Texas cities suing over new law that cuts telecom fees, saying it won’t save you money 11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
Fort WorthStar-Telegram AMPACT2020
Fort Worth Star-Telegram s-
POLITICS&GOVERNMENT
Texas cities suing over new law that cuts telecom
fees, saying it won't save you money
BY TESSA WEINBERG
OCTOBER 28,2019 06:00 AM,UPDATED OCTOBER 28,2019 09:10 AM
%F f u f*
Railroad commissioner?County Court-at-Law judge?County tax assessor-collector?When you head to the
polls,know what the responsibilities are of the positions on your ballot.Here's a brief explainer on some of the
key elected positions in Texas BY LENA BLIETz
AUSTIN
Telecom providers expect to save millions of dollars thanks to a new state law that cuts fees.But a
coalition of nearly 5o Texas cities,who will be on the losing end of that revenue,worry those
discounts won't be passed on to their residents.
So they're suing.
For years,telecom providers paid two separate fees to run cable and phone lines through city-
owned strips of land,know as rights-of-way.Companies were required to pay both fees,even if it
took only one line to deliver the two services.
https://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 1/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
TOPARTICLES
�-
10TEmcn
All
VOTE AQU
Some Tarrant voters are having problems casting
ballots on Election Day
But a bill,authored by state Sen.Kelly Hancock,R-North Richland Hills,changed that practice,
allowing companies to pay only the higher of the two fees if cable and phone services are delivered
over the same line.
Explore where you live.
Subscribe for 12 FREE weeks of unlimited digital access.
SAVE NOW
Walt Baum,the president of the Texas Cable Association,said the legislation was simply meant to
bring the law up to date with current technology.
But Texas cities have joined forces and are suing the state in an attempt to stop the law from being
enforced.The lawsuit alleges the law—along with a 2017 law that was also authored by Hancock—
is unconstitutional,forcing cities to provide a gift to private companies.
"I consider it corporate welfare,"said Jimmy Stathatos,the town manager of Flower Mound,which
joined the lawsuit.
Fort Worth estimates$4 million to$5 million will be lost annually due to the law—a hefty portion
of at least$to million in revenue the city anticipates losing due to new state laws,including laws
that banned red light cameras and imposed a revenue cap on property taxes.
Local officials said they took a hit this legislative session—and a secret recording recently revealed
some lawmakers'desires for it to be"the worst session in the history of the legislature for cities and
counties."Meanwhile,the Texas Cable Association,which represents many of the state's cable
companies,including Charter Spectrum,one of the largest providers in Fort Worth,touted this
session as"a successful one."
"It didn't have anything to do with anything else,"Baum said of the new law.
LAWSUIT
The legal challenge of SB 1152,the bill authored by Hancock that cuts right-of-way fees,was tacked
onto a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of SB 1004,a sep r t ill passed m 2o17—that
was also authored by Hancock.
https://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.htmi 2/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
Since 2006,telecom providers—some who stand to potentially cut costs due to Hancock's bill—
have contributed over$200,000 to Hancock's campaign,according to the National Institute on
Money in Politics.Hancock has stressed that his constituents will see the savings themselves,and
previously said cities fighting the laws are"welcome to spend money on attorneys all they want."
Hancock,who isn't mentioned by name in the lawsuit,did not respond to a request for comment
Friday.His office maintains a policy of not commenting on pending litigation,Caity Jackson,a
spokeswoman for Hancock,said.
SB 1152 was amended onto the lawsuit on Aug.30—a day before the law went into effect—said
Austin Stevenson,an assistant city attorney for McAllen,which is leading the suit.
The lawsuit,filed in Travis County District Court,alleges that both laws are forcing cities to violate
articles of the Texas Constitution that prohibit the legislature from directing local municipalities to
make gifts or grants to a corporation.
It claims that SB 1152 does that by allowing a telecom provider to be exempt from paying two fees,
despite generating"two separate streams of income from its use of the city property."
"It's pretty clear under the law,that the value isn't determined by how many lines you're using,but
your revenues,"Stevenson said."And that's been established for decades in Texas."
The article of the Texas Constitution being cited stems from the 1800s,said Bennett Sandlin,the
executive director of the Texas Municipal League,which represents more than i,ioo cities.
"They didn't want the legislature forcing cities to give away their public land to attract railroads,
because that was a big deal,which town the railroads went through,"Sandlin said."It literally
prohibits the giving away of public property to make profit unless you get market value."
Sandlin said it's a similar concept,arguing that taxpayers'need to be reimbursed if private
companies are using public land in the same way homeowners would if a company was running
cable or phone lines through residents'backyards.
Supporters of the law have said that companies'savings will be passed on to residents once it
applies to payments starting in January 2020.Baum previously told the Star-Telegram that
residential customers may see reductions of$1 to$3 in their bills,and small businesses may see as
much as a couple hundred dollars a month.Meanwhile,telecom providers may save as much as
$16o million statewide,he said previously.
"Any hint that the customers are going to see a difference is complete smoke and mirrors
fabrication,"Stevenson said,noting that there's no language in the bill that requires those savings
to trickle down to customers.
When asked if telecom providers would be open to adding a provision to ensure that,Baum said he
did not want to speculate.
"I think most of the cable customers in this state who were paying both fees will see one of the fees
reduced when this goes into effect first part of next year,"Baum said.
SIGN UP FOR TX POLITICS,OUR WEEKLY NEWSLETTER OF
GOVERNMENT AND ELECTIONS NEWS.
1_.Ad
7_
Less city revenue means less resources for cities to provide essential services like police,fire and
more,Sandlin said.
"City revenue to some degree is a zero sum game.Cities aren't just trying to collect all they can.
They've got to provide a certain amount of services,"Sandlin said."And when you lose that
revenue from a person that's using public land,that should be of concern to citizens."
hftps://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 3/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
What's more,the law will not just hurt consumers,but smaller telecom providers,the lawsuit
claims,by giving an added advantage to larger companies who will pay less offering cable and
phone over one line,versus smaller companies that will pay in full offering one of the two services.
"It's like taking away the rent and overhead from one store and requiring the other one to pay full
price in a shopping center,"Stevenson said."They're going to be able to invest much more and
profit much more quickly."
Baum pushed back on that notion,noting that some satellite providers aren't paying any of these
fees.
CITIES ON JOINING
The addition of SB 1152 has brought the total number of cities and towns joining the litigation from
a little over 30 up to 48 so far.
"It's not surprising to see cities react more to loss of actual current revenue than hypothetical
revenue,"Sandlin said.
SB 1004,the original bill the lawsuit challenged,regulates how network nodes,or small cells,used
for wireless services can be implemented in right-of-ways,which was still a growing technology at
the time the bill was passed.
Dallas is the largest city named as a plaintiff,and El Paso was the most recent addition.El Paso
estimates it will lose about$2.7 million annually to the law,said Laura Cruz-Acosta,a
spokeswoman for the city.
Even smaller towns have joined the fight,with Flower Mound signing on.Stathatos,Flower
Mound's town manager,said SB 1152 was"the straw that broke the camel's back"that pushed them
to join.
"We thought,`We need to have a united front.'If not,what's going to be then next session?And
next session?They just keep pushing the envelope,"Stathatos said of lawmakers."It's having a
financial impact on our residents,and so we need to go to bat for them."
Stathatos said it's a"bitter pill to swallow"knowing the town will lose roughly$170,00o annually
to the law.
"Now our residents are having to subsidize a gift that they gave these companies,quite frankly,
because we're having to make up that money in our budget,"Stathatos said.
But some of the cities that stand to lose the most to the new law,have yet to add their names to the
lawsuit,including Fort Worth.
The$4 million to$5 million Fort Worth expects to lose is a small fraction of the ci 's$1.8 billion
budget for 2020.But in Fort Worth,where the median salary fora police officer is$74,152,that loss
would translate to the salaries of roughly 53 to 67 officers,for example.
Michelle Gutt,a spokeswoman for the city,said Fort worth is waiting on a final cost estimate from
McAllen's attorneys,who are leading the suit.
"We expect to submit a recommendation to City Council to adopt a resolution for us to join the
lawsuit once we have that information,"Gutt wrote in an email.
Houston pinned its potential losses as high as$27 million,more than any other city.Houston
Mayor Sylvester Turner even sent letters to Houston-area lawmakers and cable customers warning
of the bill's impact.
Bill Kelly,Houston's government relations director,told the Star-Telegram in April that the bill was
the city's"number one"measure it hoped to defeat.Kelly declined to comment last week as to why
the city has yet to join the lawsuit or if it has plans to file litigation of its own.
Stevenson said McAllen is in discussions with more cities about potentially joining.And while
there's no hard deadline,the January start date for when telecom providers can pay less,looms.
hftps://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 4/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
"The sooner the better when it comes to other cities joining,"Stevenson said.
RELATED STORIES FROM FORT WORTH STAR TELEGRAM
STATE-POLITICS TEXAS
Texas cities plan to sue the state over a law Lawmakers want to cut cable TV fees,but
that will slash telecom providers'fees cities say you won't see savings
JUNE 24,2019 6:00 AM APRIL 26,20191:25 PM
POLITICS-GOVERNMENT POLITICS-GOVERNMENT
House leaders`hate'Texas'cities and Texans will be asked to ban income taxes.
counties.`It's just infuriating,'FW mayor Why that brings fears of unintended
says consequences
OCTOBER 17,201910:51 AM OCTOBER 09,2019 6:00 AM
a Cha�cte�\
Telecom providers expect to save millions of dollars thanks to a new state law that cuts fees.But a
coalition of nearly 50 Texas cities,who will be on the losing end of that revenue,worry those
discounts won't be passed on to their residents.So they're suing.JEFF ROBERSON AP
t' TESSAWEINBERG V f , 817-807-3200
Tessa Weinberg is a state government for the Star-Telegram.Based in Austin,she covers all things policy and politics
with a focus on Tarrant County.She previously covered the Missouri legislature where her reporting prompted an
investigation by the Attorney General's office.A California native and graduate of the University of Missouri,she's
made her way across the U.S.and landed in Texas in May 2019.
FROM OUR ADVERTISING PARTNERS
hftps://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 5/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees Fort Worth Star-Telegram
1
1 '
•
Mainstream Actors Who Turned to the Adult Industry We Now Understand Why'Duck Dynasty'Family Has
Just
®Disappeared
- I
r
Meghan's Risque Outfit Was Just Too Scandalous for Why You Should Never Buy a Rotisserie Chicken From
the Royals Walmart
Clinton Accusers Speak Out After Ronan Farrow's Adult Film Star Jessica Jaymes Found Dead
Comments
hftps://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.htmi 6/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees Fort Worth Star-Telegram
Q
n
Trump's Bizarre Comment About Son Barron is Turning Death Toll Cimbs in Mexican Cartel Shootout by the
Heads Border
COMMENTS
VIDEOS
hftps://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 7/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
Impact 2020:5 voter groups presidential candidates need to win over
- - -� C-SPAN
House votes to approve impeachment inquiry rules
VIEW MORE VIDEO
TRENDING STORIES
23 prostitution arrests reported during weekend police operation at Fort Worth hotel
NOVEMBER 04,201911:18 AM
TCU quarterback Alex Delton leaves team;Duggan could play vs.Baylor,Patterson
says
NOVEMBER 05,201912:31 PM
Tuesday is Election Day in Texas.Here are a few things you need to know
NOVEMBER 05,20195.00 AM
What won and what lost in Tarrant County and Texas on Election Day
NOVEMBER 05,2019 7:05 PM
SPONSORED CONTENT
i
hftps://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 8/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
APPLE'S COMPLICATED HISTORY WITH TV
Dallas woman accused of selling 11-year-old for sex at hotels for months,police say
NOVEMBER 04,201911.45 AM
r
A 0 1
NATIONAL POLITICS
Erdogan: Turkey captures slain IS leader al-
Baghdadi's wife
BY SUZAN FRASER ASSOCIATED PRESS
NOVEMBER 06,201907:59 AM,UPDATED 1 HOUR 55 MINUTES AGO
V f u &
Turkish president says Turkey has captured wife of the slain leader of Islamic State group,al-Baghdadi.
https://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 9/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees I Fort Worth Star-Telegram
KEEP READING 4
Explore where you live. Subscribe for 12 FREE weeks of unlimited digital access.
#ReadLocal
MORE POLITICS&GOVERNMENT
3 4a
NATIONAL NATIONAL POLITICS NATIONAL POLITICS
Liberal Tucson,Arizona rejects plan to Walmart,Tesla settle lawsuit over fiery Johnson hit by Cabinet resignation as
be sanctuary city solar panels UK election kicks off
NOVEMBER 06,2019 2:47 AM NOVEMBER 06,2019 9:17 AM NOVEMBER 06,2019 9:15 AM
NATIONAL POLITICS NATIONAL POLITICS
Wisconsin Assembly to Colorado biologist gets
attempt first overrides in probation for selling
11 years bobcat pelts
SPONSORED CONTENT
Good Reasons to Go With a New
Oxygen Sensor
NOVEMBER 06,2019 9:21 AM NOVEMBER 06,2019 9:15 AM BY FORD MOTOR COMPANY
Take Us With You
Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in
the palm of your hand.
SUBSCRIPTIONS
Start a Subscription
Customer Service
eEdition
Vacation Hold
Pay Your Bill
Rewards
LEARN MORE
https://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.htmi 10/11
11/6/2019 Texas cities sue over law that reduces telecom provider fees Fort Worth Star-Telegram
About Us
Contact Us
Newsletters
News in Education
Archives
ADVERTISING
Information
Place a Classified
COPYRIGHT
COMMENTING POLICY
PRIVACY POLICY
TERMS OF SERVICE
https://www.star-telegram.com/news/politics-government/article236008523.html 11/11