to the Emily Fowler Public Library in 1969 and again in 1980. Some
remnants exist of the original design of the City of Denton Municipal Swimming Pool, also
designed by the O'Neil Ford firm in 1965.
Acclaimed architecture critic, David Dillon, wrote that O'Neil Ford (1905-1982) was the most
influential Texas architect of the twentieth century. In July of 1992 the City of Denton officially
designated the area, bounded by Withers Street on the north, Bell Avenue on the east, McKinney
Street on the south and Austin and Oakland Streets on the west, as the O'Neil Ford Civic Complex.
In July 1993, the City Council installed and dedicated a Local Historic Landmark marker in the
courtyard on the south side of the City Hall. The Planning Division has been unsuccessful in
locating the ordinance that would have officially designated the Complex as a Local Historic
Landmark. The item before you now is to consider making a recommendation to the Planning and
Zoning Commission for the adoption of an ordinance to formalizing the designation.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
The designation of an historic resource in the City of Denton falls within Element 4, Community
Character & Urban Design. Element 4 was developed to identify, preserve, maintain, and create
character areas within the city. Designations also fall within Element 7, Housing and
Neighborhoods. Element 7 calls for being proactive in neighborhood conservation and using
historic district designations as a"defense mechanism to prevent `spillover' impacts from adjacent
corridor and center development, and from capital investments such as road widening".
CONSIDERATIONS:
1. The O'Neil Ford Civic Complex is formally defined by Resolution Number R92-040. The
Resolution formally adopted names of certain city facilities.
2. City Hall is 50 years old this year and the other buildings located in the Complex have recently
reached this milestone.
3. The criteria for Historic Landmark Designations are provided in Section 35.7.6.4 of the DDC.
4. In making the designations, City Council shall consider but shall not be limited to one (1) or
more of the following criteria:
I. Character, interest or value as part of the development, heritage or cultural
characteristics of the city, state or the United States;
2. Recognition as a recorded state historic landmark, a national historic landmark or
entered into the National Register of Historic Places;
3. Embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type or specimen;
4. Identification as the work of an architect or master builder whose individual work has
influenced the development of the city;
5. Embodiment of elements of architectural design, detail, material or craftsmanship
which represent a significant architectural innovation;
6. Relationship to other distinctive buildings, sites or areas which are eligible for
preservation according to a plan based on architectural, historic or cultural motif,
7. Portrayal of the environment of a group of people in an area of history characterized
by a distinctive architectural style;
8. Archeological value in that it has produced or can be expected to produce data affecting
theories of historic or prehistoric interest;
9. Exemplification of the cultural, economic, social, ethnic or historical heritage of the
city, state, or United States;
10. Location as the site of a significant historic event;
11. Identification with a person who significantly contributed to the culture and
development of the city, state or United States;
12. A building or structure that because of its location has become of value to a
neighborhood, community area or the city;
13. Value as an aspect of community sentiment or public pride.
5. This property meets the following criteria:
Number 4. Identification as the work of an architect or master builder whose individual
work has influenced the development of the city;
This is best stated by Mike Cochran, former Chairman of the Historic Landmark
Commission,in the small catalogue titled,O'Neil Ford Architect—A Catalogue of the Works
of O'Neil Ford in Denton, Texas. He wrote in the forward, "O'Neil Ford is arguably the
Planning Report
HL 17-0001
Page 2 of 3
most prominent architect to have come from Texas. In his long and distinguished career, he
achieved both popular and critical success, yet retained a strong life-long link to his
hometown of Denton."
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends that the HLC recommend to the Planning and Zoning Commission that the
O'Neil Ford Civic Complex be designated a Local Historic Landmark. This designation is
consistent with the goals and objectives of the Denton Plan 2030 and meets the criteria for Historic
Landmark Designations as outlined in the Denton Development Code.
OPTIONS:
1. Recommend approval as submitted
2. Recommend approval subject to conditions
3. Recommend denial
4. Continue the item
ATTACHMENTS:
• Resolution R92-040
• Image of July 21, 1993 Marker
• Denton Record Chronicle Article on O'Neil Ford, January 1993
• May 10, 1993, HLC Minutes - Consideration of Wording of Marker
• Letter from City Manager agreeing that Complex should be designated
• Letter from Attorney for Woman's Club to consider inclusion of that building in the complex
• October 5, 1993, Memo to HLC regarding options for review
• 1993 O'Neil Ford Civic Complex Map
• October 11, 1993, HLC Minutes
• August 17, 1993, Designation of Complex Memo
• Current Map of the area
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
PQ 0?1�- —
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report
HL 17-0001
Page 3 of 3
;r 9
RESOLUTION NO. eq02 -01/0
RE?SOLUTION OF THE CITY OF DENTON, TEXAS, FORMALLY ADOPTING NAMES
' !?IA CERTAIN CITY FACILITIES ; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS , the City of Denton will soon be in the process of
xpanding and renovating its facilities ; and
WHEREAS, in order to maintain an orderly flow of business and
in better accommodate citizens using City facilities, a committee
;if tl» City Council has studied the issue and submitted recommenda-
i r)ns to the City Council for the designation of names for certain
- ' iry Eacilities, and the Council wish to accept same; NOW, THERE-
!'ORE ,
111F CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DENTON HEREBY RESOLVES:
SECTION I . That area encompassing the Civic Center Park which
is hounded by Withers Street on the north, Bell Avenue on the east,
McKinney Street on the south and Austin and Oakland Streets on the
west shall be known as the "O' Neil Ford Civic Complex. " The fol-
lowi.nq buildings shall be located within the O'Neil Ford Civic
('(implex: Emily Fowler. Library, Denton Senior Center, Civic Center
Fool , Civic/Convention Center and City Hall .
SECTION II . That those facilities located at 601 East Hickory
,ind 604 East Hickory, formerly owned by Moore Business Forms, shall
he known as the "Denton Municipal Complex. "
SECTION III . That facility located at 221 North Elm Street
!;hall be known as "City Hall West. "
SECTION IV. That this resolution shall become effective
immediately upon its passage and approval .
PASSED AND APPROVED this theal day of 1992 .
BOB CASTLEBERRY, MAYO
ATTEST:
TE?ST:
IENNIFER WALTERS, CITY SECRETARY
B Y : '�
A
It
is
-wro
lb
46
_ J
AW
�i�[.-- .w`sImmommow
Aw
t-w,
VW� am op
: I7�r� .►.i„s• a ti r—
< r ors• Aft
—".�•r'
OWN=
wr.aaw.r. . •
.. .... -- aa......r. +n. ter. �� ■� �.� i ..
' ? .. �. fie.,/. ` •S e � •. �c
I f
e 1
AW
R'
-
• S
•�-- O ' NEIL FORD
CIVIC COMPLEX
O'NEIL FORD PROMINENT
TEXAS ARCHITECT, WAS BORN
IN PINY HILL, TEXAS IN 1905 AND MGV'ED TO DENTON A
a � T
THE AGE OF 12 . HE GRADUATE -
_ SCHOOL A D FROM DENTON HIGH
AND ATTENDED NORTN TEXAS STATE TEACRERS
COLLEGE, NOW THE UNIVERSITY_ Y OF NORTH TEXAS.
FORD DESIGNED HIS FIRST RESIDENCE
MARSHALL HOUSE HERE IN 1929. IN 1939
THE MAR7� �
NATIONAL PROMINENCE WITH THE COMP,
FORD EA�tNED --- ------- —
PLEfi10N OF THE _
- LITTLE CHAPEL IN — THE— WOODS ON THE TEXAS WOMAWS
• UNIVERSITY CAMPUS .
AMONG FORDS MANY CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE ARCHI —
z -T TECTURE OF DENTON ARE THE BUILDINGS OF THE
Ion
CIVIC CENTER COMPLEX , THE CIVIC CENTER WAS BUILT
IN 1966 , THE CITY FIALL, BUILT IN 19679 DISPLAYS MANY
POPULAR FORD THEMES , INCLUDING DOORS CARVED BY
HIS� BP:OTHER, LYNN FORD , ✓CERAMIC LIGHT FIXTURES _:~ `- '•' ''�� • AND" SA�,TILLO TILE FLOORS* FORD AND -MS FIRM
- ADDITIONS TO THE EMILY FOVLER 'PUBLIC
" LIBRARY' - I`N -1 69 AND
9 i 9 8 0
aRD CI�EWfED CIS PURSUIT OF THE CREATIVE LIFECIO
` _
Tb• ftfg FASCINATION WITH THE DENTON COUNTY COURT
"I USED TO JU ST STAND THERE, WONDERING HOW -
THEY EVER OOT 1T " UP . * . - I WAS IN DENTON JUST' THE
� 6THEE. DAY ... SO I lnNT OVER TO LOOK AT TIIE COURT
MUSE AGAIN AND 8T. L DON'j KNOW HOW THEY EVER
DiIS 'THAT' BLASTtlS,*_btE88Eb ITING611 -
O`NEIL EbkD Df9b ON JULY 20, 1982,
J!r h: a • 1t '��
IN SAN AfiTTONYO, TEXAS. -
r FORD CIVIC COMPLEX -
E lAk
DtbltATEb ON JULY 3I , 1993
BY THE DENTON -CITY COUNCIL40
jj
st
' k'• —
• ,7 y
e j/Mjj r v .3► a ,
' _/°^�• I ��t�t 'v • . ,� �-T� ! fir-- «} � +
® Denton cord-Cbj�onicle
Rriday, July 30, 1993
rea jivin D
TOARC�ITECT
III ti�
I I
s f•
By MaWe Resaledy
Creative UVIng Editor
OWeiil Ford could be, or probably
should be, called The National
Ax ch.9tect of Texas.
���.I o as.
ew a feint.I S outspoken,is oksr.
p ,
+ I
•r° x s'
:tar er rot seTrluo ns r
0
:Tt i c ns:
d homes, officeArd he deslge
31%ldim asdo]l5x universities,
campuses,7 nes, churches and chapels,
hotels and industrial complexes all
F
over the�. state tll8l't reflelct6d h15
c,
love
Ve f natu
ral iasa..srtals.
5 L,
I
5 « -E
I ach bears his unique and
mnovat
ive rather rcat� trademarks rough-looking brick r-
— �,
t-
xi g`"` � �fl k native
— - weathered
I'� stone, Mex'�1�[:a'Fl " �,
....,s.■ _ r - _ cedar and metal, pitched roofs. Hia
i
I. 1 ,I designs are pu-re and ueadorned.
L~ with no pretense,no 6-lihs. ThWejs
f', W all immaculate attention to 41et .
Architect O'Neil Ford„ above, g=e
the cornTr" rl.ro rne,rit address in XVLHe could also be called
1977 at the lust ri S,ellocrl u h h National Architect of Denton. am
1 As
designed seven
he designed in 1965. As far t � � -�f � 2 to -he e�I'm concerned„ ninthode calcia.- hcus waU as the Little
his is unnecessary," he told the w � � �� � .: � - Texas
grade rig seniors. 'he tour, _ , . c. (1938),,
r&,•. -. First Chrstisrt Church ill 1 , the
rr ht„ _eta the tr h� the archi: Denton Civic Center complex
tect deslgrte , tt was built in I929 � :, p ex iu the
Mary 1w�arsivall and n� ihs� ; ;� � -d- frls, e terminal ,at the cites
r „ ..., a' ,� y
,at IS1-9 N. Sell r o professor w- _. u l 19nbra 7odduto Fowler
hone of Gerrude Gibson, l�ordp y n.s m 1
who Idied In 1982, was also con- � , an;d 1980D, the Selwyn choral in
sidered uhe "Jather j' preseru a- _.. - ,,� 196 - 6, Pairhaven Retirement
tron tn T for his uyork ugth Home in 1196M5, the Gazebo at the
the Alavuw, La ViUita and die R. University of forth Texas in 1928,
er a k in Scm, Antonto. anal the Opera Air Theater at 1$t+IT
i 1 28 which was demolished in
the 1960s.
- - See RC=C-'T/30
C y �lti
I
,
EF
a � �
I �
I
I
3'
Little Chapel-in-the-Woods under- construction- die courhyard of the I1enton Civte Center being renamed for O'Neil Pbrd on Saturday.
rofessor pom'ets
to chapel changes
Y �Z
may_ Maggie:Kipmeay
Creative Living Editor
Dorothy A.nto MLaSelle waved a long, thin wrinkled
.., . an over hand
y carvet3,bAaehaood pew in the Little
,<
Chapel-in-the-Wbo�3s_
4 "They're not supposed to be this dark,"she remarked. "The
pews are supposed to be straw colored, much lighter Than
P.
- this. Guess its lime to have them refinished."
She was sitting in a pew toward the rear of the cool, dark
chapel and inspecting it like a Marine drill instructor. "It's
t; ., - darker in here anyway since so much of the stained glass
has been replaced," she continued. "The new glass is darker
thag-the-ori.ginal for some reason."
r: But things do have a way of changing over 55 years and
ti 9
fo ACY
:T9,ni=L4$elle has good reason to feel rather proprietary
— fiTeilFord-designed chapel.
Architects Arch Swank, retired art professor Tbni LaSetle and O_Nell Ford,from left, in fro,
of Lithe Chapel-in-the-Woods in 1979 during the chapel's 40th anniuersasy celebration. � See CHAPEL/3®
l -
Friday, July 30, 1993/Denton Record-Chronicle/3D
Architect
From/1 D projects and the original full- anders through the civic cen-
His homes include those at color, full-size drawings of the ter area.
1819 N. Bell built in 1929 (his stained-glass windows the
Little Chapel-in-the-Woods. "On the master plans, he p,
first) for Mary Marshall, The exhibit will remain at drew a series of small retain-
chairman
heck dams
ment at whatis nowe art eTWU the gallery through Aug. at- ing along thes and e creek," he offered. •
(the house belongs to Gertrude Hours are 1 to 4 p.m. this Sat- "It's too bad the city didn't fol- v
Gibson now); the Annie Alford urday and 1 to 5 p.m. Sunday low his plan because that con-
through Friday. The gallery P
home at 220 Marietta in 1939 will be closed Aug. 10. crete channel is a blight now.
(with longtime partner and But there's hope. There's still -
friend Arch Swank of Dallas); That will be followed by the a line item in the capital im-
"O'Neil
the Parrill Sisters home at O Neil Ford and His Gift to provement plan for 1992-94
1712 Highland Park Road in Texas" symposium at 11 a.m. mentioning $50,000 for designR�" �, E `
"d• Kk
1939• the Jack Johnson home in City Council chambers. Bill work and study. There's still
at 2280 W. Oak with Arch Mercer, director of UNT's Cen- the potential to fulfill O'Neil " a =F F ry
W ,
Swank in 1938; the Roland ter for Texas Studies, will lead Ford's dream, to turn that Fk ;}
and Authella Ford Hersh an informal discussion with blight into something wonder- k'
home (his sister) at 1408 Roland Laney of Denton, a re- ful for Denton, to build our
Country Club Road in Argyle tired architect who studied own little Riverwalk. ?;
in 1965 which replaced the and worked with Mr. Ford; ar- "O'Neil Ford designs, partic-, `_ t
couple's first home the two chitect Frank Welch of Dallas; ularly his early work, is time- y
men designed for them in architects Dwayne and Jane less," Mr. Cochran went on. '
1939 at 304 W. Avenue D. The Landry of Dallas; architect
Roland Laney remembers A: �
first Hersh home built on the Carolyn Peterson from Ford, vividly his first encounter with
site of Mr. Ford's boyhood Powell & Carson in San Anto- the man who was to become ,
home was demolished in 1965 nio; and Toni LaSelle, the re- his mentor, friend and boss.
to make way for UNT expan- tired TWU art professor who "I was a sophomore architec- k; °F
lion. directed the student design ture student at Texas A&M in
This warm and funny man projects on the Little Chapel- 1937," he said. "I was in class
who died in 1982 at 76 will be in-the-Woods from 1938 to working on a design project `
honored today and Saturday 1943. � E
probably a house. This charac-
in Denton where he lived from A self guided driving tour of ter came in and started '
age 12 to 22 (1917-1926) and Mr. Fors work in Denton is �
where he designed his first planned from 1 to 4 p.m. Sat. looking at our work and clly
tiquing it. We were all really
home in 1929 and his first ma- urday for those who wish tointo O'Neil Ford in those days. , 3
jor structure — the Little participate. Maps will be pro-
He was standing beside me "A
Chapel-in-the-Woods — which vided and guides will be avail- ...
him into national able to answer looking at my design. I said,
propelled questions at This is the way O'Neil Ford
prominence. the Selwyn School, Little Cha- does it.' He looked at me and
"The City of Denton has re- pel-in-the-Woods and the civic replied, `I am OTTeiI Ford'."
named the civic center the complex. i
Friends and family called _
O'Neil Ford Civic Complex," "All of this is to help people him Neil Ford. His real name
explained Mike Cochran, understand we have some ar-
was Otha Neil Ford. t ��
chairman of the O'Neil Ford chitectural wealth in our coin- "He didn't like Otha much," ,<
Marker Dedication Task munit said Mr. Cochran -
Force. "The cityy'�� Mr. Laney recalled. By college
is going to cel- `that we've got some cultural he was O. Neil, then O'Neil af-
ebrate and formally dedicate heritage, a valuable prize that
the complex in Ford's name. will carry us into the 21st cen- favorite writers.
O , one of his
'
He wasNeil hated artiface," he
one of the most promi- tury." ter Eugene Neill
_.._ ..
nent chitects in the country Mr. Cochran never met continued. "He believed if it's
and ar7uably the most promi- O'Neil Ford but has been a a brick, let it be a brick. He Called "771e Motherhood Window," this giant stained-glass work of art in TWU's Little Chapel-in-
nent architect to come from Ford fan for many years. "I'm
m was a craftsman. He and his the-Woods was the work of students Beatrice Paschall, Helen Crain, Ivy May Choliar, Mary Ann
Texas. Were fortunate to have a student of architecture and younger brother Lynn used to Chadick, Billie.Marie Culweil, Coreen Spellman,Lura Mae Kendricks and Marilyn Yates. 77ie ico-
so much of his work right I've appreciated his work for a build their own toys as kids nography is by their art teacher Toni LaSelle.
here." long time," he said, adding he ,
thinks the civic complex because they didn't have any
The two-day event begins at p x is money. He took all the wood- mother-in-law's home in San College which he attended for lecture at Harvard at Cam-
7 p.m. tonight with the open- perfectly suited to its site. "It workingand metal shop clan- g '
ing of the "O'Neil Ford, A provides a sense of place and p Antonio. It was a wonderful two years. However, Neil Ford bridge, become a professor of
Denton Legacy" exhibit r the the inner courtyard is an is-and
ses he could in school. He was place, though. There was no didn't get his degree from architecture at the University
neat East Gallery hi the Cen- land of calm." pretty disappointed with the heating or air-conditioning, now-UNT. Financial problems of Virginia and have a chair in
ter for the Visual Arta, 400 E. There's still a chance, ac- new architects because most of just fireplaces for heat and big forced him to continue his architecture named after him
them aren't craftsmen. windows strategically laced
!� Y P studies through the Interns- at the University of Texas in
Hickory at Bell. It focuses on cording to Mr. Cochran, that
According to Mr. Laney, the for cross ventilation." tional Correspondence Schools Austin," Mike Cochran wrote
artifacts a and photos ects his love element O'Neil Fo ahead ors last 15 years of his friend's ca- This "National Historic while working at Dyche's Cor- in the catalog he prepared for
P J � reer were sent lecturing, »
P "Con-
Landmark, the only individu- ner, a hamburger stand at the the exhibit.
of crafts and art, blueprints of design for the creek that me-
teaching and speaking. Con- al so honored, was born in corner of Avenue A and Hicko- O'Neil Ford has an impres-
aidering the time he spent out Pink Hill near Sherman, the ry. sive list of design accomplish-
Ford
Driving ! ur of the office, the company's oldest of three children. His In 1926, he moved to Dallas ments outside Denton: Texas
things still have that certain brother Lynn was a master as an assistant to architect Instruments in Richardson;
touch of his." carpenter and woodcarver who David Williams where his first University of Dallas in Irving,
Mr. Laney described his designed many of the doors assignment was doing the Trinity University in San An-
friend as a cross between Hill and other wood pieces for big drafting on the old First Pres- tonio, University of Texas at
Country humorist Hondo brother Neil's homes and byterian Church of Denton. It San Antonio, the La Villita re-
Follow signs Crouch and J. Eric Jonnson, buildings• was demolished in 1965. He construction in San Antonio,
t University Drive T.W.U. the charming and elegant co- The family moved to Sher- was still with Williams when St. Mark's School of Dallas,
founder of Texas Instruments man, then to Denton in 1917 he designed two projects for the Founder's Building at
0" and former mayor of Dallas. when his father died in a train LINT that were never built — what is now UT-Dallas in
"Neil didn't even live in one of accident. His mother kept a 130-foot memorial tower and Richardson Skidmore College
his own houses," Mr. Laney boarders in their home at 304 a student center. in New York the Greenhill
g said. "He and Wanda and the W Avenue D, a block west of "This correspondence school School in Dallas, the Tower of
four children lived in his North Texas State Teachers architect from Denton would the Americas in San Antonio.
oak St
Hickory SL Countwwa Chapel
U.N.T. `q—
From/1 D teaching, science, social ser- doors. a white knit cap drawn low
vice, speech, literature, dance By the time the chapel was over her eyes and a walking
She was an associate art pro- and music. The ninth window finished, according to Ms. La- cane in her hand. After the in-
fessor in her mid-30s at Texas above the entrance signifies Selle, more than 400 women terview, she planned to walk.to
N State College for Women (now the renewal of faith through worked on the chapel. Some the student center in the 100
A Texas Woman s University) in communion with nature while came for a week or two only, degree heat until I offered her
3 1938 when she got one of her the most prominent window, others just to wash glass and a ride.
biggest teaching challenges ev- the motherhood window, over- assist the designers. "Others As for O'Neil Ford, Ms. La-
Highland Park PA f_31 a er—director of chapel art pro- looking the nave is dedicated to said `Oh, boy!' An important Selle recalled he came to the
jects for the chapel, all of it to the ideal woman. projects'," she said smiling. construction site frequently
Follow signs be done by TSCW art students. They also carried the work Now 91, Ms. LaSelle splits from his Dallas office. "He was
Construction began in 1938 through the painting and firing her time between Denton and always interested in the project
and was completed in 1941. of the glass. They carved the Cape Cod where she continues and what we were doing," she
EXISTING STRUCTURES DESIGNED BY O'NEIL FORD "We started in September of pews, laid the mosaic tile inlay, to paint and do Shows. She's said. "By the time we finished
1938 and knew by December fashioned the light fixtures, not difficult to miss around the we had done 14 projects in-
1.Denton Municipal Building 8.The Gazebo what we wanted," she recalled. wove the carpet for the nave, TWU campus either. The day stead of the original two but he
2.Denton Civic Center U.N.T. Cam "The Project started small but designed and made the mas- we met she was covered in a never said he didn't like any-
Pus grew a great deal as the girls sive Honduras mahogany front loose-fitting white pants outfit, thing we were doing.
3.Emily Fowler Public Library 9. 220 Marietta St. came up with new ideas."
.Little Chapel in the Woods- 10.2280 West Oak St. A core group of 20 to 35
T.W.U. Campus 11. Selwyn School Complex young women in their late • WE CREATE - a 5. 1819 N. Bell 12.1712 Highland Park teens and early twenties de- , t-3s & teat 3040 31&M830
signed the 10 huge stained- FANTASY .tom tmw boomis *�
6.Fairhaven Retirement Home 13.1408 Country Club Rd., �� t�f�
7.First Christian Church Argyle glass windows depicting the
1203 N.Fulton theme, "Woman Ministering to FACES® FREE WILLY ♦ (PG)*.
Human Needs." It was dedi- 11:25 1:55 4:40 7:10 9:40
Graphic by Mike Cochran and Mary Martinets Bated to women in nursing, YOUR COMPLETE POETIC JUSTICE ♦ (R)*
SESSION INCLUDES: 11:55 2:35 5:15 7:55 10:35
FRIDAY • •A glamorous, CONEHEADS ♦ (PG)*
��► q S complimentary makeover 12:00 2:40 5:10 7:30 9:55
S COUSINS and hairstyling ROBINHOOD:MEN IN TIGHTS♦(PG-13)*
• Four exciting wardrobe 11:20 2:05 4:50 7:4010:30
and accessory pose changes IN THE LINE OF FIRE (R)THX
„' • A tun
When two cousins by marriage discover photo session
11:10 2:15 5:05 8:00 10:45sion video ♦ (R)
FIRM
• that their spouses are having an affair with •Instant viewing of your THE 11M5 2:45 7:00 10:25
each other,revenge is very sweet.Starring color proofs
Ted Danson and Isabella Rossellini. •Portraits back in JURASSIC PARK ♦ (PG-13)
about a week 11:00 1:45 4:30 7:15 10:00
FRIDAY AT 7 PM \ RISING SUN (R)THX*
••. CHANNEL 19 _ .>> . 11:15 2:00 4:55 7:45 10:40
-� ♦ + Golden Triangle Mall ROOKIE OF THE YEAR ♦ (PG),
" • - \ + 382-6077 11:35 2:10 4:35 7:05 9:35
vim SLEEPLESS IN SEATTLE ♦ (PG)
Q.�[]I W, Your Complete11:40 2:20 4:45 7:25 10:05
�' � � i 11:50 2:25 5:20 7:50 10:20 ANOTHER STAKEOUT♦(PG-13)*
Friends Don't LetTHIS WEEK I HOCUS POCUS ♦ (PG)*
Friends ' SAMMONS COMMUNICATIONS Call fortanappoortfaits adtmenttodayl 11:45 2:30 5:00 7:20 9:45
566�2901 . �` Satisfaction sevnclaysanteaed. S� U�' �65Tl,Cr� E
Drive Drunknseven a s s week. / 9 / S
t
MINUTES
HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION
May 10, 1993
The regular meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission of the City of Denton was held
at 5:00 p.m. in the Civil Defense Room of the Municipal Building located at
215 E. McKinney Street, on Monday, May 10, 1993.
Present: Judith Abbott, Joe Bailey, W.A. Barker, Elinor Caldwell, Rita Holcomb,
Mary McCain, and George Spuller
Absent: Liz Bays and Judy Cole
Present from Staff: Frank Robbins, Executive Director for Planning and Development;
and Donna Baker, Planning Technician
Others Present: Mike Cochran
I. Consider the minutes of the regular meeting of April 12, 1993.
It was moved by Mr. Spuller, seconded by Mr. Barker and unanimously carried
(6-0) to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of April 12, 1993.
Ms. Holcomb did not vote.
II. Consider the wording for the O'Neil Ford Civic Complex Heritage Marker.
Mr. Cochran stated the O'Neil Ford Committee, which Liz Bays is appointed to,
has scheduled July 31,1993 as the date for the O'Neil Ford Ceremony. In honor
of O'Neil Ford the followingwordinghas been created for a historic marker that
will be unveiled the day of the ceremony:
O'NEIL FORD CIVIC COMPLEX
O'Neil Ford, Prominent Texas Architect, was born in Pink Hill, Texas in 1905
and moved to Denton at the age of 12. He graduated from Denton High School
and attended North Texas State Teachers College, now the University of North
Texas.
Ford designed his first residence, the Mary Marshall House, here in 1929. In
1939, Ford earned national prominence with the completion of the Little Chapel
in the Woods on the Texas Woman's University Campus.
Among Ford's many contributions to the architecture of Denton are the buildings
of the Civic Center Complex. The Civic Center was built in 1966. The City Hall,
built in 1967, displays many popular Ford themes, including doors carved by his
brother, Lynn Ford, ceramic light fixtures, and saltillo tile floors. Ford and his
firm designed additions to the Emily Fowler Public Library in 1969 and 1980.
Ford credited his pursuit of the creative life to his fascination with the Denton
County Courthouse. "I used to just stand there, wondering how they ever got it
Historic Landmark Commission
Minutes of May 10, 1993
Page 2 of 3
. . . (built), I was in Denton just the other day . . . so I went over to look at the
courthouse again and still don't know how they ever did that blasted, blessed
thing."
O'Neil Ford died on July 20, 1982, in San Antonio, Texas.
Dedicated the O'Neil Ford Civic Complex on July 31, 1993.
Ms. McCain asked what all was included in the O'Neil Ford Civic Complex.
Mr. Cochran stated that it would include the Civic Center, City Hall, Senior
Center, Library, and all city owned buildings in the area. Mr. Cochran added that
the City Council has already titled all of the buildings as the O'Neil Ford Civic
Complex.
Mr. Cochran stated that someone earlier had a question as to whether the Little
Chapel in the Woods should be hyphenated. He said he would check and if it
should be hyphenated he would change it accordingly.
Ms. McCain stated that she did not understand the last line and felt that since it
was not a sentence, it was not very clear.
Ms. Abbott suggested changing the last sentence to "The O'Neil Ford Civic
Complex dedicated on July 31, 1993".
Mr. Bailey suggested adding that the dedication was made by the Denton City
Council. The Commission agreed.
Mr. Barker moved to approve the wording, as amended. It was seconded by
Mr. Spuller and unanimously carried (6-0). Ms. Holcomb did not vote.
III. Receive reports regarding:
a) O'Neil Ford Celebration Ceremony
Ms. Abbott stated that the date of the O'Neil Ford Ceremony has been
changed and is rescheduled from July 24, 1993 to July 31, 1993 as stated
earlier.
Mr. Cochran stated that the Denton Record Chronicle has agreed to take
photographs for free. In addition, the ceremony will include having a
representative from the O'Neil firm present as well as a self guided tour
from 2:00 - 5:00 p.m. The opening ceremony will be on Friday,
Historic Landmark Commission
Minutes of May 10, 1993
Page 3 of 3
July 30, 1993withthe dedication at 10:00a.m. on Saturday,July 31, 1993.
Mr. Cochran said that he felt Ms. Bays has been an asset to the Committee
and thanked the Commission for her help.
b) Preservation Plan
Ms. Abbott stated the drawingsfor the Preservation Plan are complete. She
thanked Ms. McCain for an excellent job.
Ms. McCain stated that Elizabeth McMath also provided help in the
drawings.
The Commissioners looked at some of the drawings and expressed their
appreciation for the work involved.
IV. Future Agenda Items.
Ms. Abbott stated that the Commission may want to discuss in the future some
alternatives for raising money for the historic inventory.
Mr. Bailey moved to adjourn the meeting at 5:35 p.m. It was seconded by
Mr. Barker and unanimously carried (7-0).
CITY of DENTON, TEXAS MUNICIPAL BUILDING / DENTON, TEXAS 76201 / TELEPHONE(817) 566-8307
Office of the City Manager
March 23, 1993
Mike Cochran
610 West Oak Street
Denton, Texas 76201
Dear Mike:
Thank you for your letter regarding your concerns with the Historic
Landmark Commission responsibilities. I want to assure you that
the City of Denton recognizes the efforts of the Historic Landmark
Commission in historic preservation and the many benefits it
provides to the community.
Because you specifically mentioned the Civic Center Pool
renovation, I wanted you to be aware of the history of the project.
Last June, the City Council instructed the Parks and Recreation
Department to proceed with renovation of the pool . There was a
strong concern that the pool was not providing an adequate standard
of service to the community, from both a functional and aesthetic
perspective. In its twenty-eight years of public use, the cedar
fencing and trellis had deteriorated significantly and the aging
plumbing system needed replacement. In addition, the size of the
office and bathhouse was no longer adequate for current user loads .
Because the City Council did not want to disrupt the swimming
season, the Parks Department was also directed to complete the
project prior to the opening of the pool season on Memorial Day
weekend of this year.
While HLC does not have regulatory authority outside historic
districts or landmarks, the Council did take into account the
integrity of Ford's great work. After Council 's initial review of
the project, Council Members asked staff to reconsider some of the
architectural elements of the project. In response, the projects
was modified to more closely resemble O'Neil Ford's architectural
style. The amphitheater-like berm, that is mentioned in the
catalog of Ford' s work, will remain, along with the bold ceramic
light fixtures and the trellis covered deck area. The major
departure from the original pool will, of course, be the new
bathhouse/concession and office building. The size of these
structures had to be increased to meet current standards and codes
for public pool support facilities . However, the brick selected
Mike Cochran
March 23, 1993
Page 2
for the building will match that which Ford used at City Hall and
the Civic Center.
I agree completely that it is appropriate for the HLC to begin the
process to designate the O'Neil Ford Civic Complex as a Historic
Landmark District based on the criteria you cited in your letter.
Staff could begin exploring with HLC the type of HLC review and for
what buildings such review should be made. Accordingly, I have
asked the Parks and Recreation Director and the Planning Director
to report to HLC concerning your letter.
Again, thank you for bringing your concerns regarding this issue to
my attention.
Sincer y,
G�
Llo d V. Harrell
City Manager
LVH:bw
AMM00278
cc: Mayor and Members of the City Council
Jim Englebrecht, Planning and Zoning Commission
Judith Abbott, Historic Landmark Commission
Frank Robbins, Executive Director for Planning
Rich Dlugas, Director of Parks and Recreation
MAR 10 1993
C1TY 'F iiN ON
610 Warr OAx STmw
DmToN, 762OI
March 8, 1993 "Y:, ..};
Lloyd Harrell
i
City Manager Y
City of Denton
215 E. McKinney
Dear Lloyd,
I have recently become aware of a problem concerning the
responsibilities of the Historic Landmark Commission that I
think needs your attention.
As you know, the city has begun preparations for a
ceremony to honor the naming of the O'Neill Ford Government `
Center. This is part of a movement to rekindle awareness of
the importance of Ford in Denton and help establish for
public record the uniqueness of our community.
Ironically, while preparations are, underway to honor
this native son, the City of Denton has just destroyed one
excellent example of his work at the swimming pool. This
of Ford's work.
Althou§h it is too late to bring back the swimming pool
complex, the lapse in procedure that allowed this to happen
without any form of public review (through the Landmark
Commission) , is unforgivable. I believe that steps must be
taken to insure that public landmarks are treated less
cavalierly in the future.
It is clearly stated in the Historic Landmark Ordinance
80-30 that itIis a matter of public policy that 'preservation
and use of historic landmarks is a public necessity. . . " It
further states that the Landmark Ordinance exists to 'protect
1
Uj
From: Judith P. Abbott, Attorney at Law
100 W. Oak, Suite 310
Denton, Texas 76201
(817) 387-7557
FAX (817) 566-1101
To: Jane Biles , Preservation Officer
City of Denton
100 W. Oak St.
Denton, Texas
July 13 , 1993
Dear Jane,
As part of the planning for presentation of an O'Neil Ford
Government Complex Historic District, we need to consider the
inclusion of the Women' s Club Building in that District.
Please find out who is the official keeper of the ground
lease entered into by the City and the Federated Women' s Club at
some point in the last 1920s .
If you need any additional information, please don' t
hesitate to contact me.
Sincerely,
)Wu
Judith Abbott
CITY of DENTON, TEXAS 215 E. WKINNEY/DENTON, TEXAS 76201 /TELEPHONE(817)566-8200
October 5 , 1993
TO: Members of the Historic Landmark Commission
FROM: Jane Biles , Preservation Officer
RE: Options for O'Neil Ford Historic District
At our October 11 meeting , please be prepared to discuss the pros
and cons of the following options concerning the proposed O'Neil
Ford Historic District :
1 . Status Quo
2 . Informal Review -- HLC authority only by policy and practice,
not by ordinance .
3 . Designating entire area as a district .
4. Designating part of the area as a district .
5 . Designating two or three buildings as landmarks :
a. Municipal Building
b. Library
C . Women' s Building
Reasoning : O'Neil Ford was dissatisfied with the final
construction of the Civic Center; he didn' t design the Senior
Center; the pool bath house has been demolished.
\ J
CITY
\ POOt
1 Y►-7MEN'� -
'ILNNC
Ii
W
CONGRESS
s FUTURE
EX PANS iON
SENIOR
CITIZENS
/ 6LGG
I /
pRA+NAGf � � � CNIC
CENTER 1
0
^iTY HALL
C9 Ll
COUNTY D
JAIL
Q
O 0
LI 1 (_l
MCK1NNEY
i
= /0
MINUTES
Historic Landmark Commission
October 11, 1993
The regular meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission of the City of Denton was held at 5:00 p.m.
in the Civil Defense Room of the Municipal Building located at 215 E. McKinney Street on Monday,
October 11, 1993.
Present: Judith Abbott, Rita Holcomb, Bullitt Lowry, Mary McCain, Mark Merki, Kenneth Morgan,
and Alan Smart
Absent: Suzanne Byron and Judy Cole
Present from Staff: Frank Robbins, Executive Director of Planning and Development; Jane Biles,
Preservation Officer; and Donna Baker, Planning Technician
Others Present: Councilmem ber Brock
Chairperson Abbott called the meeting to order.
I. Consider approval of the minutes of the special called meeting of September 3, 1993 and
the regular meeting of September 13, 1993.
Mr. Lowry moved to approve the minutes of the special called meeting of
September 3, 1993. It was seconded by Ms. Holcomb and unanimously approved (7-0).
Mr. Lowry moved to approve the minutes of the regular meeting of September 13, 1993.
It was seconded by Ms. Holcomb and unanimously approved (7-0).
II. Discuss options concerning the proposed O'Neil Ford Historic District.
Mr. Robbins reported to the Commission that there were five options available regarding the
proposed O'Neil Ford Historic District. The five options were:
Option One: Use the existing system where the City Council decides in public and no
criteria is used.
Option Two: Historic Landmark Commission informal review. Council decides in public.
Historic Landmark Commission comments to staff and/or Council. Ad hoc
and/or individual criteria.
Option Three: Designation to include City Hall, Library and Womans Building.
Option Four: Designation to include City Hall, Civic Center, Park, Swimming Pool,
Womans Building and Library.
Option Five: Create a district for part of the area only.
Ms. Abbott stated that she felt that people were either in favor or opposed to preservation.
Historic Landmark Commission
Minutes of October 11, 1993
Page 2 of 2
Mr. Lowry stated that he liked option four and added that he felt it was the least restrictive.
He added that he felt a subcommittee should draft an ordinance for the Council to look at
prior to deciding.
Mr. Lowry moved to have the Chairwoman elect a subcommittee to draft the criteria to be
used for the ordinance to designate the whole area. It was seconded by Ms. Holcomb and
unanimously carried (7-0).
III. Discuss Preservation Plan.
Ms. Biles stated that in the Commissioners backup was the draft Preservation Plan.
Ms. Biles reported to the Commission the major changes to the plan.
The Commissioners agreed to the draft plan and asked that staff proceed with a final copy.
Ms. Abbott left the meeting.
IV. Future Agenda Items.
Ms. Holcomb stated that she felt the Commission should capitalize from Ms. McCain's
artwork for the Preservation Plan. She suggested possibly calendars and notepads.
Ms. Holcomb moved to adjourn the meeting at 6:21 p.m. It was seconded by Ms. McCain
and unanimously carried (6-0).
DATE : August 17 , 1993
CITY COUNCIL REPORT FORMAT
TO: Mayor and Members of the City Council
FROM : Lloyd V. Harrell , City Manager
SUBJECT: Historic designation of O' Neil Ford Civic Complex
RECOMMENDATION: Historic Landmark Commission recommends
approval#
SUMMARY: The Historic Landmark Commission has requested that the
City Council consider directing the Landmark Commission
to seek designating the O' Neil Ford Civic Complex as a
Historic District . In the Historic Landmark Preservation
and Historic District s ordinance , Sec . 35-215 ,
"Designation of Landmarks . " delineates the criteria the
City Council should consider in designating historical
properties . The O' Neil Ford Civic Complex meets several
of the thirteen criteria established by the ordinance ,
most particularly:
( 4 ) Identification as the work of an architect or
master builder whose individual work has
influenced the development of the city.
If the Council feels that the O'Neil Ford Civic Complex
qualifies and should be designated as a local Historic
District , the Council needs to act as the applicant and
direct the Landmark Commission to proceed with the
application process on the Council ' s behalf . Designating
the property as a Historic District would make any
exterior changes in the district subject to Landmark
Commission review with appeal to the City Council .
Specific design guidelines for the district would be
established as part of the designation process . The City
already owns two locally designated properties : the
Police Station at 221 N . Elm and the Center for the
Visual Arts at 407 S . Bell .
BACKGROUND: O'Neil Ford is arguable the most prominent
architect to have come from Texas . In his long and
distinguished career, he achieved both popular and
critical success , yet retained a strong life link
to his hometown of Denton. Fifteen of his
structures survive still in Denton. The City
Council has made an effort to recognize and promote
that asset by partially funding , through the
Historic Landmark Commission and the Certified
Local Governments program, a catalogue of the works
of O' Neil Ford . Also , in July 1992 , the Council
passed a resolution designating the Ford-designed
municipal buildings as the "O'Neil Ford Civic.
Complex" , and on July 31 , 1993 , officially
dedicated and renamed the property in Ford ' s honor.
Preservation and promotion of cultural assets is
also a strategic issue for the City: "In order to
be known as a unique and special city in the
metroplex. . . promote unique architecture ( new as
well as existing . "
PROGRAMS, DEPARTMENTS, OR GROUPS AFFECTED:
Historic Landmark Commission
Building Operations
Parks and Recreation
Planning and Development
FISCAL IMPACT: None
Respectfully submitted:
)ared bN
Lloyd V. Harrell
City Manager
aia Bi es , anager
N in Stre Program
'reservation Officer
Approved:
Frank Z . Robbin AICP
Executive Director
Planning and Development
From: Judith P . Abbott , Attorney at Law
100 W. Oak, Suite 310
Denton, Texas 76201
(817) 387-7557
FAX (817 ) 566-1101
To: Mayor Bob Castleberry
City Hall
Denton, Texas
July 6 , 1993
--- --- ------ --- --- ----------------------------------------------
Dear Mayor,
The Landmark Commission welcomes the opportunity to come and
discuss the possibility of the creation of an Historic District
for the O'Neil Ford Government Complex: . The Commission has
suggested that we be put on the agenda of one of the Council Work
Sessions . That seems to be a reasonable place for us to start .
If you have any questions or if you feel that another approach
might be more appropriate, please don' t hesitate to contact me.
Si�y,
—uudith Abbo t
ownership appears on the last approved city tax roll. ►pis property for city fazes as the
fOrd. No. 80-30, § 1(App. B, Art. 28A, § 28A-16), 4-1.80)
Fin
35.215. Designation of landmarks.
) The city council may designate buildings, structures, sites, districts, areas and lands
city as historic landmarks and define, amend and delineate the boundaries thereof. The
suffim "H" shall indicate the zoning designation of those buildings,
areas and lands which the city council designates structures, sites,districts,
as historic landmarks. Such designation �
shall be in addition to any other use designation established in this chapter. The zoning map
shall reflect the designation of an historic landmark by the letter s as a
use designation established under this chapter. " sum to any other
i b) In making the designations as set forth in subsection(a)of this section,the city council
shall consider but shall not be limited to one (1) or more of the following criteria;
(1) Character, interest or value as part of the development, heritage or cultural charac-
teristics of the city, state or the United States;
(2) Recognition as a recorded state historic landmark, a national historic landmark or
entered into the National Register of Historic Places;
(3) Embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type or specimen;
(4) Identification as the work of an architect or master builder whose individual work has
influenced the development of the city;
(5) Embodiment of elements of architectural design, detail, materials or craftsmanship
which represent a significant architectural innovation;
(6) Relationship to other distinctive buildings, sites or areas which are eligib
pres-
ervation accordingto a plan le for P based on architectural, historic or cultural motif;
(7) Portrayal of the environment of a group of people in an area of history characterized
by a distinctive architectural style;
ZONING § 35-218
(8) Archaeological value in that it has produced or can be expected
affecting theories of historic or prehistoric interest; to Produce data
(9) Exemplification of the cultural, economic, social, ethnic or historical heritage of the
city, state or United States;
(10) Location as the site of a significant historic event;
(11) Identification with a person who significantly contributed to the culture and devel-
opment of the city, state or United States;
(12) A building or structure that because of its location has become of value to a neigh-
borhood, community area or the city;
(13) Value as an aspect of community sentiment or public pride.
(Ord. No. 80-30, § 1(App. B, Art. 28A., §§ 28A-3, 28A-4), 4-1-80)
Sec. 35-216. Hearings.
(a) The city planning and zoning commission shall hold public hearings as provided for in
V.T,C,A., I.,ocal Government Code § 211.007 to consider Pnv
r1111a; to the property.
()rd No. 80-30, § 1(App. $, Art. 28A, § 28A-14(d)), 4-1.80)
tivc. 35.255. Criteria for designation of historic districts.
In evaluating applications for historic districts, the historic landmark commission shall
Insider section 35-215 and section 35.233. If the landmark commission recommends the
_f ablishment of an historic district, it shall cause to be prepared an historic district designa-
ion ordinance which shall contain, but not be limited to, the following:
U) A statement of purpose setting forth the commission's reasons for recommending
designation of the district;
(2) A legal description of the boundaries of the district;.
(3) Maps, charts and photographs of the buildings, structures, sites, areas or lands lo-
cated within the district;
2554
ZONING § 35-256
grindings that support the, criteria required in sections 35-215 and 35-233, if appli-
11111ble, that establishes the particular importance or value of the district;
Tiecommendations for the protection and preservation of the district referred to as the
district preservation plan.
u n-+- 2RA-_$ 28A-14(0), 4.1-80)
buiIdnam.r
RESOLUTION NO.
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF DENTON, TEXAS, FORMALLY ADOPTING NAMES
FOR CERTAIN CITY FACILITIES; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
WHEREAS, the City of Denton will soon be in the process of
expanding and renovating its facilities; and
WHEREAS , in order to maintain an orderly flow of business and
to better accommodate citizens using City facilities, a committee
of the City Council has studied the issue and submitted recommenda-
t-..ions to the City Council for the designation of names for certain
City facilities, and the Council wish to accept same; NOW, THERE-
FORE,
T11E CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DENTON HEREBY RESOLVES :
SECTION I . That area encompassing the Civic Center Park which
i.s bounded by Withers Street on the north, Bell Avenue on the east,
14cKinney Street on the south and Austin and Oakland Streets on the
west shall be known as the "O'Neil Ford Civic Complex. " The fol-
lowing buildings shall be located within the O'Neil Ford Civic
complex: Emily Fowler Library, Denton Senior Center, Civic Center
Pool , Civic/Convention Center and City Hall .
SECTION II . That those facilities located at 601 East Hickory
and 604 East Hickory, formerly owned by Moore Business Forms, shall
be known as the "Denton Municipal Complex. "
SECTION III. That facility located at 221 North Elm Street
shall be known as "City Hall West. "
SECTION IV. That this resolution shall become effective
.immediately upon its passage and approval .
PASSED AND APPROVED this the(j' /,Q ' day of , 1992 .
BOB CASTLEBERRY, MAYO
ATTEST:
J ENNIFER WALTERS, CITY SECRETARY
BY: '`
CITY OF DENTON
CITY COUNCIL AGENDA REQUEST FORM
THIS FORM IS TO BE SUBMITTED BY NOON OF THE MONDAY OF THE WEEK
PRIOR TO THE REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING.
DATE OF CITY COUNCIL MEETING: August 17, 1993 _
REQUESTING DEPARTMENT/
INDIVIDUAL/EXTENSION: Planning Dept./ Jane Biles/ ext. 8350
ITEMS TO BE PLACED ON AGENDA:
1. Word item exactly as it is to be placed on agenda. Include any
Advisory Board recommendation.
2. List backup materials which will be provided (must be
submitted no later than 5: 00 p.m. Wednesday, prior to the
Council meeting) .
-------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Discuss initiating the designation of the O'Neil Ford Civic
Complex as a Historic District and give staff directions.
2 . Letter of request from Judith Abbott, Chairman of the Historic
Landmark commission.
Criteria for designating historic landmarks and historic
districts.
Resolution naming "O'Neil Ford Civic Complex. "
AXX00061
O'Neil Ford Civic Complex
Site Location
lzwr� A
Mimi
jj
0 111MIl _
r�llw� I nn�r
i ' CC ■
•
l 'EPEE ww--v
�r -
1=7,
7
�!I ■ ..IYic;
�t f-- I IKE"'
F",
=mom
-�'
N 0 90 180 360
SITE �, F I Feet
s d
I]
Parcels
0
DENTON
Roads Development Services•GIS
Dale:3/24/2017
11The y of Denton has prepared maps for departmental use.These are not official maps of the City of Denton and should not be used for le al,endgineerinq or surve ing purposes but rather for reference purposes.These maps are the properly of
the Cof Denton and have been made avai able to the public based on the Public Information Acl.The Cily of,Denton makes every efforl�o pro uce and publish tie most current and accurate information possible.No warranties,expressed or
impliCR are provided for the data herein,its use,or its interpretation.Utilization of this map indicates understanding and acceptance of this statement.
Item 3E
Staff Report
&IMMM
Historic Property of the Month (HPM) Procedure
OHistoric Landmark Commission
DENTON April 10, 2017
REQUEST:
Consider approval of the procedures for awarding Historic Property of the Month Awards.
BACKGROUND:
In 2016 the City began an informal program of awarding Historic Property of the Month Awards.
During the January 9, 2017, Historic Landmark Commission (HLC) meeting, staff recommended
and the Commission concurred that a formal procedure for selecting the Historic Property of the
Month be established.
CONSIDERATIONS:
The following is proposed:
PURPOSE:
The purpose of the award is to formally recognize the good care and work community
members have taken with historic properties throughout Denton. Secondarily, it is to
encourage quality preservation, build relationships with property owners and elevate the
public's awareness of historic preservation in Denton.
NOMINATIONS:
Nominations for the Historic Property of the Month Award will be made to the Planning
Division, Department of Development Services by phone at (940) 349-8382, via email to
roman.mcallen&cityofdenton.com,or in person at 215 West Hickory Street. Only an address
is required for nominations. A nominee may supply more information about a property if
they wish. Owners will then be contacted to receive their written permission to nominate their
property and if they would like to have their property featured on DTV's Preservation Denton
program.
SELECTION:
If there are more than 3 properties nominated prior to a HLC meeting,the Planning Division
staff shall determine the top three properties to put forward for that meeting. The top three
properties will be chosen based on:
• Evidence of good maintenance of the structure
• Uniqueness of the property
• Maintenance of the site
The historic preservation officer shall bring three nominations to the HLC at a time.
AWARDS:
The Planning Division will present a Historic Property of the Month Award every three
months. Those not selected during a particular Historic Landmark Commission meeting shall
be included in the next 2 consecutive meetings in which a Historic Property of the Month is
awarded.
NOTIFICATIONS:
The Planning Division shall notify the owners to let them know they have been selected by
phone. In addition,the owners will receive a certificate from the Planning Division and staff
will post a Historic Preservation of the Month sign in their yard.
COMPREHENSIVE PLAN:
The Community Character and Urban Design Element of the Plan calls for promoting the character
of Denton through community interaction (DP2030 Overview). This Element states that
preservation of historic resources is a top priority for the Denton community (DP2030 104) and
recommends support of maintenance of areas having cultural significance (DP2030 4.5.2).
Further, Element 7 calls for taking proactive measures to encourage neighborhood conservation
DP2030 203).
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of the procedures as presented in this report.
OPTIONS:
1. Approve as presented
2. Approve with conditions
3. Deny item
4. Table item
ATTACHMENTS:
• PDF—Unsolicited emails supporting the program
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report
Work Session Item 1
Page 2 of 2
McAllen, Roman
From:
Sent: Monday, February 06, 2017 7:58 AM
To: McAllen, Roman
Subject: More Preservation Denton!!
Good morning!
I'm a resident here in the City of Denton and an aspiring home owner. I love driving around town, or browsing
Google Maps, and checking out all the unique houses and buildings within our city.
I just discovered your episodes of Preservation Denton on the City of Denton's Youtube channel and I love
them!
Please! You have to post more videos! It is quite a treat not only seeing the houses/buildings featured but
mostly hearing you describe and explain historical features and significance.
You're amazing and your videos are amazing! Keep up the great work!
Best regards,
i
McAllen, Roman
From: Nathan Miller
Sent: Tuesday, October 11, 2016 5:58 PM
To: McAllen, Roman
Subject: Re: Preservation Denton video
Roman thank you so much!! Was a pleasure meeting you and I had fun as well. Have a great week!
Nathan Miller
On Oct 11, 2016, at 5:11 PM, McAllen, Roman <Roman.McAllen @citvofdenton.com>wrote:
Nathan,
I hope you like this video and thank you for being such a good sport about it!
Also,your home might qualify for the program from the state, attached. - roman
Council Members:
This week DTV launched a new program, Preservation Denton, to highlight historic homes, buildings,
and public spaces in Denton. I hope you enjoy the first episode, linked below:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmL3Liicm0s&feature=Voutu.be
Best,
Alison Ream
Administrative Services Manager
City of Denton
(940) 349-8310
www.citvofdenton.com
<THC HTCP Conference Flyer Reduced.pdf5
i
McAllen, Roman
From: Cabrales, John J.
Sent: Wednesday, October 12, 2016 12:15 PM
To: Baker, Lindsey N.; Rogers, Jessica A; McAllen, Roman; Mauladad, Munal; Fortune,Jon E.
Subject: FW: Preservation Denton video
This is a really neat program. I am wondering if this might be a cold candidate submission for a TML Municipal
Excellence Award next year?
John Cabrales Jr
City of Denton
Assistant City Manager
940-349-8509 (work)
940-465-4846 (mobile)
www.cityofdenton.com
From: Matthews, Billy H.
Sent:Tuesday, October 11, 2016 9:19 AM
To:Stengel, Robby J <Robby.Stengel@cityofdenton.com>; McGinnis, Kevin D. <Kevin.McGinnis@cityofdenton.com>;
Harmon,Justin D<Justin.Harmon@cityofdenton.com>; Plinck, Brian R<Brian.Plinck@cityofdenton.com>; Scott,Adam
<Adam.Scott@cityofdenton.com>; Karrenbrock, Caleb P<Caleb.Karrenbrock@cityofdenton.com>
Cc: Baker, Lindsey N. <Lindsey.Baker@cityofdenton.com>; Cabrales,John J. <John.Ca bra les@cityofdenton.com>
Subject: Preservation Denton video
The link below is to episode 1 of DTV's new program - Preservation Denton. Hosted by Roman McAllen, Preservation
Denton will highlight historical homes, buildings, characters, and preservation efforts in Denton.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmL3Li*cm0s&feature=youtu.be
Best,
Billy Matthews
City of Denton I DTV
O: (940) 349-7272
C: (940)465-0848
1
McAllen, Roman
From: Gregory, Dalton R
Sent: Wednesday, October 12, 2016 10:05 AM
To: Ream, Alison B
Cc: McAllen, Roman
Subject: Re: Preservation Denton video
Thanks for sharing the video and letting us know about this great new program. Good job all around.
Dalton Gregory
Denton City Council Member
At-Large Place 5
On Oct 11, 2016, at 11:11 AM, Ream,Alison B<Alison.Ream @citvofdenton.com>wrote:
Council Members:
This week DTV launched a new program, Preservation Denton,to highlight historic homes, buildings,
and public spaces in Denton. I hope you enjoy the first episode, linked below:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LmL3Li*cm0s&feature=youtu.be
Best,
Alison Ream
Administrative Services Manager
City of Denton
(940) 349-8310
www.citVofdenton.com
1
Item 4A
Planning Report
iT JC Historic Property of the Month
°Fv Historic Landmark Commission
DENTON April 10, 2017
REQUEST:
Receive a report, hold a discussion and select a Historic Property of the Month.
BACKGROUND:
The purpose of the Historic Property of the Month award is to formally recognize the good care and
work community members have taken with historic properties throughout Denton. The three
nominations for your consideration, in no particular order, represent quality preservation and should
be recognized for their uniqueness and for the property owner's continued maintenance.
A. 1902 North Bell Avenue— 1945 (Per HRS 1996)— ¢
Mid Century Ranch—original gable siding and steel casement 3
windows—upkeep
B. 1117 West Congress — 1930 (Per HRS 1996), 1912 Per
DCAD, 1940 per owner—Post War—Colonial Revival
Siding dates to 1940s—detailed paint—landscaping -upkeep
C. 607 E College — 1915 (Per HRS 1996) — Craftsman
Bungalow — survivor of TWU expansion — original a "
windows and siding -upkeep
Please note that property B and C were previously presented at the December 2016 HLC meeting
for consideration and were not selected.
Prepared By: Reviewed By:
Roman McAllen, Assoc. AIA, AICP Ron Menguita, AICP
Historic Preservation Officer Long Range Planning Administrator
Date: 03/20/2017 Date: 03/29/2017
Planning Report
COA16-0021
Page 2 of 2
Historic Landmark Commission Requests for Information
Note: This is a working draft of pending Historic Landmark Commission items and is subject to change without notice.
Request
Date
Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
Landmark the WPA stone lined canals Citizen August After meeting with the Engineering Department,
2016 it was determined that there is no immediate
lans to replace the canals.
December Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
Historic Preservation App Stevenson 2016 Staff is considering options for a surveying app
and an interactive tour app.
Conduct a value of redevelopment and utilization of the Historic Stevenson December Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
State Tax Credit 2016
Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
Design guidelines specific to development in a Historic District Riddle December Design Guidelines in a Historic District will be
2016 incorporated as part of the Historic Preservation
Plan Up date.
Create a Historic Tourism Overlay District Conte December Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
2016
Staff has prepared procedures for selecting
Formalize a process for the Historic Property of the Month Pulido December Historic Property of the Month. This item is
2016 schedule for the Commission to discuss during
the HLC April meeting.
December Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
Designate the Selwyn School as a Local Historic Landmark Riddle 2016 Staff will be seeking direction regarding this
request.
Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
Current incentives include the Downtown
List of Incentives Stevenson December Reinvestment Grant,property tax exemption for
2016 Historic Landmarks, and assistance from staff on
Historic Preservation Tax Credit Program
applications.
HLC Mission or Objective Stevenson December Staff to present at an upcoming HLC meeting.
2016
4/3/17 1